美国预防服务工作组肺癌筛查指南在非裔美国成人吸烟者中的评估
南方社区队列研究前瞻性纳入美国南部12州48 364名现吸及曾吸烟者,评估USPSTF肺癌筛查标准的诊断准确性。非裔吸烟者符合筛查比例17%低于白人31%(P<.001),肺癌患者中非裔符合筛查比例32%低于白人56%(P<.001)。将吸烟包年阈值降至最低20包年可提高非裔吸烟者筛查符合率并使敏感度与特异度表现更公平。
要点
- 非裔吸烟者符合USPSTF筛查比例17%,低于白人吸烟者31%(P<.001)。
- 肺癌患者中非裔符合筛查比例32%,低于白人56%(P<.001)。
- 包年阈值降至20包年可提高非裔吸烟者筛查符合率并使敏感度与特异度表现更公平。
核心结论
- 现行USPSTF肺癌筛查指南对非裔美国吸烟者可能过于保守。
- 研究结果提示按种族调整包年标准可使高危非裔吸烟者获得更公平的筛查。
研究设计与样本
- 南方社区队列研究前瞻性纳入2002年3月25日至2009年9月24日在美国南部12州社区健康中心就诊的40至79岁非裔及白人现吸与曾吸烟成人,随访癌症发病至2014年12月31日。
- 统计分析时间为2016年5月11日至2018年12月6日。
- 共纳入48 364名曾吸烟者,其中非裔32 463人(67%)、白人15 901人(33%),识别1269例新发肺癌。
主要发现
- 全部48 364名参与者中,非裔吸烟者5654/32 463(17%)符合USPSTF筛查,白人吸烟者4992/15 901(31%)符合(P<.001)。
- 肺癌患者中,非裔吸烟者255/791(32%)符合筛查,白人吸烟者270/478(56%)符合(P<.001)。
- 非裔吸烟者符合筛查的肺癌病例比例较低主要与包年数较少相关(中位包年:非裔25.8[四分位距16.9-42.0]对比白人48.0[四分位距30.2-70.5];P<.001)。
- 各年龄段非裔与白人吸烟者间USPSTF指南的敏感度与特异度均存在种族差异。
- 将吸烟包年标准降至最低20包年与非裔吸烟者筛查符合率提高相关,且各年龄段与非裔相比白人吸烟者的敏感度与特异度表现更公平(55岁现吸非裔吸烟者敏感度从32.2%升至49.0%,55岁现吸白人吸烟者为56.5%;特异度从83.0%降至71.6%,白人为69.4%;P<.001)。
关键数值与推荐
- USPSTF推荐低剂量计算机断层扫描用于肺癌筛查。
- USPSTF筛查指南来源人群仅含4%非裔吸烟者,未考虑吸烟模式的种族差异。
- 将吸烟包年标准降至最低20包年与非裔吸烟者筛查符合率提高相关(55岁现吸非裔吸烟者敏感度从32.2%升至49.0%,特异度从83.0%降至71.6%;P<.001)。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论指出现行USPSTF肺癌筛查指南对非裔美国吸烟者可能过于保守。
- 作者认为按种族调整肺癌筛查指南中的包年标准可使高危非裔吸烟者获得更公平的筛查。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: The United States Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) recommends low-dose computed tomography screening for lung cancer. However, USPSTF screening guidelines were derived from a study population including only 4% African American smokers, and racial differences in smoking patterns were not considered. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of USPSTF lung cancer screening eligibility criteria in a predominantly African American and low-income cohort. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: The Southern Community Cohort Study prospectively enrolled adults visiting community health centers across 12 southern US states from March 25, 2002, through September 24, 2009, and followed up for cancer incidence through December 31, 2014. Participants included African American and white current and former smokers aged 40 through 79 years. Statistical analysis was performed from May 11, 2016, to December 6, 2018. EXPOSURES: Self-reported race, age, and smoking history. Cumulative exposure smoking histories encompassed most recent follow-up questionnaires. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Incident lung cancer cases assessed for eligibility for lung cancer screening using USPSTF criteria. RESULTS: Among 48 364 ever smokers, 32 463 (67%) were African American and 15 901 (33%) were white, with 1269 incident lung cancers identified. Among all 48 364 Southern Community Cohort Study participants, 5654 of 32 463 African American smokers (17%) were eligible for USPSTF screening compared with 4992 of 15 901 white smokers (31%) (P < .001). Among persons diagnosed with lung cancer, a significantly lower percentage of African American smokers (255 of 791; 32%) was eligible for screening compared with white smokers (270 of 478; 56%) (P < .001). The lower percentage of eligible lung cancer cases in African American smokers was primarily associated with fewer smoking pack-years among African American vs white smokers (median pack-years: 25.8 [interquartile range, 16.9-42.0] vs 48.0 [interquartile range, 30.2-70.5]; P < .001). Racial disparity was observed in the sensitivity and specificity of USPSTF guidelines between African American and white smokers for all ages. Lowering the smoking pack-year eligibility criteria to a minimum 20-pack-year history was associated with an increased percentage of screening eligibility of African American smokers and with equitable performance of sensitivity and specificity compared with white smokers across all ages (for a 55-year-old current African American smoker, sensitivity increased from 32.2% to 49.0% vs 56.5% for a 55-year-old white current smoker; specificity decreased from 83.0% to 71.6% vs 69.4%; P < .001). CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Current USPSTF lung cancer screening guidelines may be too conservative for African American smokers. The findings suggest that race-specific adjustment of pack-year criteria in lung cancer screening guidelines would result in more equitable screening for African American smokers at high risk for lung cancer.
引用
- Aldrich MC, Mercaldo SF, Sandler KL, et al. Evaluation of USPSTF Lung Cancer Screening Guidelines Among African American Adult Smokers. JAMA Oncol. 2019. PMID: 31246249. doi:10.1001/jamaoncol.2019.1402
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。