加拿大医学影像试验网络多中心研究中99mTc-SPECT灌注成像的站点资质认定与临床判读标准
该研究在35台相机上采集静息-负荷99mTc-SPECT模体扫描,以右冠状动脉(RCA)区域SDS≥2为资质认定标准,由两个核心实验室定量评分;在合格相机上采集20例患者静息-负荷图像并由核心实验室判读。结果显示定量评分与判读在站点资质认定和临床判读标准化后具有高度可重复性,双核心实验室判读适用于确定99mTc-SPECT MPI的准确性。
要点
- 模体扫描中视觉评分在所有相机上确认RCA缺血,区域SSS与SDS一致性中等至很好(ICC-r=0.57、0.84)。
- 患者扫描中90%的整体SSS差异和85%的SDS差异≤3,整体异常(SSS≥4)与缺血(SDS≥2)判读ICC-r=0.90。
- 经审核后临床判读一致性为100%,图像质量一致性为70%。
核心结论
- 在站点资质认定和临床判读标准化后,扫描的定量评分和判读具有高度可重复性,表明双核心实验室判读适用于确定99mTc-SPECT MPI的准确性。
研究设计与样本
- 在35台相机上采集静息-负荷99mTc-SPECT模体扫描,由两个核心实验室定量评分,以右冠状动脉(RCA)区域SDS≥2为资质认定标准。
- 在合格相机上采集20例患者静息-负荷图像并由核心实验室判读,评估评分、判读、图像质量和诊断参数的一致性。
主要发现
- 模体扫描:视觉评分在所有相机上确认RCA缺血,区域SSS与SDS一致性中等至很好(ICC-r=0.57、0.84)。
- 患者扫描:90%的整体SSS差异和85%的SDS差异≤3。
- 患者扫描:区域SSS与SDS一致性ICC-r=0.87、0.86,整体异常(SSS≥4)与缺血(SDS≥2)判读ICC-r=0.90。
- 经审核后临床判读一致性为100%,图像质量一致性为70%。
- 自动指标一致性:缺血总灌注缺损ICC-r=0.75,可逆性灌注缺损、短暂性缺血性扩张和静息-负荷LV射血分数ICC-r≥0.90。
关键数值与推荐
- 资质认定标准为右冠状动脉(RCA)区域SDS≥2。
- 整体异常定义为SSS≥4,缺血定义为SDS≥2。
- 两核心实验室间整体评分差异>3或临床判读不一致时进行审核。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Qualification and interpretation standards are essential for establishing 99mTc-SPECT MPI accuracy vs. alternative modalities. METHODS: Rest-stress 99mTc-SPECT phantom scans were acquired on 35 cameras. LV defects were quantified with summed stress (SSS) and difference scores (SDS) at 2 core labs. SDS ≥ 2 in the right coronary artery (RCA) was the qualifying standard. Twenty rest (R)-stress (S) patient images were acquired on qualified cameras and interpreted by core labs. Global scoring differences > 3 between labs or discordant clinical interpretations underwent review. Scoring, interpretation, image quality, and diagnostic parameter agreement were assessed. RESULTS: Phantom scans: visual scoring confirmed RCA-ischemia on all cameras. Regional SSS, SDS agreement was moderate to very good: ICC-r = 0.57, 0.84. Patient scans: 90% of global SSS, 85% of SDS differences were ≤ 3. Regional SSS, SDS agreement: ICC-r = 0.87, 0.86, and global abnormal (SSS ≥ 4) and ischemic (SDS ≥ 2) interpretation: ICC-r = 0.90 were excellent. Clinical interpretation agreement was 100% following review. Image quality agreement was 70%. Automated metrics also agreed: ischemic total perfusion deficit ICC-r = 0.75, reversible perfusion defect, transient ischemic dilation, and S-R LV ejection fraction ICC-r ≥ 0.90. CONCLUSION: Quantitative scoring and interpretation of scans were highly repeatable with site qualification and clinical interpretation standardization, indicating that dual-core lab interpretation is appropriate to determine 99mTc-SPECT MPI accuracy.
引用
- Renaud JM, Premaratne M, Villeneuve MC, et al. Site qualification and clinical interpretation standards for 99mTc-SPECT perfusion imaging in a multi-center study of MITNEC (Medical Imaging Trials Network of Canada). J Nucl Cardiol. 2020. PMID: 32185684. doi:10.1007/s12350-020-02100-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。