软组织肉瘤切除术后边缘分类系统评估局部复发风险的分析
R分类可区分三个复发风险层级;R+1mm分类虽增加R1边缘数量,但缩小了R1与R0的复发差异;TMCC对阳性边缘提供额外分层。
要点
- R分类下10年局部复发率:R0为8%,R1为21%,R2为44%。
- R+1mm分类使R1边缘增至726例(vs 278例,P<.001),10年复发率R0为8%、R1为12%。
- TMCC中关键结构阳性边缘10年复发率与R0无差异(11% vs 8%,P=.18),意外阳性边缘复发率高。
核心结论
- R分类可识别软组织肉瘤局部复发的三个不同风险层级。
- R+1mm分类缩小了R1与R0的局部复发差异,提示负但<1mm的边缘在多学科治疗下可能足够。
- TMCC对阳性边缘提供额外分层,可能有助于手术规划和患者教育。
研究设计与样本
- 边缘按R分类(切缘镜下肿瘤定义为R1)、R+1mm分类(距切缘1mm内镜下肿瘤定义为R1)和TMCC分类进行编码。
- 采用多因素竞争风险回归模型进行分析。
主要发现
- 按R分类,10年局部复发率在R0、R1、R2分别为8%、21%、44%。
- R+1mm分类增加R1边缘数量(726 vs 278,P<.001),但降低R1的局部复发且不改变R0的复发;R0的10年复发率为8%(范围7%至10%),R1的10年复发率为12%(10%至15%)。
- TMCC各层级间局部复发率不同(P<.001)。
- 关键结构阳性边缘的10年局部复发率与R0无差异(11% vs 8%,P=.18)。
- 意外阳性边缘局部复发率高:5年为28%(95%CI 19%至37%),10年为35%(95%CI 25%至46%),P<.001。
临床怎么用
- 可采用R分类评估软组织肉瘤术后局部复发风险层级。
- R+1mm分类提示负但<1mm的边缘在多学科治疗下可能可接受。
- TMCC可对阳性边缘进一步分层,辅助手术规划和患者教育。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Purpose To compare the ability of margin classification systems to determine local recurrence (LR) risk after soft tissue sarcoma (STS) resection. Methods Two thousand two hundred seventeen patients with nonmetastatic extremity and truncal STS treated with surgical resection and multidisciplinary consideration of perioperative radiotherapy were retrospectively reviewed. Margins were coded by residual tumor (R) classification (in which microscopic tumor at inked margin defines R1), the R+1mm classification (in which microscopic tumor within 1 mm of ink defines R1), and the Toronto Margin Context Classification (TMCC; in which positive margins are separated into planned close but positive at critical structures, positive after whoops re-excision, and inadvertent positive margins). Multivariate competing risk regression models were created. Results By R classification, LR rates at 10-year follow-up were 8%, 21%, and 44% in R0, R1, and R2, respectively. R+1mm classification resulted in increased R1 margins (726 v 278, P < .001), but led to decreased LR for R1 margins without changing R0 LR; for R0, the 10-year LR rate was 8% (range, 7% to 10%); for R1, the 10-year LR rate was 12% (10% to 15%) . The TMCC also showed various LR rates among its tiers ( P < .001). LR rates for positive margins on critical structures were not different from R0 at 10 years (11% v 8%, P = .18), whereas inadvertent positive margins had high LR (5-year, 28% [95% CI, 19% to 37%]; 10-year, 35% [95% CI, 25% to 46%]; P < .001). Conclusion The R classification identified three distinct risk levels for LR in STS. An R+1mm classification reduced LR differences between R1 and R0, suggesting that a negative but < 1-mm margin may be adequate with multidisciplinary treatment. The TMCC provides additional stratification of positive margins that may aid in surgical planning and patient education.
引用
- Gundle KR, Kafchinski L, Gupta S, et al. Analysis of Margin Classification Systems for Assessing the Risk of Local Recurrence After Soft Tissue Sarcoma Resection. J Clin Oncol. 2018. PMID: 29346043. doi:10.1200/JCO.2017.74.6941
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。