平面与断层焦磷酸盐显像诊断转甲状腺素蛋白心脏淀粉样变的比较:风险与陷阱
该研究评估133例患者(53%男性,平均年龄76岁)的Tc-99m PYP显像数据,所有患者均在1小时平面显像后常规行SPECT。以SPECT心肌摄取为参照,平面半定量视觉评分与SPECT相关性好(r=0.94,P<.0001),准确率98%,但会误判少数患者;H/CL比值降低平面诊断确定性,断层显像应始终进行。
要点
- 平面视觉评分与SPECT心肌摄取相关性好(r=0.94),准确率98%。
- 平面显像会误判少数患者,SPECT可纠正误诊。
- H/CL比值降低平面视觉评分的诊断性能。
核心结论
- 平面衍生的视觉评分对断层心肌摄取有极好准确率,但会误分类小部分患者。
- H/CL比值降低平面显像的诊断确定性。
- 断层显像可防止误诊,应始终进行。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性评估133例患者(53%男性;平均年龄76岁)的PYP显像数据。
- 所有患者均在1小时平面显像后常规行SPECT。
- 按推荐方法确定半定量视觉评分和H/CL比值。
主要发现
- 35例(26%)基于SPECT心肌摄取被认为阳性。
- 其中20例(57%)H/CL比值≥1.5,34例视觉评分≥2。
- SPECT识别出1例视觉评分<2患者的心肌摄取,并排除2例视觉评分≥2患者的心肌摄取。
- 视觉评分与SPECT相关性好(r=0.94;P<.0001),对断层心肌摄取准确率98%。
- 加入H/CL比值降低了视觉评分的诊断性能。
关键数值与推荐
- SPECT阳性判定基于心肌摄取。
- H/CL比值≥1.5见于20例(57%)SPECT阳性患者。
- 视觉评分≥2见于34例SPECT阳性患者。
- 视觉评分与SPECT相关系数r=0.94(P<.0001),准确率98%。
临床怎么用
- 平面PYP显像视觉评分可用于初筛,但不应单独用于诊断。
- 对平面显像结果不确定或视觉评分与临床不符时,应行SPECT断层显像。
- H/CL比值可能降低平面诊断确定性,需结合断层显像综合判断。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Tc-99m pyrophosphate (PYP) SPECT is recommended for indeterminate findings on planar imaging. We aimed to compare the findings on planar PYP scintigraphy alone to that of routinely performed PYP SPECT. METHODS: PYP scintigraphy data of 133 patients (53% men; mean age 76 years) were evaluated. SPECT was routinely performed following 1-hour planar imaging, in all cases. Semiquantitative visual score and heart-to-contralateral (H/CL) ratio were determined in all patients as recommended. RESULTS: PYP images from 35 patients (26%) were considered to be positive based on SPECT myocardial uptake. Among them, 20 (57%) had a H/CL ratio ≥1.5 and 34 had a visual score ≥ 2. SPECT identified myocardial uptake in one patient with a visual score < 2 and refuted the presence of myocardial uptake in two patients with a visual score ≥ 2. Visual score correlated well with SPECT (r = 0.94; P < .0001) and had an accuracy of 98% for tomographic myocardial uptake. Addition of H/CL ratio reduced the diagnostic performance of visual score. CONCLUSIONS: Planar-derived visual score has an excellent accuracy for tomographic myocardial uptake, though it misclassifies a small proportion of patients. H/CL ratio decreases the diagnostic certainty of planar imaging. Tomographic imaging prevents misdiagnoses and should always be performed.
引用
- Asif T, Gomez J, Singh V, et al. Comparison of planar with tomographic pyrophosphate scintigraphy for transthyretin cardiac amyloidosis: Perils and pitfalls. J Nucl Cardiol. 2020. PMID: 32901418. doi:10.1007/s12350-020-02328-5
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。