文献速递青光眼

评估青光眼手术失败的高眼压标准:对估计成功率和视野变化速率的影响

Evaluating High Intraocular Pressure Criteria for Failure in Glaucoma Surgery: Impact on Estimated Success and Visual Field Rates.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Ophthalmol · 2025-07-03

本文系统综述了青光眼手术结局研究中用作失败标准的高眼压阈值,并将这些标准应用于两个回顾性队列(小梁切除术934眼、深巩膜切除术1765眼)。发现21 mmHg标准的不同变体使5年成功率在小梁切除术为8.7%–74.0%、深巩膜切除术为22.1%–89.9%,标准间一致性仅为一般(κ=0.39和0.42)。基于眼压的分类不能很好地替代术后视野进展速率。

要点

  • 文献中高眼压失败标准高度异质,共识别144种标准。
  • 21 mmHg标准变体导致5年成功率在小梁切除术为8.7%–74.0%,深巩膜切除术为22.1%–89.9%。
  • 基于眼压的成功/失败分类与术后视野进展速率重叠大,替代性差。

核心结论

  • 当前文献中定义青光眼手术高眼压失败的标准高度异质。
  • 改变高眼压标准对青光眼手术成功率有很大影响,凸显需要标准化失败标准以便研究间一致解读和比较。
  • 基于眼压的分类不能很好地替代术后视野进展速率;长期视野变化速率提供更一致的主要结局指标,可纳入复合成功标准。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统文献综述,并将基于文献的高眼压失败标准应用于两个回顾性队列。
  • 小梁切除术队列934眼,深巩膜切除术队列1765眼;小梁切除术中位随访41.4个月,深巩膜切除术中位随访45.4个月。
  • 视野分析纳入小梁切除术队列中术后≥2年内有≥4次视野检查的患者。

主要发现

  • 从2503项初筛研究中纳入277项,识别出144种高眼压失败标准。
  • 21 mmHg标准的变体显示5年成功率:小梁切除术为8.7%至74.0%,深巩膜切除术为22.1%至89.9%。
  • 21 mmHg标准的中位Cohen's kappa显示一致性一般:小梁切除术为0.39,深巩膜切除术为0.42。
  • 339只小梁切除术眼符合视野分析条件;术后中位(四分位距)进展速率为-0.36(-0.09至-0.74)dB/年。
  • 由各种标准定义的失败组与成功组之间,进展速率分布大幅重叠。

关键数值与推荐

  • 失败定义为超过文献基于的高眼压阈值、光感丧失、低眼压修正手术或需要额外降眼压手术。
  • 成功率用Kaplan-Meier统计估计,标准间一致性用Cohen's kappa评估(5年时)。
  • 视野平均偏差进展速率用线性混合模型估计。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

PURPOSE: Review high intraocular pressure (IOP) thresholds used as failure criteria in glaucoma surgical outcome studies, evaluate their impact on success rates, and examine the relationship between surgical success criteria and visual field (VF) progression rates. DESIGN: Systematic literature review and application of high IOP failure criteria to 2 retrospective cohorts. PARTICIPANTS: Two cohorts of 934 and 1765 eyes underwent trabeculectomy and deep sclerectomy (DS), respectively, with a median follow-up of 41.4 months for trabeculectomy and 45.4 months for DS. Visual field analysis was conducted on patients in the trabeculectomy cohort with ≥4 VFs in ≥2 years post-surgery. METHODS: We applied literature-based high IOP failure criteria to the patient cohorts, defining failure as exceeding these IOP thresholds, loss of light perception, hypotony revision surgery, or need for additional IOP-lowering surgery. Success rates were estimated with Kaplan-Meier statistics, and Cohen's kappa statistic assessed the agreement among criteria in defining failure at 5 years. Linear mixed models estimated VF mean deviation (MD) progression rates based on success or failure status. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Kaplan-Meier success rates, Cohen's kappa, and MD progression rates. RESULTS: From 2503 initial studies, 277 were included, identifying 144 high IOP failure criteria. The 21-mmHg criterion variations showed success rates at 5 years ranging from 8.7% to 74.0% for trabeculectomy and 22.1% to 89.9% for DS. The median Cohen's kappa for 21-mmHg criteria indicated fair agreement (0.39 for trabeculectomy, 0.42 for DS). A subset of 339 trabeculectomy eyes were eligible for the VF analysis. Overall, the median (interquartile range) postoperative progression rate was -0.36 (-0.09 to -0.74) dB/year. Distributions of progression rates greatly overlapped between failure and success groups as defined by the various criteria. CONCLUSIONS: The criteria for defining high IOP failure in glaucoma surgery are highly heterogeneous in the current literature. Varying high IOP criteria has a large impact on glaucoma surgery success rates, highlighting the need for standardized failure criteria to enable consistent interpretation and comparison across studies. IOP-based classifications are poor surrogates for postoperative VF progression rates. Long-term visual field rates provide a more consistent primary outcome measure and may be incorporated into composite success criteria.

来源:Am J Ophthalmol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Rabiolo A, Triolo G, Servillo A, et al. Evaluating High Intraocular Pressure Criteria for Failure in Glaucoma Surgery: Impact on Estimated Success and Visual Field Rates. Am J Ophthalmol. 2025. PMID: 40617316. doi:10.1016/j.ajo.2025.05.054

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。