高价值肿瘤实践的关键经验
该研究采用正偏差混合方法分析,在美国太平洋西北部和中西部选取低保险方允许支出的肿瘤实践,并从中筛选高质量者进行访谈。研究共纳入4个正偏差(低支出)实践和3个支出居中实践,提炼出5个主题下的13项属性,其中5项属性最能区分高价值实践点。专家小组认为3项属性在降低成本的同时不损害质量的即时潜力最高。
要点
- 早期讨论治疗局限性与后果等3项属性被专家评为最具即时降本潜力。
- 保守使用影像、早期讨论治疗局限、单一接触点等5项属性最能区分高价值实践。
- 高价值属性涵盖治疗规划、患者支持、技术布局、团队组织和外部环境5个主题。
核心结论
- 研究识别出可能降低高质量肿瘤诊疗总支出、值得进一步测试的肿瘤实践属性。
研究设计与样本
- 采用正偏差探索性混合方法(定量与定性)分析访谈结果。
- 在美国太平洋西北部和中西部识别低平均保险方允许支出的肿瘤实践,并从中选择高质量者。
- 由经验丰富的肿瘤科医生组成的小组审查低支出实践中独特或频繁出现的属性。
- 共研究4个正偏差(低支出)肿瘤实践和3个支出分布接近中位的肿瘤实践。
主要发现
- 从7个肿瘤实践中归纳出5个主题下的13项属性。
- 5个主题为治疗规划与目标设定、支持患者旅程的服务、技术支持与物理布局、照护团队组织与功能、外部环境。
- 5项属性最能明显区分高价值实践点:保守使用影像、早期讨论治疗局限性与后果、单一接触点、最大限度使用注册护士执行干预、多组分医疗保健系统。
- 专家肿瘤科小组判断3项属性在降低成本同时不损害质量方面的即时潜力最高:早期且常态化的姑息治疗、门诊快速反应、早期讨论治疗局限性与后果。
关键数值与推荐
- 5项最能区分高价值实践点的属性:保守使用影像、早期讨论治疗局限性与后果、单一接触点、最大限度使用注册护士执行干预、多组分医疗保健系统。
- 专家小组判断即时降本潜力最高的3项属性:早期且常态化的姑息治疗、门诊快速反应、早期讨论治疗局限性与后果。
临床怎么用
- 可将早期讨论治疗局限性与后果、早期且常态化姑息治疗、门诊快速反应等属性作为试点改进方向。
- 在实践组织中优化团队分工,如设置单一接触点并最大限度使用注册护士执行干预。
- 关注影像保守使用与多组分医疗保健系统等组织层面属性对总支出的影响。
局限性
- 为探索性混合方法分析,研究结果需进一步测试验证。
- 仅研究美国太平洋西北部和中西部7个肿瘤实践,外推性有限。
- 专家小组对属性的判断为主观评估,尚缺乏实施效果数据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Cancer care is expensive. Cancer care provided by practice organizations varies in total spending incurred by patients and payers during treatment episodes and in quality of care, and this unnecessary variation contributes to the high cost. OBJECTIVE: To use the variation in total spending and quality of care to assess oncology practice attributes distinguishing "high value" that may be tested and adopted by others to produce similar results. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: "Positive deviance" was used in this exploratory mixed-methods (quantitative and qualitative) analysis of interview results. To quantify value, oncology practices located near the US Pacific Northwest and Midwest with low mean insurer-allowed spending were identified. Among those, practices with high quality were selected. A team then conducted site visits to interview practice personnel from June 2, 2015, through October 3, 2015, and to probe for attributes of high-value care. A qualitative analysis of their interview results was performed, and a panel of experienced oncologists was convened to review attributes occurring uniquely or frequently in low-spending practices for their contribution to value improvement and ease of implementation. Four positive deviant (ie, low-spending) oncology practices and 3 oncology practices that ranked near the middle of the spending distribution were studied. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Thematic saturation in a qualitative analysis of high-value care attributes. RESULTS: From the 7 oncology practices studied, 13 attributes within the following 5 themes emerged: treatment planning and goal setting, services supporting the patient journey, technical support and physical layout, care team organization and function, and external context. Five attributes (ie, conservative use of imaging, early discussion of treatment limitations and consequences, single point of contact, maximal use of registered nurses for interventions, and a multicomponent health care system) most sharply distinguished the high-value practice sites. The expert oncologist panel judged 3 attributes (ie, early and normalized palliative care, ambulatory rapid response, and early discussion of treatment limitations and consequences) to carry the highest immediate potential for lowering spending without compromising the quality of care. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Oncology practice attributes warranting further testing were identified that may lower total spending for high-quality oncology care.
引用
- Blayney DW, Simon MK, Podtschaske B, et al. Critical Lessons From High-Value Oncology Practices. JAMA Oncol. 2018. PMID: 29145584. doi:10.1001/jamaoncol.2017.3803
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。