哪种检验最佳:传统与当代统计检验在白内障术后等效球镜预测误差分析中的评估
该研究比较了传统与当代统计检验在白内障术后等效球镜预测误差分析中的表现,纳入5个学术中心和2个私人诊所的7839只眼。研究发现WHWK.MAE、WHWK.SD、Eyetemis.MAE、WHWK.RMSAE和Dunn.MAE五种检验更为稳健,其中WHWK.MAE总体表现最佳,McNemar最差。
要点
- WHWK.MAE总体表现最佳,显著率42%,自洽指数0.39。
- McNemar总体表现最差,自洽指数仅0.09。
- Dunn.MAE在100眼亚组中不一致比最低(0.11),可能适用于样本量小于150眼。
核心结论
- 五种高性能检验产生显著结果的频率更高且自洽性更好,WHWK.MAE和McNemar总体表现分别为最高和最低。
- Dunn.MAE可能适用于样本量小于150眼的情况。
研究设计与样本
- 研究类型为统计检验效用比较,纳入2011年3月至2022年12月期间在5个学术中心和2个私人诊所接受白内障手术并有术后显然验光的眼。
- 分析7839例患者的7839只眼,等效球镜预测误差数据随机分为样本量100、300、500、700和2600眼的子集。
- 对6种人工晶状体度数预测公式计算平均绝对误差、中位绝对误差、标准差、均方根绝对误差和预测误差在0.50屈光度以内的眼比例,并使用Friedman事后Dunn检验、Cochran Q事后McNemar检验、Eyetemis检验和WHWK检验进行分析,所有检验均采用Holm校正进行多重比较校正。
主要发现
- 按显著率,WHWK.MAE(42%)、WHWK.SD(41%)、Eyetemis.MAE(40%)、WHWK.RMSAE(39%)和Dunn.MAE(34%)分别比其余3种检验更稳健(所有P < .001)。
- Dunn.MAE在100眼子集中具有最佳不一致比(0.11)。
- 按自洽指数,前5种检验最为稳健,自洽指数分别为0.39、0.35、0.35、0.34和0.31(所有P < .02)。
- 在2600眼子集中,WHWK.SD和WHWK.RMSAE具有最佳自洽指数(均为0.77)。
- McNemar总体自洽指数最差(0.09)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To characterize the performance of traditional and contemporary statistics tests for analysis of spherical equivalent prediction error (SEQ-PE) after cataract surgery, with regard to test significance and self-consistency. DESIGN: Comparison of the utility of statistical tests. METHODS: Subjects: Eyes from 5 academic centers and 2 private practices that had cataract surgery and postoperative manifest refraction between March 2011 and December 2022. SEQ-PE data were randomly divided into subsets with sample sizes of 100, 300, 500, 700, and 2600 eyes. Mean absolute error (MAE), median absolute error (MedAE), SD, root mean squared absolute error (RMSAE), and the proportion of eyes within 0.50 diopters (D) of predicted were calculated for 6 power prediction formulas and analyzed using Friedman post hoc Dunn, Cochran Q post hoc McNemar, Eyetemis, and Wilcox-Holladay-Wang-Koch (WHWK) statistical tests. All tests were corrected for multiple comparisons using the Holm correction. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The percentage of significant relationships (Percent Significance), proportion of inconsistencies (Inconsistency Ratio), and proportion of self-consistent significant relationships (Significance Index) for each statistical test. RESULTS: Analysis was performed on 7839 eyes of 7839 patients. WHWK.MAE (42%), WHWK.SD (41%), Eyetemis.MAE (40%), WHWK.RMSAE (39%), and Dunn.MAE (34%) were more robust, respectively, than the remaining 3 tests by Percent Significance (all P < .001). Dunn.MAE had the best Inconsistency Ratio (0.11) in the 100-eye subsets. The same top 5 tests were most robust by Significance Index (0.39, 0.35, 0.35, 0.34, and 0.31, respectively; all P < .02). WHWK.SD and WHWK.RMSAE had the best Significance Indices (both 0.77) in the 2600-eye subsets. McNemar had the poorest Significance Index overall (0.09). CONCLUSIONS: The 5 high-performing tests produced significant results more often and were also self-consistent. WHWK.MAE and McNemar were highest and lowest performing overall, respectively. Dunn.MAE may be useful in sample sizes <150 eyes.
引用
- Cannon NT, Savini G, Pantanelli SM, et al. Which Test Is Best: Evaluation of Traditional and Contemporary Statistical Tests for Analysis of Spherical Equivalent Prediction Error. Am J Ophthalmol. 2025. PMID: 39922476. doi:10.1016/j.ajo.2025.01.022
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。