数据驱动呼吸门控在临床18F-FDG PET/CT中优于设备门控
研究纳入144例全身18F-FDG PET/CT检查,比较数据驱动门控(DDG-retro)与外部设备门控(RPM)及无门控重建。DDG-retro较RPM门控平均提高SUVmax 0.66±0.1 g/mL(n=87,P<0.0005),盲法评估中13%检查偏好DDG-retro而仅2%偏好RPM(P=0.008,n=121)。外部设备门控在16%检查中失败,而DDG-retro始终提供临床可接受的图像。
要点
- DDG-retro较RPM门控平均提高SUVmax 0.66±0.1 g/mL(n=87,P<0.0005)。
- 盲法评估中DDG-retro在13%检查中被偏好,RPM仅2%(P=0.008,n=121)。
- 外部设备门控在16%检查中失败,DDG-retro始终提供临床可接受图像。
核心结论
- 在该临床评估中,DDG-retro表现优于外部设备门控系统;多数检查两者等效,但DDG-retro在13%检查中表现更优,导致总体显著偏好。
研究设计与样本
- 共采集144例全身18F-FDG PET/CT检查,每例中覆盖肝脏和肺底的两个床位采集6分钟,并记录外部设备呼吸门控波形。
- 每例进行4种重建比较:DDG-retro、RPM门控、仅用前3分钟数据的无门控匹配(ungated-matched)和保留全部符合事件的无门控(ungated-full)。
- 由对处理方式设盲的放射科医生对病灶进行定量和图像质量评分。
主要发现
- 与其他重建选项相比,DDG-retro提高SUVmax并降低阈值定义的病灶体积。
- 较RPM门控,DDG-retro平均提高SUVmax 0.66±0.1 g/mL(n=87,P<0.0005)。
- 盲法图像评估结果最常见为等效,但DDG-retro在13%检查中被偏好,而RPM在2%检查中被偏好(P=0.008,n=121)。
- 23例检查中识别出肝脏病灶,该亚组中DDG-retro在6/23(26%)例中排名优于ungated-full。
- 外部设备门控重建在16%检查中失败,而DDG-retro始终提供临床可接受的图像。
关键数值与推荐
- 静息期门控保留约50%符合事件,使这两个床位有效采集时间为3分钟,与其他床位匹配。
- DDG-retro较RPM门控平均提高SUVmax 0.66±0.1 g/mL(n=87,P<0.0005)。
- DDG-retro被偏好13% vs RPM被偏好2%(P=0.008,n=121)。
- 肝脏病灶亚组中DDG-retro在6/23(26%)例排名优于ungated-full。
- 外部设备门控失败率16%,DDG-retro始终提供临床可接受图像。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
A data-driven method for respiratory gating in PET has recently been commercially developed. We sought to compare the performance of the algorithm with an external, device-based system for oncologic 18F-FDG PET/CT imaging. Methods: In total, 144 whole-body 18F-FDG PET/CT examinations were acquired, with a respiratory gating waveform recorded by an external, device-based respiratory gating system. In each examination, 2 of the bed positions covering the liver and lung bases were acquired with a duration of 6 min. Quiescent-period gating retaining approximately 50% of coincidences was then able to produce images with an effective duration of 3 min for these 2 bed positions, matching the other bed positions. For each examination, 4 reconstructions were performed and compared: data-driven gating (DDG) (we use the term DDG-retro to distinguish that we did not use the real-time R-threshold-based application of DDG that is available within the manufacturer's product), external device-based gating (real-time position management (RPM)-gated), no gating but using only the first 3 min of data (ungated-matched), and no gating retaining all coincidences (ungated-full). Lesions in the images were quantified and image quality scored by a radiologist who was masked to the method of data processing. Results: Compared with the other reconstruction options, DDG-retro increased the SUVmax and decreased the threshold-defined lesion volume. Compared with RPM-gated, DDG-retro gave an average increase in SUVmax of 0.66 ± 0.1 g/mL (n = 87, P < 0.0005). Although the results from the masked image evaluation were most commonly equivalent, DDG-retro was preferred over RPM-gated in 13% of examinations, whereas the opposite occurred in just 2% of examinations. This was a significant preference for DDG-retro (P = 0.008, n = 121). Liver lesions were identified in 23 examinations. Considering this subset of data, DDG-retro was ranked superior to ungated-full in 6 of 23 (26%) cases. Gated reconstruction using the external device failed in 16% of examinations, whereas DDG-retro always provided a clinically acceptable image. Conclusion: In this clinical evaluation, DDG-retro provided performance superior to that of the external device-based system. For most examinations the performance was equivalent, but DDG-retro had superior performance in 13% of examinations, leading to a significant preference overall.
引用
- Walker MD, Morgan AJ, Bradley KM, et al. Data-Driven Respiratory Gating Outperforms Device-Based Gating for Clinical 18F-FDG PET/CT. J Nucl Med. 2020. PMID: 32245898. doi:10.2967/jnumed.120.242248
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。