文献速递神经核医学

两种三维自动工具在纹状体多巴胺转运体SPECT定量中的头对头比较

Striatal dopamine transporter SPECT quantification: head-to-head comparison between two three-dimensional automatic tools.
PubMed 文献 · EJNMMI Res · 2020-11-07

两种软件在SBR、壳核/尾状核比值及不对称性上高度相关,与专家读片的一致率分别为84.1%和80.8%,加入P/C比值后分别提升至94.0%和86.1%。

要点

  • Datquant®与专家读片一致率84.1%,加入P/C比值后达94.0%。
  • BasGanV2与专家读片一致率80.8%,加入P/C比值后达86.1%。

核心结论

  • Datquant®与BasGanV2在DAT SPECT半定量中表现合理且彼此相似。
  • 两种工具各有优缺点,用户需详细了解以辅助视觉读片和报告。

研究设计与样本

  • 图像分别用商用软件Datquant®和免费软件BasGanV2后处理,以专家读片为金标准。
  • 对病理或临界扫描的子集患者评估MDS-UPDRS-III运动评分。

主要发现

  • 与MDS-UPDRS-III评分的相关系数尾状核SBR高于壳核SBR,且BasGanV2总体高于Datquant®。
  • Datquant®与专家读片一致率84.1%,额外考虑P/C比值后为94.0%。
  • BasGanV2与专家读片一致率80.8%,额外考虑P/C比值后为86.1%。

关键数值与推荐

  • Datquant®与专家读片一致率84.1%(仅常规指标),加入P/C比值后94.0%。
  • BasGanV2与专家读片一致率80.8%(仅常规指标),加入P/C比值后86.1%。

临床怎么用

  • 两种软件均可用于DAT SPECT半定量辅助视觉读片,但需了解各自优缺点。
  • 将P/C比值作为附加指标可提高与专家读片的一致率。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

PURPOSE: Our aim was to compare a widely distributed commercial tool with an older free software (i) one another, (ii) with a clinical motor score, (iii) versus reading by experts. PROCEDURES: We analyzed consecutive scans from one-hundred and fifty-one outpatients submitted to brain DAT SPECT for a suspected parkinsonism. Images were post-processed using a commercial (Datquant®) and a free (BasGanV2) software. Reading by expert was the gold standard. A subset of patients with pathological or borderline scan was evaluated with the clinical Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale, motor part (MDS-UPDRS-III). RESULTS: SBR, putamen-to-caudate (P/C) ratio, and both P and C asymmetries were highly correlated between the two software with Pearson's 'r' correlation coefficients ranging from .706 to .887. Correlation coefficients with the MDS-UPDRS III score were higher with caudate than with putamen SBR values with both software, and in general higher with BasGanV2 than with Datquant®. Datquant® correspondence with expert reading was 84.1% (94.0% by additionally considering the P/C ratio as a further index). BasGanV2 correspondence with expert reading was 80.8% (86.1% by additionally considering the P/C ratio). CONCLUSIONS: Both Datquant® and BasGanV2 work reasonably well and similarly one another in semi-quantification of DAT SPECT. Both tools have their own strength and pitfalls that must be known in detail by users in order to obtain the best help in visual reading and reporting of DAT SPECT.

来源:EJNMMI Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Morbelli S, Arnaldi D, Cella E, et al. Striatal dopamine transporter SPECT quantification: head-to-head comparison between two three-dimensional automatic tools. EJNMMI Res. 2020. PMID: 33159607. doi:10.1186/s13550-020-00727-w

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。