验证用于定义儿童弱视视力无改善的规则
该研究通过模拟观察视力与真实视力比较,评估六种判定视力稳定规则的假阴性与假阳性率,涵盖遮盖和眼镜两种治疗下的四种HOTV视力轮廓。结果显示不同规则假阴性率26%至67%、假阳性率0%至38%,作者认为比较两类错误率有助于选择适合临床或研究的规则。
要点
- 真实视力稳定时,六种规则的假阴性率为26%至67%。
- 真实视力改善时,六种规则的假阳性率为0%至38%。
- 连续就诊单次视力测量:遮盖假阴性30%、假阳性38%,眼镜假阴性29%、假阳性35%。
核心结论
- 比较各规则判定视力稳定的假阴性与假阳性率,有助于选择适合临床实践或研究的规则。
- 当考虑不太理想的治疗时,偏好假阴性率较低的规则;当正确分类改善中的视力很重要时,偏好假阳性率较低的规则。
研究设计与样本
- 模拟研究,将纳入测量误差的模拟观察视力与模拟真实视力进行比较。
- 评估六种判定视力稳定的规则:使用单次视力或测试/复测测量,无论是否取平均,覆盖两次或三次就诊。
- 建模四种HOTV视力轮廓:在遮盖和眼镜各自治疗下,视力随时间稳定或改善。
主要发现
- 六种规则和两种治疗下,真实视力稳定时,判定稳定的假阴性率为26%至67%。
- 真实视力改善时,判定稳定的假阳性率为0%至38%。
- 连续就诊单次视力测量:遮盖假阴性率30%、假阳性率38%,眼镜假阴性率29%、假阳性率35%。
- 每次就诊平均两次视力测试:遮盖假阴性率35%、假阳性率22%,眼镜假阴性率36%、假阳性率21%。
关键数值与推荐
- 连续就诊单次视力测量:遮盖假阴性率30%、假阳性率38%,眼镜假阴性率29%、假阳性率35%。
- 每次就诊平均两次视力测试:遮盖假阴性率35%、假阳性率22%,眼镜假阴性率36%、假阳性率21%。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: When treating amblyopia, it is important to define when visual acuity (VA) is no longer improving (i.e., stable) because treatment decisions may be altered based on this determination. METHODS: Simulated observed VAs, incorporating measurement error, were compared with simulated true VAs to determine false-positive and false-negative rates for stable VA for six rules (using single VA or test/retest measurements, with or without averaging, over two or three visits). Four HOTV VA profiles were modeled: stable or improving VA over time with each of patching and spectacles. RESULTS: Across six rules and two treatments, when true VA was stable, false-negative rates for stability ranged from 26% to 67%; when true VA was improving, false-positive rates for stability ranged from 0% to 38%. Single VA measurements at consecutive visits had a false-negative rate of 30% with patching and 29% with spectacles, a false-positive rate of 38% with patching and 35% with spectacles. Averaging two VA tests at each visit slightly increased the false-negative rate (35% with patching and 36% with spectacles), while reducing the false-positive rate (22% with patching and 21% with spectacles). CONCLUSIONS: Comparing false-negative and false-positive rates for stability across rules allows selection of the most appropriate rule for clinical practice or research. When considering less desirable treatments, a rule with a lower false-negative rate is preferable, whereas a rule with a lower false-positive rate would be preferred when it is important to correctly classify improving VA.
引用
- Wu R, Manny RE, Holmes JM, et al. Validating Rules for Defining No Improvement of Visual Acuity in Childhood Amblyopia. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci. 2025. PMID: 39745678. doi:10.1167/iovs.66.1.4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。