Nallasamy公式评估:一种用于白内障手术屈光预测的堆叠集成机器学习方法
研究基于密歇根大学Kellogg眼科中心5016例(6893眼)接受Alcon SN60WF人工晶状体植入的白内障患者,开发了堆叠集成机器学习方法Nallasamy公式,并在1003眼测试集上与7种现有公式比较。结果显示Nallasamy公式的平均绝对误差(MAE)为0.312屈光度,中位绝对误差(MedAE)为0.242屈光度,在MAE、MedAE及预测误差在0.5屈光度以内的眼百分比上均优于其他公式,配对Wilcoxon检验经Bonferroni校正后p<0.05。
要点
- Nallasamy公式在测试集MAE为0.312 D,MedAE为0.242 D,优于Barrett Universal II等7种公式。
- Nallasamy公式在MAE、MedAE及预测误差在0.5 D以内的眼百分比上均表现更优。
- 作者指出其临床意义可能主要体现在群体水平。
核心结论
- Nallasamy公式在总体MAE、MedAE及预测误差在0.5屈光度以内的眼百分比上优于所研究的其他7种公式。
- 作者指出其临床意义可能主要体现在群体水平。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入5016例(6893眼)在密歇根大学Kellogg眼科中心接受白内障手术并植入Alcon SN60WF晶状体的患者。
- 使用4013例(5890眼)训练数据集开发基于机器学习的方法,并在1003例(1003眼)测试数据集上评估。
- 将Nallasamy公式的性能与Barrett Universal II、EVO、Haigis、Hoffer Q、Holladay 1、PearlDGS和SRK/T进行比较。
主要发现
- 测试集中Nallasamy公式的MAE为0.312屈光度,MedAE为0.242屈光度。
- Barrett Universal II的MAE=0.328 D、MedAE=0.256 D;EVO的MAE=0.322 D、MedAE=0.251 D;Haigis的MAE=0.363 D、MedAE=0.289 D。
- Hoffer Q的MAE=0.404 D、MedAE=0.331 D;Holladay 1的MAE=0.371 D、MedAE=0.298 D;PearlDGS的MAE=0.329 D、MedAE=0.258 D;SRK/T的MAE=0.376 D、MedAE=0.300 D。
- 基于配对Wilcoxon检验并经Bonferroni校正,Nallasamy公式显著优于7种现有方法(p<0.05)。
关键数值与推荐
- Nallasamy公式在测试集的MAE为0.312 D,MedAE为0.242 D。
- Barrett Universal II的MAE=0.328 D、MedAE=0.256 D;EVO的MAE=0.322 D、MedAE=0.251 D;Haigis的MAE=0.363 D、MedAE=0.289 D。
- Hoffer Q的MAE=0.404 D、MedAE=0.331 D;Holladay 1的MAE=0.371 D、MedAE=0.298 D;PearlDGS的MAE=0.329 D、MedAE=0.258 D;SRK/T的MAE=0.376 D、MedAE=0.300 D。
- Nallasamy公式显著优于7种现有方法,配对Wilcoxon检验经Bonferroni校正后p<0.05。
临床怎么用
- Nallasamy公式可通过https://lenscalc.com/获取使用。
- 作者指出其临床意义可能主要体现在群体水平。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: To develop a new intraocular lens power selection method with improved accuracy for general cataract patients receiving Alcon SN60WF lenses. METHODS AND ANALYSIS: A total of 5016 patients (6893 eyes) who underwent cataract surgery at University of Michigan's Kellogg Eye Center and received the Alcon SN60WF lens were included in the study. A machine learning-based method was developed using a training dataset of 4013 patients (5890 eyes), and evaluated on a testing dataset of 1003 patients (1003 eyes). The performance of our method was compared with that of Barrett Universal II, Emmetropia Verifying Optical (EVO), Haigis, Hoffer Q, Holladay 1, PearlDGS and SRK/T. RESULTS: Mean absolute error (MAE) of the Nallasamy formula in the testing dataset was 0.312 Dioptres and the median absolute error (MedAE) was 0.242 D. Performance of existing methods were as follows: Barrett Universal II MAE=0.328 D, MedAE=0.256 D; EVO MAE=0.322 D, MedAE=0.251 D; Haigis MAE=0.363 D, MedAE=0.289 D; Hoffer Q MAE=0.404 D, MedAE=0.331 D; Holladay 1 MAE=0.371 D, MedAE=0.298 D; PearlDGS MAE=0.329 D, MedAE=0.258 D; SRK/T MAE=0.376 D, MedAE=0.300 D. The Nallasamy formula performed significantly better than seven existing methods based on the paired Wilcoxon test with Bonferroni correction (p<0.05). CONCLUSIONS: The Nallasamy formula (available at https://lenscalc.com/) outperformed the seven other formulas studied on overall MAE, MedAE, and percentage of eyes within 0.5 D of prediction. Clinical significance may be primarily at the population level.
引用
- Li T, Stein J, Nallasamy N, et al. Evaluation of the Nallasamy formula: a stacking ensemble machine learning method for refraction prediction in cataract surgery. Br J Ophthalmol. 2022. PMID: 35379599. doi:10.1136/bjophthalmol-2021-320599
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。