文献速递白内障与屈光手术

角膜地形图引导FS-LASIK与SMILE矫正近视及近视散光术后视觉效果的网状荟萃分析比较

[Comparison of visual outcomes between corneal topography-guided FS-LASIK and SMILE for myopia and myopic astigmatism: a network meta-analysis].
PubMed 文献 · Zhonghua Yan Ke Za Zhi · 2024-01-01

该网状荟萃分析纳入17篇文献(7篇随机对照试验、10篇观察性研究),比较角膜地形图引导FS-LASIK、其他FS-LASIK与SMILE矫正近视及近视散光的术后视觉效果。主要分析显示三组在裸眼远视力≥20/20比例、显然验光等效球镜度在±0.50 D及±1.00 D以内比例、矫正远视力提高1行及以上比例上均无统计学差异;敏感性分析中角膜地形图引导FS-LASIK较其他FS-LASIK的RR增加14%至40%,但置信区间均包含1。结论认为FS-LASIK术后视力结果与SMILE相当,角膜地形图引导FS-LASIK的显然验光等效球镜度在±0.50 D及±1.00 D以内的比例更高。

要点

  • 主要分析显示三种手术在裸眼远视力≥20/20比例上无统计学差异,SUCRA排序为角膜地形图引导FS-LASIK 86.7%、其他FS-LASIK 53.1%、SMILE 10.2%。
  • 敏感性分析中角膜地形图引导FS-LASIK较其他FS-LASIK的显然验光等效球镜度在±0.50 D以内比例RR=1.14(95%CI 0.78-1.59),在±1.00 D以内比例RR=1.15(95%CI 0.93-1.61),置信区间均包含1。
  • 矫正远视力提高1行及以上比例的敏感性分析中,角膜地形图引导FS-LASIK较其他FS-LASIK的RR=1.40(95%CI 0.06-24.00),SMILE较其他FS-LASIK的RR=0.77(95%CI 0.17-2.74)。

核心结论

  • 基于上述数据库信息,FS-LASIK术后视力结果与SMILE相当,角膜地形图引导FS-LASIK术后显然验光等效球镜度在±0.50 D及±1.00 D以内的比例更高。

研究设计与样本

  • 网状荟萃分析,检索Embase和PubMed自建库至2023年12月发表的随机对照试验、前瞻性对比研究、观察性研究及回顾性研究。
  • 最终纳入17篇文献,其中7篇为随机对照试验、10篇为观察性研究。
  • 采用Jadad量表评价随机对照试验质量,Newcastle-Ottawa量表评价非随机对照研究质量,使用RevMan 4.3.0软件进行网状荟萃分析。

主要发现

  • 术后裸眼远视力≥20/20的眼数比例(≤3个月)主要分析显示三组差异无统计学意义,SUCRA排序为角膜地形图引导FS-LASIK 86.7%、其他FS-LASIK 53.1%、SMILE 10.2%。
  • 术后显然验光等效球镜度在±0.50 D以内的眼数比例主要分析显示三组无统计学差异;敏感性分析中角膜地形图引导FS-LASIK较其他FS-LASIK的RR=1.14(95%CI 0.78-1.59),SMILE与其他FS-LASIK的RR=0.95(95%CI 0.73-1.11),SUCRA排序为角膜地形图引导FS-LASIK 90.4%、SMILE 31.7%、其他FS-LASIK 27.9%。
  • 术后显然验光等效球镜度在±1.00 D以内的眼数比例主要分析显示三组无统计学差异;敏感性分析中角膜地形图引导FS-LASIK较其他FS-LASIK的RR=1.15(95%CI 0.93-1.61),SMILE与其他FS-LASIK的RR=0.98(95%CI 0.92-1.00),SUCRA排序为角膜地形图引导FS-LASIK 94.5%、其他FS-LASIK 53.9%、SMILE 1.7%。
  • 术后矫正远视力提高1行及以上的眼数比例主要分析显示角膜地形图引导FS-LASIK与其他FS-LASIK相当(RR=1.02,95%CI 0.71-1.65),SMILE较其他FS-LASIK略小(RR=0.86,95%CI 0.65-1.14);敏感性分析中角膜地形图引导FS-LASIK较其他FS-LASIK的RR=1.40(95%CI 0.06-24.00),SMILE较其他FS-LASIK的RR=0.77(95%CI 0.17-2.74),SUCRA排序为角膜地形图引导FS-LASIK 72.4%、其他FS-LASIK 67.3%、SMILE 10.3%。

