基于深度学习与手动调整的全肝分割用于SIRT的临床实践
本研究改良多尺度卷积神经网络(CNN)用于SIRT患者CT肝脏分割,训练集含139个分割挑战数据集和12个本院SIRT数据集,验证集13个SIRT数据集和12个挑战数据集,测试集40个SIRT数据集。CNN分割与手动分割的中位DSC为0.94,与手动校正CNN分割的中位DSC为0.98;校正分割间DSC为0.98,较手动分割间DSC高0.04。40例CNN分割中87.5%仅需轻微调整即可临床使用。
要点
- CNN肝分割与手动分割中位DSC达0.94,与手动校正CNN分割中位DSC达0.98。
- 校正分割间DSC为0.98,较手动分割间DSC高0.04,观察者间一致性提高。
- 40例CNN分割中87.5%仅需轻微调整即可用于临床。
核心结论
- CNN模型在图像质量好、肝脏形态相对正常且肿瘤负荷低的CT图像上获得良好肝分割。
- 40例CNN分割中87.5%仅需轻微调整即可用于临床。
- 训练模型在低剂量或低对比度SIRT数据、与周围密度差异大的病灶以及肝脏位置和形态异常时失败。
- 上述场景在训练数据中未充分代表。
- 当前CNN已是提高观察者间一致性并促进剂量学标准化的有用临床工具。
研究设计与样本
- 改良多尺度CNN用于SIRT患者肝脏分割。
- CNN模型用来自三个肝脏分割挑战的139个数据集和本院12个SIRT患者数据集训练。
- 在13个SIRT数据集和12个挑战数据集上验证。
- 在40个SIRT数据集上测试。
- 一位专家手动勾画肝脏并调整40个测试SIRT数据集的CNN肝分割。
主要发现
- CNN分割与手动分割的中位DSC为0.94。
- CNN分割与手动校正CNN分割的中位DSC为0.98。
- 校正分割间DSC为0.98,较手动分割间DSC高0.04。
- 40例CNN分割中87.5%仅需轻微调整即可用于临床。
关键数值与推荐
- 分割差异通过DSC、体积比(RV)、平均表面距离(MSD)和Hausdorff距离(HD)评估。
- CNN分割与手动分割的中位DSC为0.94。
- CNN分割与手动校正CNN分割的中位DSC为0.98。
- 校正分割间DSC为0.98,较手动分割间DSC高0.04。
- 40例CNN分割中87.5%仅需轻微调整即可用于临床。
临床怎么用
- 当前CNN已是提高观察者间一致性并促进剂量学标准化的有用临床工具。
局限性
- 训练模型在低剂量或低对比度SIRT数据、与周围密度差异大的病灶以及肝脏位置和形态异常时失败。
- 上述场景在训练数据中未充分代表。
- 用更多SIRT患者数据训练CNN后有望进一步改善。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: In selective internal radiation therapy (SIRT), an accurate total liver segmentation is required for activity prescription and absorbed dose calculation. Our goal was to investigate the feasibility of using automatic liver segmentation based on a convolutional neural network (CNN) for CT imaging in SIRT, and the ability of CNN to reduce inter-observer variability of the segmentation. METHODS: A multi-scale CNN was modified for liver segmentation for SIRT patients. The CNN model was trained with 139 datasets from three liver segmentation challenges and 12 SIRT patient datasets from our hospital. Validation was performed on 13 SIRT datasets and 12 challenge datasets. The model was tested on 40 SIRT datasets. One expert manually delineated the livers and adjusted the liver segmentations from CNN for 40 test SIRT datasets. Another expert performed the same tasks for 20 datasets randomly selected from the 40 SIRT datasets. The CNN segmentations were compared with the manual and adjusted segmentations from the experts. The difference between the manual segmentations was compared with the difference between the adjusted segmentations to investigate the inter-observer variability. Segmentation difference was evaluated through dice similarity coefficient (DSC), volume ratio (RV), mean surface distance (MSD), and Hausdorff distance (HD). RESULTS: The CNN segmentation achieved a median DSC of 0.94 with the manual segmentation and of 0.98 with the manually corrected CNN segmentation, respectively. The DSC between the adjusted segmentations is 0.98, which is 0.04 higher than the DSC between the manual segmentations. CONCLUSION: The CNN model achieved good liver segmentations on CT images of good image quality, with relatively normal liver shapes and low tumor burden. 87.5% of the 40 CNN segmentations only needed slight adjustments for clinical use. However, the trained model failed on SIRT data with low dose or contrast, lesions with large density difference from their surroundings, and abnormal liver position and shape. The abovementioned scenarios were not adequately represented in the training data. Despite this limitation, the current CNN is already a useful clinical tool which improves inter-observer agreement and therefore contributes to the standardization of the dosimetry. A further improvement is expected when the CNN will be trained with more data from SIRT patients.
引用
- Tang X, Jafargholi Rangraz E, Coudyzer W, et al. Whole liver segmentation based on deep learning and manual adjustment for clinical use in SIRT. Eur J Nucl Med Mol Imaging. 2020. PMID: 32314026. doi:10.1007/s00259-020-04800-3
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。