文献速递白内障与屈光手术

现代人工晶状体公式在高度近视眼植入平板襻人工晶状体中的准确性

Accuracy of Modern Intraocular Lens Formulas in Highly Myopic Eyes Implanted With Plate-Haptic Intraocular Lenses.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Ophthalmol · 2024-05-03

该回顾性连续病例系列研究纳入高度近视白内障术后眼,评估15种现代公式和4种经眼轴调整的传统公式在Zeiss 509 M和Alcon SN6CWS平板襻人工晶状体中的预测准确性。在509 M组中RBF 3.0的均方根绝对预测误差最小(0.432),Karmona和Naeser 2分别在极长眼轴和陡峭角膜 subgroups 表现较差;SN6CWS组在BU II等6种公式中MAE和RMSAE显著低于509 M组。

要点

  • 在509 M平板襻人工晶状体组中,RBF 3.0的RMSAE最小(0.432),Zhu-Lu、Olsen和EVO 2.0紧随其后。
  • Karmona在极长眼轴亚组、Naeser 2在陡峭角膜亚组表现较差(p ≤ 0.042)。
  • Haigis-CMAL在浅前房和扁平角膜亚组准确性显著较低(P ≤ .045)。

核心结论

  • 在植入平板襻人工晶状体的长眼轴眼中,RBF 3.0表现最佳,Zhu-Lu、Olsen和EVO 2.0紧随其后。
  • 作者认为Karmona和Naeser 2分别不鼓励用于极长眼轴和陡峭角膜条件。
  • 作者认为Haigis-CMAL不建议用于浅前房和扁平角膜病例。
  • 对于大多数测试公式,C-loop设计人工晶状体眼的屈光结果比平板襻设计更准确。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性连续病例系列研究,收集2019年1月至2023年11月期间高度近视患者白内障术后数据。
  • 纳入391眼植入Zeiss 509 M和302眼植入Alcon SN6CWS,每例患者选取一眼。
  • 评估15种现代公式和4种经眼轴调整的传统公式的预测准确性。

主要发现

  • 509 M组RMSAE排名前10的公式为:RBF 3.0(0.432)、Zhu-Lu(0.436)、Olsen(0.436)、EVO 2.0(0.437)、Pearl-DGS(0.447)、K6(0.452)、VRF-G(0.454)、Naeser 2(0.464)、Haigis-CMAL(0.465)和Karmona(0.477)。
  • Karmona在极长眼轴亚组、Naeser 2在陡峭角膜亚组表现较差(p ≤ 0.042)。
  • Haigis-CMAL在浅前房和扁平角膜亚组准确性显著较低(P ≤ .045)。
  • SN6CWS组在BU II、EVO 2.0、Hoffer-QST、Kane、Pearl-DGS和Zhu-Lu公式中MAE和RMSAE显著低于509 M组(P ≤ .024)。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

PURPOSE: To evaluate the predictive accuracy of modern intraocular lens (IOL) formulas and axial length (AL) adjusted traditional IOL formulas, including Wang-Koch and Cooke-modified AL (CMAL) method, in long eyes with plate-haptic IOLs, and to compare refractive prediction error variances with C-loop IOLs. DESIGN: Retrospective consecutive case series study. METHODS: Data from 391 eyes with Zeiss 509 M and 302 eyes with Alcon SN6CWS implants in highly myopic patients, following cataract surgery from January 2019 to November 2023, were collected. One eye per patient was selected. Predictive outcomes of 15 modern formulas (Barrett Universal II (BU II), Cooke K6 (K6), Emmetropia Verifying Optical (EVO) 2.0, Hoffer-QST, Kane, Karmona, Ladas AI, Naeser 2, Olsen, Pearl-DGS, Radial Basis Function (RBF) 3.0, T2, VRF-G, Zhu-Lu, and Z-Calc) and 4 traditional IOL formulas (Haigis, Hoffer Q, Holladay 1, and SRK/T) with AL adjusted methods, were evaluated. The mean prediction error, mean absolute prediction error (MAE), root-mean-square absolute prediction error (RMSAE) and the proportions of eyes with PEs within ±0.25 Diopter (D), ±0.50 D, ±0.75 D, and ±1.00 D were analyzed. Top 10 RMSAE-ranked formulas underwent further subgroup analysis based on AL, anterior chamber depth (ACD), and keratometry (K). RESULTS: For the 509 M group, RMSAE ranking for the top 10 IOL formulas were the RBF 3.0 (0.432), Zhu-Lu (0.436), Olsen (0.436), EVO 2.0 (0.437), Pearl-DGS (0.447), K6 (0.452), VRF-G (0.454), Naeser 2 (0.464), Haigis-CMAL (0.465) and Karmona (0.477). Karmona and Naeser 2 showed poorer performance in the extremely long AL and steep K subgroups, respectively (p ≤ 0.042). Haigis-CMAL accuracy was significantly lower in shallow ACD and flat K subgroups (P ≤ .045). The SN6CWS group showed significantly lower MAE and RMSAE compared to the 509 M group for the BU II, EVO 2.0, Hoffer-QST, Kane, Pearl-DGS, and Zhu-Lu formulas (P ≤ .024). CONCLUSIONS: In long eyes with plate-haptic IOLs, RBF 3.0 performed best, closely followed by Zhu-Lu, Olsen, and EVO 2.0; Karmona and Naeser 2 are discouraged for extreme AL and steep K conditions, respectively; Haigis-CMAL is not suggested for shallow ACD and flat K cases. Refractive outcomes in eyes implanted with a C-loop design IOL were more accurate than for those implanted with a plate-haptic design, for most tested formulas.

来源:Am J Ophthalmol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Mo ER, Chen Z, Feng KE, et al. Accuracy of Modern Intraocular Lens Formulas in Highly Myopic Eyes Implanted With Plate-Haptic Intraocular Lenses. Am J Ophthalmol. 2024. PMID: 38703800. doi:10.1016/j.ajo.2024.04.017

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。