高心率下CT与SPECT射血分数计算比较:动态心脏体模研究
本研究利用可编程舒张末期容积、收缩末期容积和心率的动态心脏体模,在心率≤100次/分、射血分数30(疾病状态)和60(健康状态)条件下比较CT与SPECT的射血分数计算。SPECT在40至100次/分时射血分数计算准确度为2%,且不依赖心率,但收缩末期容积和舒张末期容积可能被低估18-20%;CT在40和60次/分时射血分数计算准确度为2.2%。SPECT在心率≤100次/分时射血分数计算准确,CT在心率≤60次/分时准确,CT在80和100次/分高心率或射血分数60时准确性较低。
要点
- SPECT在40至100次/分时射血分数计算准确度为2%,且不依赖心率。
- CT在40和60次/分时射血分数计算准确度为2.2%。
- CT在80和100次/分高心率或射血分数60时准确性较低。
核心结论
- SPECT在心率≤100次/分时射血分数计算准确,CT在心率≤60次/分时准确。
- 心率或射血分数增高时,CT的射血分数计算、收缩末期容积和舒张末期容积估计的不准确性增加。
研究设计与样本
- 使用可编程收缩末期容积、舒张末期容积和心率的动态心脏体模,比较CT与SPECT在心率≤100次/分、射血分数30(疾病状态)和60(健康状态)条件下的射血分数、收缩末期容积和舒张末期容积计算。
- CT空间分辨率高(< 1 mm),时间分辨率为175毫秒;SPECT时间分辨率为每个心动周期16帧,空间分辨率差(> 1 cm)。
主要发现
- SPECT在40至100次/分时射血分数计算准确度为2%,且不依赖心率,但收缩末期容积和舒张末期容积可能被低估18-20%。
- CT在40和60次/分时射血分数计算准确度为2.2%。
- 心率或射血分数增高时,CT的射血分数计算、收缩末期容积和舒张末期容积估计的不准确性增加。
- CT在80和100次/分高心率或射血分数60时准确性较低。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The purpose of this study is to compare the ejection fraction (EF) calculation of CT and SPECT at high heart rate. A dynamic cardiac phantom with programmable end-systolic volume (ESV), end-diastolic volume (EDV), and heart rate was used to compare CT, which has high spatial resolution (< 1 mm) and modest temporal resolution of 175 msec, and SPECT, which has high temporal resolution of 16 bins per cardiac cycle but poor spatial resolution (> 1 cm) in EF, ESV, and EDV at the heart rates ≤ 100 bpm for EF = 30 (disease state) and EF = 60 (healthy state). EF calculations for SPECT were accurate in 2% for 40 to 100 bpm for both EF = 30 and EF = 60, and were not heart rate dependent although both ESV and EDV could be underestimated by 18-20%. EF calculations for CT were accurate in 2.2% for 40 and 60 bpm. Inaccuracy in EF calculations, ESV and EDV estimates increased when the heart rate or EF increased. SPECT was accurate for EF calculation for the heart rates ≤ 100 bpm and CT was accurate for the heart rates of ≤ 60 bpm. CT was less accurate for the high heart rates of 80 and 100 bpm, or high EF = 60.
引用
- Chen CC, Shen TY, Peterson CB, et al. Comparison of ejection fraction calculation between CT and SPECT at high heart rate: A dynamic cardiac phantom study. J Nucl Cardiol. 2020. PMID: 31907855. doi:10.1007/s12350-019-01991-7
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。