锝-99m-焦磷酸盐闪烁显像诊断ATTR心脏淀粉样变性:定量与半定量方法的比较
该研究回顾了122例连续受试者的锝-99m-焦磷酸盐扫描,比较1小时定量心脏与对侧肺比值(H/CL)法与3小时半定量视觉分级法,并尝试将半定量法应用于1小时图像。定量法导致不确定结果的比例显著高于半定量法(P<.0001),两种方法在2例受试者中结果不一致,活检结果与SPECT分级一致。1小时与3小时SPECT分级在99%的病例中结果一致。
要点
- 定量H/CL法产生不确定结果的比例显著高于半定量SPECT分级法(P<.0001)。
- 1小时与3小时SPECT半定量分级在99%的病例中结果一致。
- 两种方法仅在2例受试者中结果不一致,活检结果与SPECT分级一致。
核心结论
- H/CL定量法导致高比例的不确定研究结果。
- 使用SPECT显像时,半定量法将这一比例最小化,并在1小时与3小时显示高度一致性。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析122例连续受试者的锝-99m-焦磷酸盐扫描,同时使用定量H/CL法与半定量视觉分级法,并在1小时和3小时SPECT图像上按半定量法进行心肌摄取分级。
主要发现
- 使用H/CL法,31例为阳性、10例为阴性、81例为不确定。
- 使用分级系统,35例扫描为阳性、77例为阴性、10例为不确定。
- 定量法导致不确定研究比例显著高于半定量法(P<.0001)。
- 两种方法在2例受试者中结果不一致,活检结果与SPECT分级一致。
- 1小时与3小时SPECT分级在99%的病例中结果一致。
关键数值与推荐
- H/CL法:31例阳性、10例阴性、81例不确定。
- 半定量分级系统:35例阳性、77例阴性、10例不确定。
- 定量法与半定量法不确定比例比较P<.0001。
- 1小时与3小时SPECT分级一致率99%。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: ATTR cardiac amyloidosis (CA) can be diagnosed with Tc-99m-PYP scintigraphy. There are two recommended interpretative approaches: the quantitative heart-to-contralateral lung ratio (H/CL) at 1 hour and the semi-quantitative visual system at 3 hours. This study's aim was to compare both approaches and to apply the semi-quantitative method at 1 hour. METHODS: Tc-99m-PYP scans of 122 consecutive subjects were reviewed using both approaches. On 1 hour planar images, regions of interest were drawn over the heart and contralateral chest to determine H/CL. Myocardial uptake was graded on 1 and 3 hour SPECT images according to the semi-quantitative method. Concordance was examined using kappa statistics. RESULTS: 31, 10, and 81 studies were positive, negative, and equivocal, respectively, for ATTR-CA using the H/CL approach. Using the grading system, 35, 77, and 10 scans were positive, negative, and equivocal, respectively. The quantitative approach led to a significantly higher proportion of equivocal studies compared to the semi-quantitative approach (P < .0001). These approaches yielded discordant results in 2 subjects; biopsy results were concordant with SPECT grade. 1 and 3 hour SPECT grades provided concordant result in 99% of cases. CONCLUSIONS: The H/CL approach resulted in a high proportion of equivocal studies. Using SPECT imaging, the semi-quantitative approach minimized this proportion and showed high concordance at 1 and 3 hours.
引用
- Régis C, Harel F, Martineau P, et al. Tc-99m-pyrophosphate scintigraphy for the diagnosis of ATTR cardiac amyloidosis: Comparison of quantitative and semi-quantitative approaches. J Nucl Cardiol. 2020. PMID: 32476105. doi:10.1007/s12350-020-02205-1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。