文献速递骨软组织肉瘤与黑色素瘤

黑色素瘤宽局部切除术(WLE)切缘的终结?

The end of wide local excision (WLE) margins for melanoma ?
PubMed 文献 · Eur J Cancer · 2022-11-02

本文探讨I/II期皮肤黑色素瘤是否仍需常规宽局部切除术(WLE)。六项大型前瞻性随机试验均未显示WLE与更宽切除对总生存(OS)有影响。文献检索仅找到一项回顾性研究,校正混杂因素后OS无差异;病理研究显示WLE标本残留黑色素瘤发生率低(0-4.2%)。作者建议开展前瞻性随机试验比较经典两步法与仅完整诊断性切除。

要点

  • 六项大型前瞻性随机试验均未显示WLE与更宽切除对OS有影响。
  • 仅一项回顾性研究,校正混杂因素后OS无差异。
  • 病理研究显示WLE标本残留黑色素瘤发生率为0-4.2%。

核心结论

  • 没有可靠的前瞻性证据支持对诊断性切除活检已完全切除的原发性皮肤黑色素瘤采用WLE的两步法经典教条。
  • 作者建议设立并开展前瞻性随机试验,比较经典两步法WLE与仅完整诊断性切除,以期未来废除常规WLE实践。

研究设计与样本

  • 文献检索识别省略WLE后的结局数据,并从病理研究、改良手术技术结局及 morbidity 文献中收集间接证据。
  • 六项大型前瞻性随机试验研究了WLE与更宽WLE的比较。
  • 仅找到一项回顾性研究。

主要发现

  • 六项大型前瞻性随机试验均未能显示WLE对总生存(OS)有任何影响。
  • 回顾性研究在校正混杂因素后显示OS无差异。
  • 病理研究显示WLE标本中残留黑色素瘤的发生率低(0-4.2%)。
  • Mohs手术在复发率或OS方面未显示差异。
  • WLE与相当的术后并发症相关,且随切除边缘增宽而增加。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出常规临床推荐。
  • 作者建议设立并开展前瞻性随机试验,比较经典两步法WLE与仅完整诊断性切除。

局限性

  • 仅找到一项回顾性研究,无前瞻性研究。
  • 作者建议需开展前瞻性随机试验以验证。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

CLINICAL QUESTION: Is there nowadays any benefit of continuing the practice of routine wide local excision (WLE) for primary stage I/II cutaneous melanoma? BACKGROUND: WLE aims to eradicate potential microsatellites around melanomas and thereby reduce local recurrence rates and improve overall survival. Six large prospective randomised trials investigated WLE versus wider WLE, they all failed to show any effect on overall survival (OS). METHODS: A literature search was performed to identify data on outcome after omitting WLE. Additionally circumstantial evidence was gathered from pathology studies and outcomes of modified surgical techniques, as well as publications on morbidity. RESULTS: No prospective and one retrospective study was found. The retrospective study showed no difference in OS after correction for confounding factors. Pathology studies showed a low incidence of residual melanoma in WLE specimen (0-4.2%). Mohs surgery does not show a difference in recurrence rates or OS. WLE is associated with considerable postoperative morbidity, which increases with wider excision margins. CONCLUSION: There is no solid prospective evidence to support the classic dogma of a 2-step approach with the use of WLE for primary cutaneous melanoma that has been completely excised on diagnostic excision biopsy. We recommend to setup and conduct a prospective randomised trial to compare the classical 2-step approach with WLE to a complete diagnostic excision only to abolish the routine practice of WLE in the future.

来源:Eur J Cancer,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Zijlker LP, Eggermont AMM, van Akkooi ACJ, et al. The end of wide local excision (WLE) margins for melanoma ? Eur J Cancer. 2022. PMID: 36423526. doi:10.1016/j.ejca.2022.10.028

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。