国际多学会德尔菲共识:肝肿瘤热消融操作与实践标准
该国际多学科多学会指南由ESSO、CIRSE和SIO正式背书,通过在奥地利因斯布鲁克举行的德尔菲共识会议,由72名专家经三轮迭代评分对135条陈述(分属五个领域)达成共识,最终94条(70%)达成共识。共识强调优先选择创伤最小的路径(通常经皮),切缘充分是主要技术目标,复杂消融应由有经验的操作者(既往病例数超过100例)完成。
要点
- 优先选择创伤最小的路径(通常经皮),切缘充分是主要技术目标。
- 复杂消融应由有经验的操作者(既往病例数超过100例)完成。
- 项目应基于结构化培训、多学科团队参与和常规审计。
核心结论
- 对特定原发性和转移性肝肿瘤患者,热消融是比手术更安全、创伤更小、更具成本效益的治愈性治疗,技术得当可达到相似肿瘤学结局。
- 共识优先推荐创伤最小的路径(通常经皮),并重申切缘充分是主要技术目标。
- 复杂消融应由有经验的操作者(既往病例数超过100例)完成,项目应基于结构化培训、多学科团队参与和常规审计。
研究设计与样本
- 国际多学科多学会指南,由欧洲外科肿瘤学会、欧洲心血管与介入放射学会及介入肿瘤学会正式背书。
- 德尔菲共识会议在奥地利因斯布鲁克举行,72名专家参与三轮迭代评分,对135条陈述(分属五个领域:认证、适应证、入路、操作因素和安全措施)进行共识评估。
主要发现
- 135条陈述中94条(70%)达成共识。
- 操作难度被认为取决于背景因素,由肿瘤因素、机构基础设施和操作者经验共同决定。
- 器官移位技术被认可用于维持安全性和扩大可治疗适应证。
关键数值与推荐
- 共识推荐优先选择创伤最小的路径(通常经皮)。
- 切缘充分被重申为主要技术目标。
- 复杂消融应由有经验的操作者(既往病例数超过100例)完成。
- 项目应基于结构化培训、多学科团队参与和常规审计。
临床怎么用
- 在临床实践中应优先选择创伤最小的路径(通常经皮)进行肝肿瘤热消融。
- 复杂消融应安排有经验的操作者(既往病例数超过100例)实施。
- 应建立结构化培训、多学科团队参与和常规审计的项目体系。
- 可考虑使用器官移位技术以维持安全性和扩大可治疗适应证。
局限性
- 常规实践中有效性存在差异,因为结构化培训、规划和操作治理仍然缺乏。
- 未来需开发并验证实用工具,如难度评分系统、标准化操作报告模板和综合培训课程,以改善全球一致性、标准化和临床结局。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Thermal ablation offers a safer, less invasive, and more cost-effective curative-intent treatment for selected patients with primary and metastatic liver tumours than surgery; when done with appropriate technique, ablation can deliver similar oncological outcomes. However, effectiveness in routine practice varies because structured training, planning, and procedural governance remain scarce. These international multidisciplinary, multi-society guidelines-formally endorsed by the European Society of Surgical Oncology, the Cardiovascular and Interventional Radiological Society of Europe, and the Society of Interventional Oncology-define key domains contributing to procedural difficulty and practice variation in liver tumour thermal ablation. A Delphi consensus initiative held in Innsbruck, Austria, engaged 72 experts across three iterative rounds of scoring across 135 statements grouped into five domains: credentialing, indications, approach, procedural factors, and safety measures. Consensus was achieved for 94 (70%) of 135 statements. The least invasive route-typically percutaneous-should be prioritised, and margin adequacy was reaffirmed as the principal technical goal. Procedural difficulty was considered context-dependent, shaped by tumour factors, institutional infrastructure, and operator experience. Organ displacement techniques were endorsed to maintain safety and expand treatable indications. Complex ablations should be done by experienced operators (more than 100 previous cases), with programmes underpinned by structured training, multidisciplinary team participation, and routine audit. Future efforts should develop and validate practical tools such as difficulty scoring systems, standardised procedural reporting templates, and comprehensive training curricula to improve consistency, standardisation, and clinical outcomes globally.
引用
- Laimer G, Johnston EW, Overduin CG, et al. International multisociety Delphi consensus for liver tumour thermal ablation: procedural and practice standards. Lancet Oncol. 2026. PMID: 42061383. doi:10.1016/S1470-2045(26)00114-2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。