老年肿瘤学中筛查工具个体与相对准确度的建模
该研究采用前瞻性配对设计队列,用对数线性模型估计G8与VES-13筛查需综合老年评估(CGA)的老年肿瘤患者的个体及相对真阳性率(TPF)与假阳性率(FPF)。G8检出需CGA患者优于VES-13,但代价是误分类大量正常患者。作者鼓励使用G8,因漏检需CGA患者可能比过度检出更成问题。
要点
- G8检出需CGA患者优于VES-13,但误分类大量正常患者的代价更高。
- 两种筛查工具在年龄较大和体能状态(PS)较差时TPF更优,且相比前列腺癌,所有其他癌种亚型表现更好。
- 年龄和PS对VES-13的TPF影响比G8更明显。
核心结论
- 回归建模有助于全面评估诊断试验的准确度,应更频繁使用。
- 在筛查情境中,作者鼓励使用G8,因为未识别出需CGA的患者可能比过度检出更成问题。
- 作者识别出与这些筛查工具灵敏度相关的变量,但该关联在G8中较不明显。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性配对设计队列研究。
- 以G8和VES-13筛查工具为例,目标为识别需综合老年评估(CGA)的老年肿瘤患者。
- 采用对数线性模型对每种筛查工具的TPF和FPF以及相对TPF和相对FPF进行建模。
主要发现
- G8检出需CGA患者优于VES-13,但代价是误分类大量正常患者。
- 两种筛查工具在年龄较大和体能状态(PS)较差时TPF更优,且相比前列腺癌,所有其他癌种亚型表现更好。
- 年龄和PS对TPF的影响在VES-13中更明显。
- 年龄影响FPF,但无差异。
临床怎么用
- 作者鼓励在筛查情境中使用G8,因为未识别出需CGA的患者可能比过度检出更成问题。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Classification probabilities reflect to what degree a screening test represents the true disease state and include true positive (TPF) and false positive fractions (FPF). With two tests, one can compare TPF and FPF using relative probabilities which offer advantages in terms of interpretation and statistical modeling. Our objective was to highlight how individual and relative TPF and FPF can be easily estimated and compared within a regression modeling framework. This allows the modeling of tests' accuracy while adjusting for multiple covariates, and thus provides valuable information in addition to the crude TPF and FPF. We illustrate our purpose with the G8 and VES-13 screening tests aimed at identifying elderly cancer patients in need for a comprehensive geriatric assessment (CGA). METHODS: Prospective cohort with a paired design. TPF and FPF of each test, as well as relative TPF and FPF were modeled using log-linear models. RESULTS: G8 detected patients in need for CGA better than VES-13 at the expense of misclassifying a large number of normal patients. Both tests had better TPF with older age and poorer performance status (PS), and for all cancer subtypes compared with prostate cancer. Effect of age and PS on TPF was more pronounced with VES-13. Age affected FPF, but not differentially. CONCLUSIONS: Regression modeling helps provide a thorough assessment of the accuracy of diagnostic tests and should be used more frequently. In the context of screening, we encourage the use of G8 as failing to identify patients in need of a CGA might be more problematic than over-detection. Moreover, although we identified variables associated with the sensitivity of these tests, this association was less pronounced for the G8.
引用
- Bellera CA, Artaud F, Rainfray M, et al. Modeling individual and relative accuracy of screening tools in geriatric oncology. Ann Oncol. 2017. PMID: 28327973. doi:10.1093/annonc/mdx068
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。