关键数值与推荐

  • 术后裸眼远视力≥20/20的眼数比例(≤3个月)SUCRA排序:角膜地形图引导FS-LASIK 86.7%、其他FS-LASIK 53.1%、SMILE 10.2%。
  • 术后显然验光等效球镜度在±0.50 D以内的眼数比例敏感性分析:角膜地形图引导FS-LASIK较其他FS-LASIK RR=1.14(95%CI 0.78-1.59),SMILE与其他FS-LASIK RR=0.95(95%CI 0.73-1.11);SUCRA排序:角膜地形图引导FS-LASIK 90.4%、SMILE 31.7%、其他FS-LASIK 27.9%。
  • 术后显然验光等效球镜度在±1.00 D以内的眼数比例敏感性分析:角膜地形图引导FS-LASIK较其他FS-LASIK RR=1.15(95%CI 0.93-1.61),SMILE与其他FS-LASIK RR=0.98(95%CI 0.92-1.00);SUCRA排序:角膜地形图引导FS-LASIK 94.5%、其他FS-LASIK 53.9%、SMILE 1.7%。
  • 术后矫正远视力提高1行及以上的眼数比例SUCRA排序:角膜地形图引导FS-LASIK 72.4%、其他FS-LASIK 67.3%、SMILE 10.3%。

