两种半自动人工智能PET肿瘤分割方法的重测重复性比较
本研究在肺癌PET数据集上训练、验证并测试基于纹理特征(TF)和卷积神经网络(CNN)的两种半自动AI分割方法,并在独立的重测数据集上与MV2、MV3、41%SUVMAX及SUV4等传统方法比较重复性。两种AI方法的重测系数和组内相关系数均优于多数传统方法,且分割准确度良好,适合用于PET肿瘤分割。
要点
- AI分割方法(TF与CNN)的重测重复性优于多数传统半自动分割方法。
- TF与CNN分割与参考分割的Jaccard系数中位数分别为0.7和0.73,准确度良好。
- CNN的ICC为0.99,TF为0.98,均达到优秀重复性标准(ICC>0.9)。
核心结论
- 本研究所用的半自动AI分割方法比传统分割方法具有更好的重测重复性,且对原发肿瘤和转移灶均能实现准确分割,是PET肿瘤分割的良好候选方法。
研究设计与样本
- 研究比较两种半自动AI分割方法(基于纹理特征的TF分割和卷积神经网络CNN)与传统半自动分割方法的重测重复性,算法在肺癌PET数据集上训练、验证和测试,并在完全独立的重测数据集上进行外部测试。
主要发现
- 与参考分割相比,TF和CNN的Jaccard系数中位数分别为0.7和0.73。
- 重测系数均值:TF为13.0%,CNN为13.9%,MV2为14.1%,MV3为28.1%,41%SUVMAX为28.1%,SUV4为18.1%。
- 组内相关系数:TF为0.98,MV2为0.97,CNN为0.99,MV3为0.73,SUV4为0.81,41%SUVMAX为0.68。
关键数值与推荐
- 以ICC>0.9视为优秀重复性。
- 重测重复性采用重测系数(TRT%)和组内相关系数(ICC)评估。
- 分割准确度采用Jaccard系数(JC)比较。
临床怎么用
- 在需要从PET图像提取代谢活性肿瘤体积(MATV)、总MATV(TMATV)或总病灶糖酵解用于预后评估或疗效评价时,可优先考虑重复性更优的AI分割方法。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Positron emission tomography (PET) is routinely used for cancer staging and treatment follow-up. Metabolic active tumor volume (MATV) as well as total MATV (TMATV-including primary tumor, lymph nodes and metastasis) and/or total lesion glycolysis derived from PET images have been identified as prognostic factor or for the evaluation of treatment efficacy in cancer patients. To this end, a segmentation approach with high precision and repeatability is important. However, the implementation of a repeatable and accurate segmentation algorithm remains an ongoing challenge. METHODS: In this study, we compare two semi-automatic artificial intelligence (AI)-based segmentation methods with conventional semi-automatic segmentation approaches in terms of repeatability. One segmentation approach is based on a textural feature (TF) segmentation approach designed for accurate and repeatable segmentation of primary tumors and metastasis. Moreover, a convolutional neural network (CNN) is trained. The algorithms are trained, validated and tested using a lung cancer PET dataset. The segmentation accuracy of both segmentation approaches is compared using the Jaccard coefficient (JC). Additionally, the approaches are externally tested on a fully independent test-retest dataset. The repeatability of the methods is compared with those of two majority vote (MV2, MV3) approaches, 41%SUVMAX, and a SUV > 4 segmentation (SUV4). Repeatability is assessed with test-retest coefficients (TRT%) and intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC). An ICC > 0.9 was regarded as representing excellent repeatability. RESULTS: The accuracy of the segmentations with the reference segmentation was good (JC median TF: 0.7, CNN: 0.73). Both segmentation approaches outperformed most other conventional segmentation methods in terms of test-retest coefficient (TRT% mean: TF: 13.0%, CNN: 13.9%, MV2: 14.1%, MV3: 28.1%, 41%SUVMAX: 28.1%, SUV4: 18.1%) and ICC (TF: 0.98, MV2: 0.97, CNN: 0.99, MV3: 0.73, SUV4: 0.81, and 41%SUVMAX: 0.68). CONCLUSION: The semi-automatic AI-based segmentation approaches used in this study provided better repeatability than conventional segmentation approaches. Moreover, both algorithms lead to accurate segmentations for both primary tumors as well as metastasis and are therefore good candidates for PET tumor segmentation.
引用
- Pfaehler E, Mesotten L, Kramer G, et al. Repeatability of two semi-automatic artificial intelligence approaches for tumor segmentation in PET. EJNMMI Res. 2021. PMID: 33409747. doi:10.1186/s13550-020-00744-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。