文献速递小儿眼科与斜弱视

作者性别对视觉科学同行评审过程的影响

Influence of Author's Gender on the Peer-Review Process in Vision Science.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Ophthalmol · 2022-02-25

该观察性回顾性数据库研究将30438条PubMed记录(2016-2020年Q1-Q2眼科期刊)按第一作者/最后作者性别与国家标注,用混合模型评估第一作者女性(FAF)与最后作者女性(LAF)对审稿时间线的影响。结果显示FAF/LAF论文审稿时间显著更长(最多+10天)、接收时间更长(+5天),延迟在英文姓名中持续存在而亚洲姓名中不存在。

要点

  • 前30种眼科期刊中第一作者女性占40.0%±6.7%,最后作者女性占27.1%±4.9%。
  • FAF/LAF论文审稿时间显著更长(最多+10天),接收时间更长(+5天)。
  • 延迟在英文姓名中持续存在,但在亚洲姓名中不存在。

核心结论

  • FAF或LAF论文在审稿时间和接收时间上均存在显著差异。
  • 原因可能是多因素的,可由性别偏见与女性担心被更高标准要求共同解释,后者此前已有文献记录,可能延迟对审稿人的反驳。
  • 提高对这一潜在偏见来源的认识可能有助于实施预防和纠正措施。

研究设计与样本

  • 观察性回顾性数据库研究,将30438条PubMed记录(数据来自2016-2020年Q1-Q2眼科期刊)按第一作者/最后作者性别与国家标注。
  • 使用混合模型评估第一作者女性(FAF)与最后作者女性(LAF)对稿件审稿时间线的影响,分析在全球及预设亚组(英文姓名、亚洲姓名、特定主题)中进行。
  • 按国家、期刊和研究主题探讨性别差距。

主要发现

  • FAF/LAF百分比按国家分布不均;前30种眼科期刊中FAF占40.0%±6.7%,LAF占27.1%±4.9%。
  • 总体而言,FAF/LAF论文审稿时间显著更长(最多+10天),接收时间更长(+5天)。
  • 仅考虑全球易识别的英文姓名时这些差异持续存在,但在亚洲姓名中不存在。
  • 在分析的4个主题中的3个(如弱视)发现FAF发表延迟>1个月。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

PURPOSE: To investigate the gender gap in first/last authors in vision science and whether gender affects manuscript review times. DESIGN: Observational retrospective database study. METHODS: First/last author's gender and country were assigned to 30 438 PubMed records (data derived from Q1-Q2 Ophthalmology journals for 2016-2020). Using mixed models, the influence of First Author Female (FAF) and Last Author Female (LAF) were evaluated on the manuscripts' review timeline. This analysis was performed globally and in predefined subgroups (English names, Asian names, specific topics). Additionally, the gender GAP was explored by country, journal, and research topics. RESULTS: The percentages of FAF/LAF were unevenly distributed by country; in the top 30 ophthalmology journals, FAF accounted for 40.0%±6.7% of the publications whereas LAF accounted for 27.1%±4.9%. Overall, FAF/LAF papers underwent significantly longer times to be reviewed (up to +10 days) and accepted (+5 days). These differences persisted when only English names-easily recognizable worldwide-were considered, but not for Asian names. Delays >1 month to get published were found for FAF in 3 of 4 topics analyzed (eg, amblyopia). CONCLUSIONS: Significant differences were found in both review and acceptance times for FAF or LAF papers. The causes for this are likely multifactorial and could be explained by a combination of gender bias and by women's concerns with being held to higher standards, something that has been previously documented, thereby perhaps delaying the rebuttal to reviewers. Increased awareness of this source of potential bias may assist in the implementation of preventive and corrective measures.

来源:Am J Ophthalmol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Jiménez-García M, Buruklar H, Consejo A, et al. Influence of Author's Gender on the Peer-Review Process in Vision Science. Am J Ophthalmol. 2022. PMID: 35227698. doi:10.1016/j.ajo.2022.02.017

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。