容量承诺与肺癌切除术后短期结局无关
该回顾性研究基于美国胸外科医师学会普通胸外科数据库(2015-2017年),纳入32,183例肺癌切除患者、465名外科医生和209家医院,比较符合容量承诺标准(医院年≥40例、医生年≥20例)与否的短期结局。调整混杂后,容量承诺组除住院时间缩短0.5天(95%CI 0.2-0.7天)外,手术死亡率、并发症、主要并发症及复合终点均无差异。二次分析显示医院容量与并发症呈非线性关系,医生容量与主要并发症等呈反向线性关系,仅8%外科医生的容量与更好结局相关。
要点
- 符合容量承诺标准与手术死亡率、并发症等短期结局无关,仅住院时间缩短0.5天。
- 医院容量与并发症呈非线性关系,中等容量医院并发症风险最高。
- 仅8%外科医生的容量与更好结局相关,未发现实用的容量替代阈值。
核心结论
- 容量承诺标准与肺癌切除术后短期结局无关,仅住院时间 marginally 缩短0.5天。
- 医院和医生容量-结局关系结果混杂,未提供实用的容量质量改进替代方案。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,使用美国胸外科医师学会普通胸外科数据库2015-2017年数据。
- 纳入32,183例患者、465名外科医生和209家医院。
- 采用广义估计方程调整混杂和聚类,比较符合与不符合容量承诺标准(医院年≥40例、医生年≥20例)的结局。
- 二次分析使用限制性立方样条建模容量与短期结局的关系。
主要发现
- 16,630例患者(52%)同时由符合容量承诺标准的医院和医生治疗。
- 调整后,容量承诺组与手术死亡率、并发症、主要并发症、主要并发症-死亡复合终点或抢救失败均无关系。
- 容量承诺组住院时间缩短0.5天(95%CI 0.2-0.7天)。
- 医院容量与并发症呈非线性关系,中等容量医院并发症风险最高。
- 医生容量与主要并发症、主要并发症-死亡复合终点和住院时间呈反向线性关系,仅8%外科医生容量与更好结局相关。
关键数值与推荐
- 容量承诺标准:医院年肺癌切除≥40例,外科医生年≥20例。
- 符合标准组住院时间缩短0.5天(95%CI 0.2-0.7天)。
- 仅8%外科医生的容量与更好结局相关。
临床怎么用
- 容量承诺标准不宜作为肺癌手术质量改进的唯一依据。
- 评估医院和医生容量时需考虑非线性关系及医生容量的反向线性关联。
- 住院时间可能轻微受益于容量承诺标准,但其他短期结局无改善。
局限性
- 回顾性研究设计,可能存在未测量混杂。
- 仅使用STS GTSD数据库,结果外推性受限。
- 未评估长期结局或患者报告结局。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: We examined the relationship between short-term outcomes and hospitals and surgeons who met minimum volume thresholds for lung cancer resection based on definitions provided by the Volume Pledge. A secondary aim was to evaluate the volume-outcome relationship to determine alternative thresholds in the event the Volume Pledge was not associated with outcomes. PATIENTS AND METHODS: We conducted a retrospective study (2015-2017) using the Society of Thoracic Surgeons General Thoracic Surgery Database. We used generalized estimating equations that accounted for confounding and clustering to compare outcomes across hospitals and surgeons who did and did not meet the Volume Pledge criteria: ≥ 40 patients per year for hospitals and ≥ 20 patients per year for surgeons. Our secondary aim was to model volume by using restricted cubic splines to determine the association between volume and short-term outcomes. RESULTS: Among 32,183 patients, 465 surgeons, and 209 hospitals, 16,630 patients (52%) received care from both a hospital and surgeon meeting the Volume Pledge criteria. After adjustment, there was no relationship with operative mortality, complications, major morbidity, a major morbidity-mortality composite end point, or failure to rescue. The Volume Pledge group had a 0.5 day (95% CI, 0.2 to 0.7 day) shorter length of stay. Our secondary aim revealed a nonlinear relationship between hospital volume and complications in which intermediate-volume hospitals had the highest risk of complications. Surgeon volume was associated with major morbidity, a major morbidity-mortality composite end point, and length of stay in an inverse linear fashion. Only 8% of surgeons had volumes associated with better outcomes. CONCLUSION: The Volume Pledge was not associated with better outcomes except for a marginally shorter length of stay. A re-examination of volume-outcome relationships for hospitals and surgeons yielded mixed results that did not reveal a practical alternative for volume-based quality improvement efforts.
引用
- Farjah F, Grau-Sepulveda MV, Gaissert H, et al. Volume Pledge is Not Associated with Better Short-Term Outcomes After Lung Cancer Resection. J Clin Oncol. 2020. PMID: 32762615. doi:10.1200/JCO.20.00329
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。