黑人个体的青光眼:我们取得了哪些进展,未来路在何方?
本文为视角文章并附范围综述,回顾关键流行病学研究,明确显示黑人个体青光眼风险增高,并从种族作为社会法律建构、遗传祖先及社会决定因素角度解析这一差异,同时通过案例说明基于种族的医学的缺陷与未来方向。作者指出,尽管对差异的理解有所增长,但因对该负担沉重群体研究不足导致数据欠缺,差距仍存。
要点
- 关键流行病学研究反复且明确显示黑人个体青光眼风险增高。
- 种族作为社会法律建构及遗传祖先仅部分解释青光眼风险差异。
- 社会决定因素是青光眼种族差异的重要驱动因素。
核心结论
- 过去数十年对黑人个体青光眼差异的理解有所增长,但因对该负担沉重群体研究不足导致数据欠缺,差距仍存。
- 种族作为变量在精准医学兴起下可能日益不相关,但仍是一个关键但有缺陷的概念,仍是衡量、研究和干预这些差异以促进健康公平的最佳手段。
研究设计与样本
- 视角文章并附范围综述,对选定文献进行回顾、综合与批判性评价,纳入眼科内外的重要研究。
主要发现
- 关键流行病学研究反复且明确显示黑人个体青光眼风险增高。
- 对种族作为社会法律建构的历史回顾有助于理解多层级的种族差异。
- 对遗传祖先的仔细审视被视为黑人个体青光眼风险增高的部分途径。
- 社会决定因素作为青光眼种族差异重要驱动因素的研究不断增多。
- 通过示例性案例突出了基于种族的医学的缺陷与危险。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文指出,由于缺乏对该负担沉重群体的研究导致数据欠缺,差距仍存。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To provide updates on the key scientific discoveries made and sociological theories put forth that have allowed for a better understanding of the disproportionate burden of glaucoma among Black individuals, and to provide insights into future directions for this important field of work. DESIGN: Perspective with a scoping review of the literature. METHODS: Review, synthesis, and critical appraisal of selected literature on the impact of glaucoma in Black Americans. Important studies within and outside of ophthalmology are considered to allow for a greater understanding of the historical, sociopolitical, and encompassing medical contexts surrounding this complex issue. RESULTS: A historical overview of key epidemiologic studies highlights the repeated and unequivocal demonstration of increased risk of glaucoma in Black individuals. To begin to understand this multi-layered racial disparity, a historical review of race as a social-legal construct is provided. A careful examination of genetic ancestry is considered as a partial means by which increased glaucoma risk is conferred among Black individuals. The growing body of work examining social determinants as an important driver for racial disparities in glaucoma is also reviewed. Finally, the pitfalls and dangers of race-based medicine are highlighted through illustrative cases before providing insights to future directions. CONCLUSIONS: Though our understanding of the disparities in glaucoma in Black individuals has grown over the past decades, gaps persist, particularly due to deficient data driven by a lack of studies in this disproportionately burdened group. Though the use of race as a variable may become increasingly less relevant with the rise of precision medicine, it remains a crucial, though flawed concept that continues to be our best means by which to measure, investigate, and intervene upon these disparities in our efforts to achieve health equity.
引用
- Kitayama K, Wilson MR. Glaucoma in Black Individuals: How Far Have We Come and Where Do We Go From Here? Am J Ophthalmol. 2023. PMID: 39491123. doi:10.1016/j.ajo.2023.10.009
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。