临床怎么用

  • 原文结论认为FS-LASIK术后视力结果与SMILE相当,角膜地形图引导FS-LASIK术后显然验光等效球镜度在±0.50 D及±1.00 D以内的比例更高。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Objective: To compare the postoperative visual outcomes of corneal topography-guided femtosecond laser-assisted laser in situ keratomileusis (FS-LASIK) and small incision lenticule extraction (SMILE) for myopia and myopic astigmatism. Methods: Embase and PubMed were searched for randomized controlled trials (RCTs), prospective comparative studies, observational studies and retrospective studies of patients with myopia and/or myopic astigmatism treated by corneal topography-guided FS-LASIK, the other FS-LASIKs or SMILE (inception to November 2023). The studies meeting the criteria were collected and underwent quality assessment according to the Jadad scale for RCTs and the Newcastle-Ottawa scale for non-randomized studies. RevMan4.3.0 was used for network meta-analysis. Results: A total of 17 studies were included for meta-analysis, including 7 RCT and 10 observational studies. For the percentage of surgical eyes with uncorrected distance visual acuity≥20/20 (≤3 months), there were no statistically significant differences among corneal topography-guided FS-LASIK, the other FS-LASIKs and SMILE. The surface under the cumulative ranking curve (SUCRA) ranking from best to worst was corneal topography-guided FS-LASIK (86.7%), the other FS-LASIKs (53.1%) and SMILE (10.2%). For the percentage of surgical eyes with postoperative manifest refraction spherical equivalent (MRSE) within ±0.50 D (combined follow-up measure timepoint), the main analyses showed no statistical differences among the 3 surgery groups. The sensitivity analyses disclosed the relative risk (RR) of corneal topography-guided FS-LASIK significantly increased by 14% (RR=1.14, 95%CI:0.78-1.59) as compared to that of the other FS-LASIKs, while there was no significant difference between SMILE and the other FS-LASIKs. The SUCRA ranking from best to worst was corneal topography-guided FS-LASIK (90.4%), SMILE (31.7%) and the other FS-LASIKs (27.9%). For the percentage of surgical eyes with postoperative MRSE within± 1.00 D (combined follow-up measure timepoint), the main analyses showed no statistical differences among the 3 surgery groups. The sensitivity analyses showed the RR of corneal topography-guided FS-LASIK significantly increased by 15% (RR=1.15, 95%CI:0.93-1.61) as compared to that of the other FS-LASIKs, while there was no significant difference between SMILE and the other FS-LASIKs. The SUCRA ranking from best to worst was corneal topography-guided FS-LASIK (94.5%), the other FS-LASIKs (53.9%) and SMILE (1.7%). For the percentage of surgical eyes with postoperative corrected distance visual acuity improved by 1 or more lines (combined follow-up measure timepoint), the main analyses showed no statistical difference between corneal topography-guided FS-LASIK and the other FS-LASIKs, while the RR of SMILE was slightly lower than that of the other FS-LASIKs (RR=0.86, 95%CI:0.65-1.14). The sensitivity analyses disclosed the RR of corneal topography-guided FS-LASIK significantly increased by 40% (RR=1.40, 95%CI:0.06-24.00) as compared to that of the other FS-LASIKs, while SMILE had a slightly lower RR as compared with the other FS-LASIKs (RR=0.77, 95%CI:0.17-2.74). The SUCRA ranking from best to worst was corneal topography-guided FS-LASIK (72.4%), the other FS-LASIKs (67.3%) and SMILE (10.3%). Conclusions: Compared with SMILE, FS-LASIK showed a similar postoperative visual acuity improvement. The corneal topography-guided FS-LASIK had better predictability with a higher rate of MRSE within ±0.50 D/1.00 D. 目的: 比较角膜地形图引导飞秒激光辅助准分子激光原位角膜磨镶术(TG FS-LASIK)和飞秒激光小切口角膜基质透镜取出术(SMILE)矫正近视和近视散光的术后视觉效果。 方法: 网状荟萃分析。通过设定的检索策略检索Embase和PubMed数据库自建库至2023年12月已发表的TG-FS-LASIK、其他类型FS-LASIK(TG-FS-LASIK 除外的)和SMILE矫正近视和(或)近视散光患者的随机对照试验(RCT)、前瞻性对比研究、观察性研究及回顾性研究。通过Jadad量表(标准包括随机化、双盲性和退出率等)和Newcastle-Ottawa Scale(NOS)量表(标准包括研究对象、可比性、结局测量等)分别对纳入的RCT和非RCT文献进行质量评价后,使用RevMan 4.3.0统计学软件进行网状荟萃分析。 结果: 按照检索策略通过计算机系统检索和查重后初筛获得3 836篇文献,最终纳入17篇文献,其中7篇为RCT、10篇为观察性研究。对于术后裸眼远视力(UDVA)≥20/20的眼数比例(≤3个月),网状荟萃分析显示TG-FS-LASIK、SMILE及其他FS-LASIK差异无统计学意义;累积排序曲线下面积(SUCRA)排序(从高到低)依次为TG-FS-LASIK(86.7%)、其他FS-LASIK(53.1%)及SMILE(10.2%)。对于术后显然验光等效球镜度(MRSE)在±0.50 D以内的眼数比例(综合随访时间),网状荟萃分析主要结果分析显示,TG-FS-LASIK、SMILE 和其他 FS-LASIK 三者在各方面表现相当。在术后MRSE在±0.50 D 以内的眼数比例方面,敏感性结果显示,TG-FS-LASIK 较其他 FS-LASIK 增加14%(RR=1.14,95%CI:0.78~1.59),而SMILE与其他FS-LASIK相当(RR=0.95,95%CI:0.73~1.11)。SUCRA排序(从高到低)依次为TG-FS-LASIK(90.4%)、SMILE(31.7%)和其他FS-LASIK(27.9%)。对于术后MRSE在±1.00 D 以内的眼数比例(综合随访时间),网状荟萃分析主要结果分析显示三者相当。敏感性结果显示,TG-FS-LASIK 的术后 MRSE 在±0.50 D 以内的眼数比例较其他 FS-LASIK 增加 15%(RR=1.15,95%CI:0.93~1.61),而 SMILE 与其他 FS-LASIK 相当(RR=0.98,95%CI:0.92~1.00)。SUCRA 排序(从高到低)依次为 TG-FS-LASIK(94.5%)、其他FS-LASIK(53.9%)和SMILE(1.7%)。在术后矫正远视力(CDVA)提高1行及以上的眼数比例(综合随访时间)方面,网状荟萃分析主要结果显示,TG-FS-LASIK 与其他 FS-LASIK 相当(RR=1.02,95%CI:0.71~1.65),而 SMILE 术后 CDVA 提高 1 行及以上的眼数比例较其他 FS-LASIK 略小(RR=0.86,95%CI:0.65~1.14)。敏感性结果显示,TG-FS-LASIK 的术后 CDVA 提高 1 行及以上的眼数比例较其他 FS-LASIK 增加 40%(RR=1.40,95%CI:0.06~24.00),而SMILE较其他FS-LASIK略小(RR=0.77,95%CI:0.17~2.74)。SUCRA排序(从高到低)依次为TG-FS-LASIK(72.4%)、其他FS-LASIK(67.3%)和SMILE(10.3%)。 结论: 基于上述数据库信息FS-LASIK术后视力结果与SMILE相当,TG-FS-LASIK术后MRSE在±0.50 D及±1.00 D以内的比例更高。.

来源:Zhonghua Yan Ke Za Zhi,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Liu ZY, Chen YG. [Comparison of visual outcomes between corneal topography-guided FS-LASIK and SMILE for myopia and myopic astigmatism: a network meta-analysis]. Zhonghua Yan Ke Za Zhi. 2024. PMID: 39648029. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112142-20240108-00014

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。