前瞻性对比研究:通气-灌注平面显像与通气-灌注SPECT诊断慢性血栓栓塞性肺动脉高压
本研究在前瞻性疑似肺动脉高压患者中比较V/Q平面显像与V/Q SPECT诊断CTEPH的效能,并以肺动脉造影为参考标准。208例完成研究(含69例经肺动脉造影确诊CTEPH),三种方法诊断效能均高且敏感度、特异度无显著差异;但按肺段识别灌注缺损时V/Q SPECT敏感度显著更高,V/Q平面显像特异度显著更高。
要点
- V/Q平面显像、V/Q SPECT与Q-LDCT诊断CTEPH的敏感度和特异度无显著差异。
- 按肺段识别灌注缺损,V/Q SPECT敏感度显著高于平面显像和Q-LDCT。
- 按肺段识别灌注缺损,V/Q平面显像特异度显著高于V/Q SPECT和Q-LDCT。
核心结论
- V/Q平面显像与V/Q SPECT诊断CTEPH均高效,Q-LDCT可能是不适合通气显像患者的可靠替代方法。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究纳入疑似肺动脉高压患者,排除左心疾病或肺疾病所致肺动脉高压。
- 纳入经右心导管确诊肺动脉高压并完成V/Q平面显像、V/Q SPECT、Q-LDCT和肺动脉造影的患者。
- V/Q图像按2009年欧洲核医学协会指南判读,以肺动脉造影分析为参考标准。
- 共208例完成研究,其中69例经肺动脉造影确诊CTEPH。
主要发现
- V/Q平面显像诊断CTEPH的敏感度为94.20%、特异度为92.81%。
- V/Q SPECT诊断CTEPH的敏感度为97.10%、特异度为91.37%。
- Q-LDCT诊断CTEPH的敏感度为95.65%、特异度为90.65%。
- 三种技术诊断CTEPH的敏感度和特异度无显著差异。
- 按肺段识别灌注缺损:V/Q SPECT敏感度79.21% vs V/Q平面显像75.84%(P=0.012),V/Q SPECT vs Q-LDCT 74.91%(P<0.001)。
关键数值与推荐
- V/Q平面显像、V/Q SPECT和Q-LDCT诊断CTEPH的敏感度分别为94.20%、97.10%、95.65%。
- V/Q平面显像、V/Q SPECT和Q-LDCT诊断CTEPH的特异度分别为92.81%、91.37%、90.65%。
- 按肺段识别灌注缺损的敏感度:V/Q SPECT 79.21% vs V/Q平面显像75.84%(P=0.012),V/Q SPECT vs Q-LDCT 74.91%(P<0.001)。
- 按肺段识别灌注缺损的特异度:V/Q平面显像54.14% vs V/Q SPECT 46.05%(P<0.001),V/Q平面显像 vs Q-LDCT 46.05%(P=0.001)。
临床怎么用
- V/Q扫描被推荐用于肺动脉高压诊断过程中排除CTEPH。
- V/Q平面显像与V/Q SPECT诊断CTEPH均高效,Q-LDCT可能是不适合通气显像患者的可靠替代方法。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
This study compared the diagnostic performance of ventilation-perfusion (V/Q) planar imaging and V/Q SPECT and determined whether combining perfusion SPECT with low-dose CT (Q-LDCT) may be equally effective in a prospective study of patients with chronic thromboembolic pulmonary hypertension (CTEPH). V/Q scanning is recommended for excluding CTEPH during the diagnosis of pulmonary hypertension (PH). However, V/Q planar imaging and V/Q SPECT have yet to be compared in patients with CTEPH. Methods: Patients with suspected PH were eligible for the study. PH attributable to left heart disease or lung disease was excluded, and patients whose PH was confirmed by right heart catheterization and who completed V/Q planar imaging, V/Q SPECT, Q-LDCT, and pulmonary angiography were included. V/Q images were interpreted and patients were diagnosed as instructed by the 2009 European Association of Nuclear Medicine guidelines, and pulmonary angiography analyses were used as a reference standard. Results: A total of 208 patients completed the study, including 69 with CTEPH confirmed by pulmonary angiography. V/Q planar imaging, V/Q SPECT, and Q-LDCT were all highly effective for diagnosing CTEPH, with no significant differences in sensitivity or specificity observed among the 3 techniques (respective sensitivity and specificity: 94.20% and 92.81% for V/Q planar imaging, 97.10% and 91.37% for V/Q SPECT, and 95.65% and 90.65% for Q-LCDT). However, V/Q SPECT was significantly more sensitive (V/Q SPECT, 79.21%; V/Q planar imaging, 75.84% [P = 0.012]; Q-LDCT, 74.91% [P < 0.001]), and V/Q planar imaging was significantly more specific (V/Q planar imaging, 54.14%; V/Q SPECT, 46.05% [P < 0.001]; Q-LDCT, 46.05% [P = 0.001]) than the other 2 techniques for identifying perfusion defects in individual lung segments. Conclusion: Both V/Q planar imaging and V/Q SPECT were highly effective for diagnosing CTEPH, and Q-LDCT may be a reliable alternative method for patients who are unsuitable for ventilation imaging.
引用
- Wang L, Wang M, Yang T, et al. A Prospective, Comparative Study of Ventilation-Perfusion Planar Imaging and Ventilation-Perfusion SPECT for Chronic Thromboembolic Pulmonary Hypertension. J Nucl Med. 2020. PMID: 32198309. doi:10.2967/jnumed.120.243188
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。