指南与共识眼外伤眼整形与眼眶角膜与眼表疾病

眼球与附属器外伤术语调查

Globe and Adnexal Trauma Terminology Survey.
指南 / 共识 · JAMA Ophthalmol · 2022-01-01

该研究通过两轮改良德尔菲法调查69名眼科专家,更新眼球与附属器外伤术语。第一轮25个问题中18个达成共识,第二轮7个问题中4个达成共识;现有BETT术语系统获84%(第一轮)和97%(第二轮)共识,专家同意需进一步细化损伤分区定义并纳入损伤机制、泪小管、鼻泪管、晶状体、视网膜及中央与旁中央角膜状态等术语。

要点

  • 69名眼科专家参与第一轮,58名完成第二轮,共识定义为至少67%专家同意。
  • 现有BETT术语系统获84%(58/69)第一轮和97%(56/58)第二轮共识。
  • 专家同意需细化损伤分区定义(55/69,80%),并纳入损伤机制、泪小管、鼻泪管、晶状体、视网膜及中央与旁中央角膜状态至修订术语。

核心结论

  • 专家共识(定义为至少67%专家同意)支持继续使用现有BETT系统定义,并认为需要额外术语以更新当前眼外伤术语。

研究设计与样本

  • 两轮改良德尔菲法调查,于2021年1月1日至7月31日进行,专家小组包括69名通过眼科(眼球与附属器外伤)学会会员身份识别的眼科医生。
  • 专家纳入标准为平均职业生涯中管理过52例眼球或附属器外伤病例和/或发表总计5篇或以上眼球或附属器外伤相关同行评议文章。
  • 第一轮就现有和新提议术语寻求共识,第二轮聚焦第一轮未解决问题;共识定义为至少67%专家同意。

主要发现

  • 共69名专家参与并完成第一轮调查;所有完成第一轮的69名参与者被邀请完成第二轮,收到58份回复。
  • 第一轮25个问题中18个(72%)达成共识,第二轮7个问题中4个(57%)达成共识。
  • 现有BETT系统术语在第一轮获84%(58/69专家)共识,第二轮获97%(56/58专家)共识。
  • 专家同意需要进一步细化损伤分区定义(55/69,80%),因为受影响分区可对视觉和功能结局产生实质影响。
  • 共识认为应将损伤机制(52/69,75%)以及泪小管状态(54/69,78%)、鼻泪管(48/69,69%)、晶状体(46/58,80%)、视网膜(42/58,73%)和中央与旁中央角膜(47/58,81%)纳入修订术语。

关键数值与推荐

  • 共识定义为至少67%专家同意。
  • 现有BETT系统术语共识:第一轮84%(58/69专家),第二轮97%(56/58专家)。
  • 需细化损伤分区定义共识:55/69(80%)。
  • 纳入损伤机制共识:52/69(75%);纳入泪小管状态共识:54/69(78%);纳入鼻泪管共识:48/69(69%);纳入晶状体共识:46/58(80%);纳入视网膜共识:42/58(73%);纳入中央与旁中央角膜共识:47/58(81%)。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

IMPORTANCE: Ocular trauma terminology should be periodically updated to enable comprehensive capturing and monitoring of ocular trauma in clinical and research settings. OBJECTIVE: To update terminology for globe and adnexal trauma. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: A 2-round modified Delphi survey was conducted from January 1 to July 31, 2021, using an expert panel, including 69 ophthalmologists identified through their membership in ophthalmology (globe and adnexal trauma) societies. Consensus was defined as at least 67% expert agreement. A steering committee developed questions after identifying gaps in the current terminology via a targeted literature review. Round 1 sought consensus on existing and newly proposed terminology, and round 2 focused on unresolved questions from round 1. Experts included ophthalmologists who had managed, on average, 52 globe or adnexal trauma cases throughout their careers and/or published a total of 5 or more globe or adnexal trauma-related peer-reviewed articles. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Expert consensus on ocular and adnexal terms. RESULTS: A total of 69 experts participated in and completed round 1 of the survey. All 69 participants who completed round 1 were asked to complete round 2, and 58 responses were received. Consensus was reached for 18 of 25 questions (72%) in round 1 and 4 of 7 questions (57%) in round 2. Existing Birmingham Eye Trauma Terminology system terminology achieved consensus of 84% (58 of 69 experts) in round 1 and 97% (56 of 58 experts) in round 2. Experts agreed on the need for further refinement of the definition of zones of injury (55 of 69 [80%]), as the zone affected can have a substantial effect on visual and functional outcomes. There was consensus that the mechanism of injury (52 of 69 [75%]) and status of the lacrimal canaliculi (54 of 69 [78%]), nasolacrimal ducts (48 of 69 [69%]), lens (46 of 58 [80%]), retina (42 of 58 [73%]), and central and paracentral cornea (47 of 58 [81%]) be included in the revised terminology. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: There was consensus (defined as at least 67% expert agreement) on continued use of the existing Birmingham Eye Trauma Terminology system definitions and that additional terms are required to update the current ocular trauma terminology.

来源:JAMA Ophthalmol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Hoskin AK, Fliotsos MJ, Rousselot A, et al. Globe and Adnexal Trauma Terminology Survey. JAMA Ophthalmol. 2022. PMID: 35862061. doi:10.1001/jamaophthalmol.2022.2594

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。