整合稳定与判别性放射组学特征在平扫CT上区分肉芽肿与腺癌
该回顾性研究纳入3家机构412例肺腺癌或肉芽肿患者,从平扫CT提取结节内及结节周围放射组学特征,定义跨站点表达稳定的特征。在独立测试集中,同时最大化特征稳定性和判别性的分类器AUC高于仅最大化判别性的分类器(测试集I:0.85 vs 0.80,P=0.047;测试集II:0.87 vs 0.79,P=0.021)。
要点
- 同时考虑特征稳定性和判别性可提高放射组学分类器区分肉芽肿与腺癌的泛化能力。
- 结节周围纹理和形状特征较结节内纹理特征受扫描参数影响更小,但判别性较低。
- 在<3mm和≥3mm层厚扫描中,稳定+判别性分类器的AUC均优于仅判别性分类器。
核心结论
- 同时优化特征稳定性和判别性可构建更泛化的放射组学分类器,用于平扫CT区分腺癌与肉芽肿。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性纳入3家机构412例腺癌或肉芽肿患者,训练集145例,测试集I 205例,独立测试集II 62例。
- 由专家放射科医师在2D轴位视图手动分割肺结节,提取结节内和结节周围放射组学特征。
主要发现
- 测试集I中,稳定+判别性分类器最大AUC为0.85,仅判别性为0.80,P=0.047。
- 测试集II中,稳定+判别性分类器最大AUC为0.87,仅判别性为0.79,P=0.021。
- 层厚<3mm亚组(n=100)中,AUC为0.88 vs 0.80,P=0.039;层厚≥3mm亚组(n=105)中,AUC为0.81 vs 0.76,P=0.034。
- 结节周围纹理和形状特征稳定性高于结节内纹理特征,但判别性较低。
临床怎么用
- 在开发放射组学模型时,应同时评估特征跨站点稳定性与判别性,而非仅追求高AUC。
- 结节周围纹理和形状特征可能对扫描参数变化更稳健,可优先考虑纳入稳定特征集。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性相关内容。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To identify stable and discriminating radiomic features on non-contrast CT scans to develop more generalisable radiomic classifiers for distinguishing granulomas from adenocarcinomas. METHODS: In total, 412 patients with adenocarcinomas and granulomas from three institutions were retrospectively included. Segmentations of the lung nodules were performed manually by an expert radiologist in a 2D axial view. Radiomic features were extracted from intra- and perinodular regions. A total of 145 patients were used as part of the training set (Str), whereas 205 patients were used as part of test set I (Ste1) and 62 patients were used as part of independent test set II (Ste2). To mitigate the variation of CT acquisition parameters, we defined 'stable' radiomic features as those for which the feature expression remains relatively unchanged between different sites, as assessed using a Wilcoxon rank-sum test. These stable features were used to develop more generalisable radiomic classifiers that were more resilient to variations in lung CT scans. Features were ranked based on two criteria, firstly based on discriminability (i.e. maximising AUC) alone and subsequently based on maximising both feature stability and discriminability. Different machine-learning classifiers (Linear discriminant analysis, Quadratic discriminant analysis, Support vector machines and random forest) were trained with features selected using the two different criteria and then compared on the two independent test sets for distinguishing granulomas from adenocarcinomas, in terms of area under the receiver operating characteristic curve. RESULTS: In the test sets, classifiers constructed using the criteria involving maximising feature stability and discriminability simultaneously achieved higher AUC compared with the discriminating alone criteria (Ste1 [n = 205]: maximum AUCs of 0.85versus . 0.80; p-value = 0.047 and Ste2 [n = 62]: maximum AUCs of 0.87 versus. 0.79; p-value = 0.021). These differences held for features extracted from scans with <3 mm slice thickness (AUC = 0.88 versus. 0.80; p-value = 0.039, n = 100) and for the ≥3 mm cases (AUC = 0.81 versus. 0.76; p-value = 0.034, n = 105). In both experiments, shape and peritumoural texture features had a higher stability compared with intratumoural texture features. CONCLUSIONS: Our study suggests that explicitly accounting for both stability and discriminability results in more generalisable radiomic classifiers to distinguish adenocarcinomas from granulomas on non-contrast CT scans. Our results also showed that peritumoural texture and shape features were less affected by the scanner parameters compared with intratumoural texture features; however, they were also less discriminating compared with intratumoural features.
引用
- Khorrami M, Bera K, Thawani R, et al. Distinguishing granulomas from adenocarcinomas by integrating stable and discriminating radiomic features on non-contrast computed tomography scans. Eur J Cancer. 2021. PMID: 33743483. doi:10.1016/j.ejca.2021.02.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。