文献速递青光眼

阐明眼科医疗标准的挑战:一篇综述

Challenges in Elucidating Ophthalmology's Standards of Care: A Review.
PubMed 文献 · JAMA Ophthalmol · 2022-01-01

该叙述性综述探讨了医疗标准、实践指南与金标准三个相关但不同概念的定义与混淆,回顾了眼科领域标准医疗法律案例(Helling v Carey)对常规眼压测量标准化的影响,并指出法律对医疗标准的定义是最低能力标准,与临床最佳实践存在竞争性定义,可能设置过低基准而不减少 frivolous 诉讼。

要点

  • 医疗标准常被法院和行业决定,与临床最佳实践定义不同,法律标准为最低能力。
  • 眼科Helling v Carey案标准化了青光眼诊断延迟后常规眼压测量。
  • 综述强调应将医疗质量与医疗标准区分,法律定义可能设置过低基准。

核心结论

  • 医疗专业人员通常将医疗标准等同于最佳临床实践,而法律在确定医疗标准时规定的是最低能力标准。
  • 这些竞争性定义至多具有误导性,至差可能适得其反。
  • 该综述论证必须将医疗质量与医疗标准区分,并概述法律定义可能设置过低基准,在不减少无意义诉讼的情况下抑制创新。

研究设计与样本

  • 该研究为叙述性综述,考察美国医疗指南如何制定、正式化、沟通和采纳,旨在阐明眼科医生对医疗标准、实践指南和金标准三个相关但不同概念的理解。

主要发现

  • 定义医疗标准的问题因描述医疗标准、实践指南和金标准三个相关但不同概念的混淆起源和词汇而复杂化。
  • 医疗标准一词虽常作为医学术语使用,但常由法院和行业决定。
  • 眼科提供了医疗标准法律史上最具影响力的案例之一(Helling v Carey),该案在原告因延迟青光眼诊断而丧失视力后标准化了眼压测量的常规使用。
  • 法院当前对医疗标准的看法与眼科保健史上那个定义性时刻大不相同。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

IMPORTANCE: Defining a standard of care is difficult, and physicians don't always agree on what it means in specific contexts. This is, in part, owing to constantly changing treatment patterns; but at the same time, the underlying framework that determines standards of care is continuously evolving. This situation presents clear challenges for all practicing physicians, including ophthalmologists. OBSERVATIONS: Complicating the issue of defining a standard of care are the confusing origins and lexicon used to describe 3 related yet distinct ideas: standard of care, practice guidelines, and gold standards. Indeed, each of these terms is defined and influenced by many stakeholders both inside and outside the health care system. The term standard of care is one example that, although used frequently as a medical term, is often decided by courts and industry. Ophthalmology itself has provided one of the most influential cases in standard-of-care law history (Helling v Carey), which standardized the routine use of tonometry after the plaintiff lost vision because of a delayed glaucoma diagnosis. But even the courts' current view of standard of care is far different than it was at that defining moment in eye care history. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Today, health care professionals typically equate standard of care with best clinical practices, and yet the law specifies a standard of minimal competence when determining standard of care. These competing definitions are, at best, misleading and, at worst, counterproductive. This narrative review examines how medical guidelines are developed, formalized, communicated, and adopted in the United States. It seeks to clarify ophthalmologists' understanding of the related but distinct ideas of standard of care, practice guidelines, and gold standards. Last, this review argues that quality of care must be distinguished from standard of care and outlines how legal definitions of standards of care can set exceedingly low benchmarks, discouraging innovation without reducing frivolous litigation.

来源:JAMA Ophthalmol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Hellem A, VanderBeek BL. Challenges in Elucidating Ophthalmology's Standards of Care: A Review. JAMA Ophthalmol. 2022. PMID: 35024758. doi:10.1001/jamaophthalmol.2021.5511

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。