四种正电子发射体与三套临床前PET/CT系统的图像质量评估
本研究用NEMA图像质量模体和分析方案,在三套小动物PET/CT系统上评估¹¹C、⁶⁸Ga、¹⁸F和⁸⁹Zr的图像质量。结果显示¹⁸F的NEMA图像质量参数最优,¹¹C和⁸⁹Zr略差,⁶⁸Ga因正电子射程大表现最差;图像定量误差较大,提示需优化定量校准与协调方案。
要点
- ¹⁸F的NEMA图像质量参数最优,¹¹C和⁸⁹Zr略差于¹⁸F。
- ⁶⁸Ga因正电子射程大,图像质量表现最差,最大%RC低于62%。
- 图像定量误差较大,最大误差达22.73%(⁸⁹Zr,Inveon)。
核心结论
- 使用¹⁸F时各系统NEMA图像质量参数表现最优,¹¹C和⁸⁹Zr略差于¹⁸F,⁶⁸Ga因正电子射程大表现最差。
- 图像定量存在较大差异,提示不仅需优化图像质量还需优化定量,需进一步研究合适的校准与协调方案并在多扫描仪多中心层面评估。
研究设计与样本
- 研究使用三套小动物PET/CT系统(Siemens Inveon、RAYCAN X5和Molecubes β-cube)评估¹¹C、⁶⁸Ga、¹⁸F和⁸⁹Zr的图像质量。
- 评估在单扫描仪层面使用NEMA图像质量模体和分析方案进行,¹⁸F采用标准NEMA协议采集,¹¹C、⁶⁸Ga和⁸⁹Zr采用放射性核素特异性采集时间。
- 图像评估指标包括百分比恢复系数(%RC)、百分比标准差(%STD)、图像均匀性(%SD)、溢出比(SOR)和图像定量评估。
主要发现
- ⁶⁸Ga在所有系统上%RC最低(<62%)。
- ¹⁸F在所有系统上最大%RC最高(>85%)且5 mm rod的%STD最低。
- ¹¹C和⁸⁹Zr的最大%RC接近¹⁸F(>76%)。
- 在所有系统上,¹¹C和⁶⁸Ga在水中的SOR较¹⁸F更大,空气中的SOR反映了图像重建和数据校正性能。
- 图像定量观察到较大差异,最大误差分别为22.73%(⁸⁹Zr,Inveon)、17.54%(⁸⁹Zr,RAYCAN)和-14.87%(⁶⁸Ga,Molecubes)。
关键数值与推荐
- ⁶⁸Ga在所有系统上%RC低于62%。
- ¹⁸F在所有系统上最大%RC高于85%且5 mm rod的%STD最低。
- ¹¹C和⁸⁹Zr的最大%RC高于76%,接近¹⁸F。
- 最大定量误差为22.73%(⁸⁹Zr,Inveon)、17.54%(⁸⁹Zr,RAYCAN)和-14.87%(⁶⁸Ga,Molecubes)。
临床怎么用
- 临床前PET/CT图像质量与定量评估应关注所用正电子发射体的正电子射程差异,⁶⁸Ga图像质量参数最差需注意。
- 图像定量存在较大误差,提示需建立合适的校准与协调方案,并在多扫描仪多中心层面进一步评估。
局限性
- 评估在单扫描仪层面进行,未在多扫描仪和多中心层面验证。
- 研究未确定合适的校准与协调方案,需进一步研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: We investigated the image quality of 11C, 68Ga, 18F and 89Zr, which have different positron fractions, physical half-lifes and positron ranges. Three small animal positron emission tomography/computed tomography (PET/CT) systems were used in the evaluation, including the Siemens Inveon, RAYCAN X5 and Molecubes β-cube. The evaluation was performed on a single scanner level using the national electrical manufacturers association (NEMA) image quality phantom and analysis protocol. Acquisitions were performed with the standard NEMA protocol for 18F and using a radionuclide-specific acquisition time for 11C, 68Ga and 89Zr. Images were assessed using percent recovery coefficient (%RC), percentage standard deviation (%STD), image uniformity (%SD), spill-over ratio (SOR) and evaluation of image quantification. RESULTS: 68Ga had the lowest %RC (< 62%) across all systems. 18F had the highest maximum %RC (> 85%) and lowest %STD for the 5 mm rod across all systems. For 11C and 89Zr, the maximum %RC was close (> 76%) to the %RC with 18F. A larger SOR were measured in water with 11C and 68Ga compared to 18F on all systems. SOR in air reflected image reconstruction and data correction performance. Large variation in image quantification was observed, with maximal errors of 22.73% (89Zr, Inveon), 17.54% (89Zr, RAYCAN) and - 14.87% (68Ga, Molecubes). CONCLUSIONS: The systems performed most optimal in terms of NEMA image quality parameters when using 18F, where 11C and 89Zr performed slightly worse than 18F. The performance was least optimal when using 68Ga, due to large positron range. The large quantification differences prompt optimization not only by terms of image quality but also quantification. Further investigation should be performed to find an appropriate calibration and harmonization protocol and the evaluation should be conducted on a multi-scanner and multi-center level.
引用
- Teuho J, Riehakainen L, Honkaniemi A, et al. Evaluation of image quality with four positron emitters and three preclinical PET/CT systems. EJNMMI Res. 2020. PMID: 33301074. doi:10.1186/s13550-020-00724-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。