白内障手术学习曲线:定量追踪一名住院医师整个培训期间的手术操作动作
本研究为n=1面板研究,收集一名住院医师2021至2022年100例白内障手术视频(第6至760例),人工标注19个手术阶段,用时间序列分析测量各动作时长趋势。结果显示总时间中位数11.6分钟,每10个视频整体速度提升43.4秒,9个阶段时间显著下降,结论认为80例后达到基本手术胜任力,300例后技能进一步提升。
要点
- 总时间中位数11.6分钟,每10个视频整体速度提升43.4秒(95%CI 35.1至52.7秒)。
- 9个手术阶段时间随培训显著下降,主切口、超声乳化、水分离速度提升相对最大。
- 作者结论认为80例后达到基本手术胜任力,300例后技能进一步精进。
核心结论
- 本研究首次定量追踪白内障手术所有相关操作的时间与频率并得出各操作的学习曲线。
- 作者结论认为,与既往研究一致,完成80例后达到基本手术胜任力,300例后技能向手术精巧进一步提升。
研究设计与样本
- n=1面板研究,收集一名住院医师2021至2022年施行的白内障手术录像。
- 仅纳入无上级医师干预且质量合格的完整长度视频,由一名受训标注员人工标注19个手术阶段的起止时间。
- 采用时间序列分析测量该住院医师培训第一年各操作时间趋势的方向与幅度。
主要发现
- 数据集共100个视频,覆盖该住院医师第6至第760例手术。
- 总时间中位数为11.6分钟(IQR 10.1至14.4分钟),整体速度提升幅度为每10个视频43.4秒(95%CI 35.1至52.7秒)。
- 9个手术阶段的时间在整个培训期间显著下降。
- 主切口、超声乳化、水分离相对其平均手术时间的速度提升最大。
- 每个视频平均有26.9个不同手术动作(不包括空闲时段),范围为20至50个。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To track operative phases of cataract surgery over a resident's training to measure action times and frequencies as a surrogate for competency and skill progression. DESIGN: An n = 1 panel study. METHODS: Cataract surgery video recordings performed by a single resident between 2021-2022 were collected. Only full-length videos of adequate quality without supervisor intervention were included. The start and end times of 19 distinct operative phases of cataract surgery were manually labeled by a trained annotator. Timeseries analysis was employed to measure the direction and magnitude of trends in the resident's surgical timing for each action across their first year of training. RESULTS: The dataset comprised 100 videos spread across the resident's sixth to 760th cases. The median total time was 11.6 minutes (IQR 10.1-14.4 minutes), with overall speed increasing at a rate of 43.4 seconds for every 10 videos (95% CI 35.1, 52.7 seconds). Nine operative phases significantly decreased in time throughout training. The main incision, phacoemulsification, and hydrodissection had the greatest improvements in speed relative to their average procedural time. There was an average of 26.9 distinct operative actions (excluding idle periods) in each video (range 20-50). CONCLUSIONS: This is the first study to quantitatively track operative times and frequencies across all relevant actions in cataract surgery and derive learning curves for each. Consistent with previous works, it was found that a basic level of surgical competency was achieved after performing 80 cases. In addition, results from this study indicated that the next level in skill advancement towards surgical finesse occurs after 300 cases.
引用
- Balas M, Kwok JM, Miguel A, et al. The Cataract Surgery Learning Curve: Quantitatively Tracking a Single Resident's Operative Actions Throughout Their Training. Am J Ophthalmol. 2022. PMID: 36581189. doi:10.1016/j.ajo.2022.12.006
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。