检测视盘玻璃膜疣的影像学诊断准确性比较:增强深部成像光学相干断层扫描时代
该研究纳入105例疑似视盘玻璃膜疣(ODD)患者的205只眼,比较B超、眼底照相、眼底自发荧光(FAF)和增强深部成像光学相干断层扫描(EDI-OCT)的诊断准确性。EDI-OCT的敏感度和准确率最高(95%、97%),高于FAF(84%、92%)、B超(74%、86%)和眼底照相(38%、66%)。结论认为EDI-OCT是检测ODD诊断效用最高的影像 modality,应被视为首选的初始诊断 modality。
要点
- EDI-OCT检测ODD的敏感度95%、准确率97%,均为四种影像 modality中最高。
- EDI-OCT检查者确信度96%,高于其他所有 modality的88%。
- 所有影像 modality特异度均>97%,精确率均>93%。
核心结论
- 在所有 modality中,EDI-OCT是检测ODD诊断效用最高的影像 modality,应被视为首选的初始诊断 modality。
研究设计与样本
- 比较性诊断分析,纳入2家三级神经眼科门诊因疑似ODD转诊的105例患者共205只眼,其中108只眼有ODD、97只眼无ODD。
- 所有眼接受完整面对面眼科检查(含视神经3D视图)及全部4种影像 modality检查,图像由3名设盲神经眼科医生独立判读,最终经共识作出解释。
- 参考标准为主治眼科医生基于开放病历回顾并结合所有影像 modality和临床信息(包括疾病病程)作出的临床判断。
主要发现
- EDI-OCT检测ODD的敏感度和准确率分别为95%和97%,高于FAF的84%和92%、B超的74%和86%、眼底照相的38%和66%。
- 所有影像 modality的特异度均>97%,精确率均>93%。
- EDI-OCT的检查者确信度最高,为96%,其他所有 modality为88%。
关键数值与推荐
- EDI-OCT检测ODD:敏感度95%、准确率97%、检查者确信度96%。
- FAF检测ODD:敏感度84%、准确率92%。
- B超检测ODD:敏感度74%、准确率86%。
- 眼底照相检测ODD:敏感度38%、准确率66%。
- 所有影像 modality:特异度>97%、精确率>93%;其他所有 modality检查者确信度88%。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为EDI-OCT应被视为检测ODD的首选初始诊断 modality。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To identify the most accurate diagnostic imaging modality to detect optic disc drusen (ODD) between B-scan ultrasonography (US), fundus photography, fundus autofluorescence (FAF), and enhanced depth imaging optical coherence tomography (EDI-OCT). DESIGN: Comparative diagnostic analysis. METHODS: Two hundred five eyes of 105 patients referred to 2 tertiary care neuro-ophthalmology clinics for suspected ODD were recruited: 108 eyes had ODD and 97 did not have ODD. All eyes received a full in-person ophthalmic exam with 3D view of the optic nerve and all 4 imaging modalities. Images were independently reviewed by 3 masked neuro-ophthalmologists to determine the presence or absence of ODD. Final interpretation was made through consensus. The reference standard was defined as the attending ophthalmologist's clinical judgement based on open chart review, with access to all image modalities and clinical information, including disease course. Main outcome measures were sensitivity, specificity, accuracy, and precision for each imaging modality. Examiner confidence was quantified as the proportion of eyes in which the reviewers were certain of their decision. RESULTS: The EDI-OCT had the highest sensitivity and accuracy (95%, 97%) to detect ODD, compared with FAF (84%, 92%), US (74%, 86%), and fundus photography (38%, 66%), respectively. All image modalities had high specificity (> 97%) and precision (> 93%). The EDI-OCT also had highest examiner confidence (96%) compared with all others (88%). CONCLUSIONS: Among all modalities, EDI-OCT was the imaging modality with the highest diagnostic utility for the detection of ODD and should be considered as the preferred initial diagnostic modality.
引用
- Youn S, Loshusan B, Armstrong JJ, et al. A Comparison of Diagnostic Accuracy of Imaging Modalities to Detect Optic Disc Drusen: The Age of Enhanced Depth Imaging Optical Coherence Tomography. Am J Ophthalmol. 2022. PMID: 36516916. doi:10.1016/j.ajo.2022.12.004
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。