英国肺癌筛查CT研究中经组织学证实的AI性能:减少工作量的潜力
该研究在英国肺癌筛查(UKLS)试验的1252例基线CT扫描中,独立评估了商用AI软件与人类读者的判读性能,并以欧洲专家小组参考标准和金标准组织学肺癌结局进行验证。AI作为一线判读者排除阴性CT时,最大估计可减少79%的CT判读工作量,且未导致漏诊肺癌。
要点
- AI检测到全部31例基线肺癌,但因100mm3阈值将其中1例分类为阴性,NPV为99.8%(99.0%-99.9%)。
- 与参考标准相比,AI的误分类少于人类判读,NPV为92.0%(90.2%-95.3%)。
- AI作为一线判读者排除阴性CT,估计最大可减少79%的CT判读工作量。
核心结论
- 将AI作为一线判读者排除阴性CT扫描,显示出相当大的减少CT判读工作量的潜力,且未导致肺癌漏诊。
研究设计与样本
- 研究基于UKLS试验数据集,纳入1252例基线CT扫描,由AI和人类读者独立评估。
- AI性能在两个层面评估:与欧洲专家小组参考标准(基于NELSON2.0欧洲立场声明)比较,以及与金标准组织学肺癌结局比较。
主要发现
- 专家小组参考标准报告1252例UKLS参与者中815例(65%)为阴性,437例(35%)为不确定/阳性。
- 与参考标准相比,AI误分类少于人类判读,NPV为92.0%(90.2%-95.3%)。
- 与金标准比较,AI检测到全部31例基线轮肺癌,但因100mm3阈值将其中1例分类为阴性,NPV为99.8%(99.0%-99.9%)。
- 估计最大CT判读工作量减少为79%。
关键数值与推荐
- 阳性误分类定义为结节阳性判读≥100mm3且专家判读无结节或<100mm3。
- 阴性误分类定义为结节阴性判读而专家判读为不确定或阳性发现。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Artificial intelligence (AI) could reduce lung cancer screening computer tomography (CT)-reading workload if used as a first-reader, ruling-out negative CT-scans at baseline. Evidence is lacking to support AI performance when compared to gold-standard lung cancer outcomes. This study validated the performance of a commercially available AI software in the UK lung cancer screening (UKLS) trial dataset, with comparison to human reads and histological lung cancer outcomes, and estimated CT-reading workload reduction. METHODS: 1252 UKLS-baseline-CT-scans were evaluated independently by AI and human readers. AI performance was evaluated on two-levels. Firstly, AI classification and individual reads were compared to a EU reference standard (based on NELSON2.0-European Position Statement) determined by a European expert panel blinded from individual results. A positive misclassification was defined as a nodule positive read ≥ 100mm3 and no/<100mm3 nodules in the expert read; A negative misclassification was defined as a nodule negative read, whereas an indeterminate or positive finding in the expert read. Secondly, AI nodule classification was compared to gold-standard histological lung cancer outcomes. CT-reading workload reduction was calculated from AI negative CT-scans when AI was used as first-reader. RESULTS: Expert panel reference standard reported 815 (65 %) negative and 437 (35 %) indeterminate/positive CT-scans in the dataset of 1252 UKLS-participants. Compared to the reference standard, AI resulted in less misclassification than human reads, NPV 92·0 %(90·2 %-95·3 %). On comparison to gold-standard, AI detected all 31 baseline-round lung cancers, but classified one as negative due to the 100mm3 threshold, NPV 99·8 %(99·0 %-99·9 %). Estimated maximum CT-reading workload reduction was 79 %. CONCLUSION: Implementing AI as first-reader to rule-out negative CT-scans, shows considerable potential to reduce CT-reading workload and does not lead to missed lung cancers.
引用
- Lancaster HL, Jiang B, Davies MPA, et al. Histological proven AI performance in the UKLS CT lung cancer screening study: Potential for workload reduction. Eur J Cancer. 2025. PMID: 40022836. doi:10.1016/j.ejca.2025.115324
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。