癌症患者净生存率估计:相对生存设定比病因别生存设定对某些假设违背更稳健,基于实证数据的敏感性分析
研究基于日内瓦癌症登记处1981至1991年确诊的4285例乳腺癌、结直肠癌、肺癌和黑色素瘤女性,比较病因别生存设定与相对生存设定估计净生存率。结果显示病因别生存设定估计值更高且差异随时间扩大;相对生存设定对寿命表不适宜不敏感,而病因别生存设定对死因错分敏感。相对生存设定更稳健,推荐用于净生存率估计。
要点
- 相对生存设定对寿命表不适宜不敏感,病因别设定对死因错分敏感。
- 病因别设定估计的净生存率高于相对生存设定,绝对差异随时间增加。
- 相对生存设定更稳健,推荐用于净生存率估计。
核心结论
- 相对生存设定对上述假设违背更稳健,因此推荐用于净生存率估计。
研究设计与样本
- 基于日内瓦癌症登记处1981至1991年确诊的4285例乳腺癌、结直肠癌、肺癌和黑色素瘤女性,估计长达20年的净生存率。
- 使用病因别生存设定和相对生存设定,并采用权重处理信息性删失,进行敏感性分析评估死因错分和寿命表不适宜的影响。
主要发现
- 对于所有四种癌症,使用病因别生存设定时净生存率最高,且两种估计值之间的绝对差异随诊断后时间增加。
- 敏感性分析显示,使用不同寿命表未损害相对生存设定中的净生存率估计。
- 敏感性分析显示,死因的小水平错分导致病因别生存设定中净生存率估计发生大变化。
临床怎么用
- 相对生存设定更稳健,推荐用于净生存率估计。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Net survival is the survival that would be observed if the only possible underlying cause of death was the disease under study. It can be estimated with either cause-specific or relative survival data settings, if the informative censoring is properly considered. However, net survival estimators are prone to specific biases related to the data setting itself. We examined which data setting was the most robust against violation of key assumptions (erroneous cause of death and inappropriate life tables). We identified 4285 women in the Geneva Cancer Registry, diagnosed with breast, colorectal, lung cancer and melanoma between 1981 and 1991 and estimated net survival up to 20 years using cause-specific and relative survival settings. We used weights to tackle informative censoring in both settings and performed sensitivity analyses to evaluate the impact of misclassification of cause of death in the cause-specific setting or of using inappropriate life tables on net survival estimates in the relative survival setting. For all the four cancers, net survival was highest when using the cause-specific setting and the absolute difference between the two estimators increased with time since diagnosis. The sensitivity analysis showed that (i) the use of different life tables did not compromise net survival estimation in the relative survival setting, whereas (ii) a small level of misclassification for the cause of death led to a large change in the net survival estimate in the cause-specific setting. The relative survival setting was more robust to the above assumptions violations and is therefore recommended for estimation of net survival.
引用
- Schaffar R, Rachet B, Belot A, et al. Estimation of net survival for cancer patients: Relative survival setting more robust to some assumption violations than cause-specific setting, a sensitivity analysis on empirical data. Eur J Cancer. 2016. PMID: 28027519. doi:10.1016/j.ejca.2016.11.019
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。