基于证据的指南:检测青光眼恶化所需视盘周围OCT扫描次数
结果显示平均RNFL厚度恶化第75和第90百分位速率分别为-1.09和-2.35微米/年,而当前约2年3次扫描仅能准确诊断47%和40%的恶化和快速恶化。结论强调需增加OCT扫描次数,且聚集测量策略可减少所需扫描数。
要点
- 平均RNFL厚度恶化中度(第75百分位)速率为-1.09微米/年,快速(第90百分位)速率为-2.35微米/年。
- 当前约2年3次OCT扫描仅能准确诊断47%的中度和40%的快速RNFL恶化。
- 采用聚集测量策略时,2年内7次扫描可达60%准确率检测中度和快速恶化。
核心结论
- 为更准确诊断RNFL恶化,需要比当前临床实践增加OCT扫描次数。
- 聚集测量策略相比均匀间隔测量可减少所需扫描次数。
研究设计与样本
- 所有眼均有至少5次Cirrus OCT(Carl Zeiss Meditec)RNFL厚度测量且信号强度≥6。
- 使用线性回归测量平均RNFL厚度及4个象限的RNFL恶化速率,并通过模拟估算两种测量策略(均匀间隔和聚集)检测恶化的准确性。
主要发现
- 平均RNFL厚度恶化的第75百分位(中度)和第90百分位(快速)速率分别为-1.09微米/年和-2.35微米/年。
- 在本样本平均约2年内3次OCT扫描的频率下,模拟显示中度和快速RNFL恶化仅分别有47%和40%的时间被准确诊断。
- 提供了达到一系列准确度水平所需的OCT扫描次数估计;例如,若采用更高效的聚集测量策略,2年内7次测量可达60%准确率检测中度和快速恶化。
关键数值与推荐
- 平均RNFL厚度恶化中度速率为-1.09微米/年(第75百分位),快速速率为-2.35微米/年(第90百分位)。
- 当前约2年3次OCT扫描对中度和快速RNFL恶化的准确诊断率分别为47%和40%。
- 采用聚集测量策略时,2年内7次扫描可达60%准确率检测中度和快速恶化。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To estimate the number of OCT scans necessary to detect moderate and rapid rates of retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL) thickness worsening at different levels of accuracy using a large sample of glaucoma and glaucoma-suspect eyes. DESIGN: Descriptive and simulation study. PARTICIPANTS: Twelve thousand one hundred fifty eyes from 7392 adult patients with glaucoma or glaucoma-suspect status followed up at the Wilmer Eye Institute from 2013 through 2021. All eyes had at least 5 measurements of RNFL thickness on the Cirrus OCT (Carl Zeiss Meditec) with signal strength of 6 or more. METHODS: Rates of RNFL worsening for average RNFL thickness and for the 4 quadrants were measured using linear regression. Simulations were used to estimate the accuracy of detecting worsening-defined as the percentage of patients in whom the true rate of RNFL worsening was at or less than different criterion rates of worsening when the OCT-measured rate was also at or less than these criterion rates-for two different measurement strategies: evenly spaced (equal time intervals between measurements) and clustered (approximately half the measurements at each end point of the period). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The 75th percentile (moderate) and 90th percentile (rapid) rates of RNFL worsening for average RNFL thickness and the accuracy of diagnosing worsening at these moderate and rapid rates. RESULTS: The 75th and 90th percentile rates of worsening for average RNFL thickness were -1.09 μm/year and -2.35 μm/year, respectively. Simulations showed that, for the average measurement frequency in our sample of approximately 3 OCT scans over a 2-year period, moderate and rapid RNFL worsening were diagnosed accurately only 47% and 40% of the time, respectively. Estimates for the number of OCT scans needed to achieve a range of accuracy levels are provided. For example, 60% accuracy requires 7 measurements to detect both moderate and rapid worsening within a 2-year period if the more efficient clustered measurement strategy is used. CONCLUSIONS: To diagnose RNFL worsening more accurately, the number of OCT scans must be increased compared with current clinical practice. A clustered measurement strategy reduces the number of scans required compared with evenly spacing measurements.
引用
- Bradley C, Hou K, Herbert P, et al. Evidence-Based Guidelines for the Number of Peripapillary OCT Scans Needed to Detect Glaucoma Worsening. Ophthalmology. 2022. PMID: 35932839. doi:10.1016/j.ophtha.2022.07.025
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。