学术性角膜与外眼病专科转诊中诊断错误的特征分析
该回顾性诊断准确性分析纳入2021年11月至2022年5月连续转诊至三级学术角膜门诊的118例新患者,诊断错误率为42%,其中51%的错误病例涉及诊断术语模糊(DA),DA与明确诊断错误(传统DE)均导致相似的诊治延迟,所有错误均源于病史采集或体格检查失败。
要点
- 转诊至学术角膜门诊的连续118例新患者中诊断错误率为42%,80%的转诊来自眼科医生。
- 诊断术语模糊(DA)占诊断错误病例的51%(25/49),其导致的诊治延迟与明确诊断错误(传统DE)相似。
- 所有诊断错误病例均源于病史采集或体格检查的失败,常见错误包括遗漏眼神经病理性疼痛及暴露性角膜病变。
核心结论
- 在转诊至学术角膜与外眼病专科门诊的病例中,诊断错误主要局限于病史采集或体格检查环节。
- 诊断语言模糊是诊断错误的重要类型,其导致成功治疗延迟的程度与明确误诊相同。
- 在眼科培训中处理认知偏差可能是预防错误及其对患者有害影响的可操作策略。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性诊断准确性和有效性分析。
- 纳入2021年11月至2022年5月连续转诊至三级学术角膜门诊的所有新患者,共分析118例患者的医疗记录。
- 提取转诊医生和接诊医生确定的诊断,对诊断为诊断错误的子集进一步分析模式、常见陷阱、使用诊断错误评估与研究(DEER)分类法分析错误原因、命名模糊的存在、疾病发生频率以及最终诊断和治疗的时间。
主要发现
- 诊断错误率为42%。
- 80%的病例由眼科医生转诊。
- 诊断术语模糊(DA)导致49例诊断错误病例中的25例(51%)。
- DA病例的诊断和治疗延迟与明确诊断错误(传统DE)病例相似。
- 误诊持续超过1年者:DA病例25例中5例,传统DE病例24例中1例;症状负担持续超过1年者:DA病例25例中10例,传统DE病例24例中9例。
关键数值与推荐
- 诊断错误率42%(49/118例)。
- 诊断术语模糊(DA)占诊断错误病例的51%(25/49例)。
- 误诊持续超过1年:DA病例25例中5例,传统DE病例24例中1例。
- 症状负担持续超过1年:DA病例25例中10例,传统DE病例24例中9例。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To systematically describe characteristics of diagnostic error in referrals to the ophthalmology subspecialty of corneal and external disease. DESIGN: Retrospective diagnostic accuracy and validity analysis. PARTICIPANTS: All consecutive new patient referrals to a tertiary care academic cornea clinic from November 2021 to May 2022. METHODS: We analyzed medical records of 118 patients to extract diagnoses determined by referring and referral providers. Among the subset identified as diagnostic error cases, we further analyzed patterns, common pitfalls, cause of error using the Diagnosis Error Evaluation and Research (DEER) Taxonomy, presence of naming ambiguity, frequency of disease occurrences, and time to final diagnosis and treatment. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Primary outcome measure was percentage of total cases with diagnostic error. Secondary outcome measures included frequencies of specific ophthalmologic conditions among several categories of diagnostic error (missed, wrong, or ambiguous), error type per the DEER Taxonomy, and time to diagnosis and treatment. RESULTS: Diagnostic error rate was 42%. Most (80%) cases were referred by ophthalmologists. Ambiguity in diagnostic terminology (DA) contributed to 25 of the 49 (51%) diagnostic error cases. DA cases suffered from delays in diagnosis and treatment similar to cases of frank diagnostic error (traditional DE). Misdiagnosis extended beyond a year in 5 of 25 DA cases and 1 of 24 traditional DE cases; symptomatic burden extended beyond a year in 10 of 25 DA cases and 9 of 24 traditional DE cases. Common diagnostic errors leading to ineffective treatment included: missing the diagnosis of ocular neuropathic pain despite absence of ocular surface disease and failing to identify exposure keratopathy, especially as a consequence of nocturnal lagophthalmos. All diagnostic error cases were caused by failures in history-taking or physical examination. CONCLUSIONS: Among referrals to an academic cornea and external disease practice, diagnostic error was predominantly localized to the history or physical examination. We identified ambiguous diagnostic language as an important type of diagnostic error and found that this leads to delay in successful therapy to the same extent as outright misdiagnosis. Addressing cognitive biases during ophthalmological training may be an actionable strategy to prevent error and harmful effects on patients.
引用
- Kao AH, Gilbert C, Safi M, et al. Characterizing Diagnostic Error in Referrals to an Academic Cornea and External Disease Practice. Am J Ophthalmol. 2025. PMID: 41067483. doi:10.1016/j.ajo.2025.10.004
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。