N-13氨PET单组织室模型心肌灌注定量:三种软件交叉比较
该研究以48例肥厚型心肌病患者的负荷N-13氨PET图像为对象,在三个中心用Carimas、FlowQuant和PMOD软件进行全局、区域和节段水平的心肌血流量定量交叉比较。采用单组织室模型(1TCM)时,全局水平一致性良好(最大差异17.2%,ICC=0.83),区域水平除LCx区域外一致性可接受,节段水平变异较大。Carimas与PMOD和FlowQuant在1TCM实现上可互换使用。
要点
- 1TCM全局MBF在三种软件间一致性良好,最大差异17.2%,ICC=0.83。
- 区域水平除LCx区域(差异25.5%,ICC=0.74)外一致性可接受。
- Carimas与PMOD和FlowQuant在1TCM全局、区域、节段水平均可互换使用。
核心结论
- 全局和区域(除一个例外)MBF值在三种软件包间一致性良好,节段值变异显著,主要位于LCx区域和节段。
- Carimas在1TCM实现上可在全局、区域和节段所有水平与PMOD和FlowQuant互换使用。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入48例肥厚型心肌病(HCM)患者的负荷N-13氨PET扫描,在三个中心分别用Carimas、FlowQuant和PMOD软件进行分析。
- 一致性判定标准为ICC>0.75且差异小于所有观察者中位数的20%。
主要发现
- 使用1TCM在全局水平一致性良好,1TCM MBF值间最大差异为17.2%(ICC=0.83)。
- 区域水平一致性可接受,但FlowQuant与PMOD之间在LCx区域差异为25.5%(ICC=0.74)。
- Carimas-1TCM与PMOD-1TCM和FlowQuant-1TCM一致性良好。
- FlowQuant-1TCM与PMOD-1TCM一致性稍差,尤其在节段水平。
关键数值与推荐
- 一致性标准:ICC>0.75且差异小于所有观察者中位数的20%。
- 全局水平1TCM MBF最大差异17.2%(ICC=0.83)。
- LCx区域FlowQuant与PMOD间差异25.5%(ICC=0.74)。
临床怎么用
- 在HCM患者的N-13氨PET心肌灌注定量中,1TCM全局和区域MBF值可在不同软件间比较,但节段值尤其是LCx区域需谨慎解读。
- Carimas可与PMOD和FlowQuant在1TCM所有水平互换使用,便于多中心数据比较。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: To cross-compare three software packages (SPs)-Carimas, FlowQuant, and PMOD-to quantify myocardial perfusion at global, regional, and segmental levels. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Stress N-13 ammonia PET scans of 48 patients with HCM were analyzed in three centers using Carimas, FlowQuant, and PMOD. Values agreed if they had an ICC > 0.75 and a difference < 20% of the median across all observers. RESULTS: When using 1TCM on the global level, the agreement was good, and the maximum difference between 1TCM MBF values was 17.2% (ICC = 0.83). On the regional level, the agreement was acceptable except in the LCx region (25.5% difference, ICC = 0.74) between FlowQuant and PMOD. Carimas-1TCM agreed well with PMOD-1TCM and FlowQuant-1TCM. Values obtained with FlowQuant-1TCM had a somewhat lesser agreement with PMOD-1TCM, especially at the segmental level. CONCLUSIONS: The global and regional MBF values (with one exception) agree well between the different software packages. There is significant variability in segmental values, mainly located in the LCx region and segments. Out of the studied tools, Carimas can be used interchangeably with both PMOD and FlowQuant for 1TCM implementation on all levels-global, regional, and segmental.
引用
- Nesterov SV, Sciagrà R, Orozco LEJ, et al. One-tissue compartment model for myocardial perfusion quantification with N-13 ammonia PET provides matching results: A cross-comparison between Carimas, FlowQuant, and PMOD. J Nucl Cardiol. 2021. PMID: 34409572. doi:10.1007/s12350-021-02741-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。