数字化胸片对肺结节的检出与诊断效能及阅片者间一致性研究
回顾性选取2012至2014年中国医学科学院肿瘤医院43例无症状肺结节患者(共43枚≤30 mm结节),6名不同年资影像医师独立阅胸片。6名医师均检出17枚,检出敏感度39.5%;结节检出一致性较好(Kappa 0.629~0.907),性质判断一致性一般或较差(Kappa 0.350~0.653)。结论认为胸片对≤30 mm肺结节检出能力有限、性质判断能力不足。
要点
- 6名医师均检出17枚结节,检出敏感度39.5%(17/43)。
- ≥5、≥4、≥3、≥2、≥1名医师检出敏感度分别为46.5%、48.8%、53.5%、58.1%、65.1%。
- 结节检出一致性较好(Kappa 0.629~0.907),性质判断一致性一般或较差(Kappa 0.350~0.653)。
核心结论
- 胸片对≤30 mm肺结节的检出能力有限,性质判断能力不足,阅片时间延长和阅片者年资增长均不会提高诊断正确率,不宜单独用于肺癌诊断。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性选取2012至2014年于中国医学科学院肿瘤医院就诊、同期具有胸部CT和X线胸片检查的无症状肺结节患者43例,全组共43枚≤30 mm结节。
- 1名有>20年阅片经验的主任医师复阅CT并记录结节大小、形态、位置、密度;6名不同年资影像诊断医师(住院医师、主治医师和副主任医师)复阅胸片,记录阅片时间、结节检出情况及诊断意见。
主要发现
- 6名医师均检出的结节17枚,检出敏感度39.5%(17/43)。
- ≥5、≥4、≥3、≥2、≥1名医师检出的结节数分别为20、21、23、25、28枚,检出敏感度分别为46.5%、48.8%、53.5%、58.1%、65.1%。
- 6名医师对≤30 mm、≤20 mm、≤15 mm、≤10 mm结节的检出敏感度依次为46.5%~58.1%、45.9%~54.1%、36.0%~44.0%、36.4%;诊断正确率依次为19.0%~85.0%、16.7%~6.5%、18.2%~80.0%、0~75.0%。
- 6名医师结节检出一致性较好(Kappa值0.629~0.907),性质判断一致性一般或较差(Kappa值0.350~0.653)。
- 年资越高的医师所需阅片时间越短,阅片时间、阅片经验与诊断正确率无关(均P>0.05)。
关键数值与推荐
- 胸片假阴性的原因包括结节的大小、位置、密度及形态。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论指出胸片不宜单独用于肺癌诊断。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective: To investigate the detection and diagnostic efficacy of chest radiographs for ≤30 mm pulmonary nodules and the factors affecting them, and to compare the level of consistency among readers. Methods: A total of 43 patients with asymptomatic pulmonary nodules who consulted in Cancer Hospital, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences from 2012 to 2014 and had chest CT and X-ray chest radiographs during the same period were retrospectively selected, and one nodule ≤30 mm was visible on chest CT images in the whole group (total 43 nodules in the whole group). One senior radiologist with more than 20 years of experience in imaging diagnosis reviewed CT images and recording the size, morphology, location, and density of nodules was selected retrospectively. Six radiologists with different levels of experience (2 residents, 2 attending physicians and 2 associate chief physicians independently reviewed the chest images and recorded the time of review, nodule detection, and diagnostic opinion. The CT imaging characteristics of detected and undetected nodules on X images were compared, and the factors affecting the detection of nodules on X-ray images were analyzed. Detection sensitivity and diagnosis accuracy rate of 6 radiologists were calculated, and the level of consistency among them was compared to analyze the influence of radiologists' seniority and reading time on the diagnosis results. Results: The number of nodules detected by all 6 radiologists was 17, with a sensitivity of detection of 39.5%(17/43). The number of nodules detected by ≥5, ≥4, ≥3, ≥2, and ≥1 physicians was 20, 21, 23, 25, and 28 nodules, respectively, with detection sensitivities of 46.5%, 48.8%, 53.5%, 58.1%, and 65.1%, respectively. Reasons for false-negative result of detection on X-ray images included the size, location, density, and morphology of the nodule. The sensitivity of detecting ≤30 mm, ≤20 mm, ≤15 mm, and ≤10 mm nodules was 46.5%-58.1%, 45.9%-54.1%, 36.0%-44.0%, and 36.4% for the 6 radiologists, respectively; the diagnosis accuracy rate was 19.0%-85.0%, 16.7%-6.5%, 18.2%-80.0%, and 0%-75.0%, respectively. The consistency of nodule detection among 6 doctors was good (Kappa value: 0.629-0.907) and the consistency of diagnostic results among them was moderate or poor (Kappa value: 0.350-0.653). The higher the radiologist's seniority, the shorter the time required to read the images. The reading time and the seniority of the radiologists had no significant influence on the detection and diagnosis results (P>0.05). Conclusions: The ability of radiographs to detect lung nodules ≤30 mm is limited, and the ability to determine the nature of the nodules is not sufficient, and the increase in reading time and seniority of the radiologists will not improve the diagnostic accuracy. X-ray film exam alone is not suitable for lung cancer diagnosis. 目的: 探讨胸片对于≤30 mm肺结节的检出和诊断效能及其影响因素,比较阅片者间的一致性。 方法: 回顾性选取2012—2014年于中国医学科学院肿瘤医院就诊、同期具有胸部CT和X线胸片检查的无症状肺结节患者(43例),全组患者胸部CT影像均可见1枚≤30 mm的结节(全组共43枚结节)。1名有>20年阅片经验的主任医师复阅CT图像,对结节的大小、形态、位置、密度进行记录。6名具有不同年资(住院医师、主治医师和副主任医师)的影像诊断医师复阅胸片,记录其阅片时间、结节检出情况及诊断意见。比较胸片检出结节与未检出结节的CT影像特征,分析影响胸片结节检出的因素。计算6名医师的检出敏感度以及诊断正确率,比较阅片者间一致性水平,分析阅片时间、阅片经验对于诊断结果的影响。 结果: 43枚结节中6名医师均检出的结节有17枚,检出敏感度为39.5%。≥5名、≥4名、≥3名、≥2名、≥1名医师检出的结节数分别为20、21、23、25、28枚,检出敏感度分别为46.5%、48.8%、53.5%、58.1%和65.1%。胸片呈假阴性的原因包括结节的大小、位置、密度及形态。6名医师对于≤30 mm、≤20 mm、≤15 mm、≤10 mm结节的检出敏感度依次为46.5%~58.1%、45.9%~54.1%、36.0%~44.0%、36.4%;诊断正确率依次为19.0%~85.0%、16.7%~6.5%、18.2%~80.0%、0~75.0%。6名医师对于结节检出的一致性较好(Kappa值:0.629~0.907),性质判断的一致性一般或较差(Kappa值:0.350~0.653)。年资越高的医师所需的阅片时间越短,阅片时间、阅片经验与诊断正确率无关(均P>0.05)。 结论: 胸片对于≤30 mm肺结节的检出能力有限,性质判断能力不足,且阅片时间的延长、阅片者年资的增长均不会提高诊断正确率,不宜单独用于肺癌的诊断。.
引用
- Liang M, Zhao SJ, Zhou LN, et al. [The performance of digital chest radiographs in the detection and diagnosis of pulmonary nodules and the consistency among readers]. Zhonghua Zhong Liu Za Zhi. 2023. PMID: 36944548. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112152-20220304-00150
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。