68Ga-PSMA11 PET三种判读标准的一致性比较
该研究回顾性分析104例前列腺癌患者的68Ga-PSMA11 PET/MRI或PET/CT资料,由3名核医学医师按EANM、PROMISE及PSMA-RADS三种标准独立判读,部分医师6个月后重复判读。结果显示三种标准在组内与组间重复性多为高度至几乎完全一致,但PSMA-RADS判读远处转移时组间一致性仅为中等。
要点
- 三种标准对68Ga-PSMA11 PET的组内与组间重复性总体良好。
- PSMA-RADS判读远处转移的组间一致性为中等(Gwet系数0.57),肺结节是主要分歧来源。
- 仍需进一步工作解决判读分歧问题。
核心结论
- 三种已发表判读标准在评估68Ga-PSMA11 PET时具有较好的组间与组内重复性,但存在导致组间分歧的因素。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析104例前瞻性入组研究方案患者,其中47例初诊中高危前列腺癌行68Ga-PSMA11 PET/MRI,57例生化复发前列腺癌行68Ga-PSMA11 PET/CT;3名核医学医师按三种标准独立判读,其中2人6个月后盲法重复判读。
主要发现
- PET/MRI组中三种标准在各部位的组间、组内及标准间一致性均为高度至几乎完全一致。
- PET/CT组组间一致性多为高度至几乎完全一致,但PSMA-RADS判读远处转移为中等一致(Gwet系数0.57),分歧最常见原因为肺结节。
- PET/CT组组内一致性及各部位标准间一致性均为高度至几乎完全一致。
关键数值与推荐
- PSMA-RADS判读远处转移的组间Gwet一致性系数为0.57,属中等一致。
临床怎么用
- 临床可依据EANM、PROMISE或PSMA-RADS标准判读68Ga-PSMA11 PET,但判读远处转移时需注意肺结节等可能引起分歧的病灶。
局限性
- 原文摘要未报告局限性内容。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PET using radiolabeled prostate-specific membrane antigen (PSMA) is now being more widely adopted as a valuable tool to evaluate patients with prostate cancer (PC). Recently, 3 different criteria for interpretation of PSMA PET were published: the European Association of Nuclear Medicine (EANM) criteria, the Prostate Cancer Molecular Imaging Standardized Evaluation criteria, and the PSMA Reporting and Data System. We compared these 3 criteria in terms of interreader, intrareader, and intercriteria agreement. Methods: Data from 104 patients prospectively enrolled in research protocols at our institution were retrospectively reviewed. The cohort consisted of 2 groups: 47 patients (mean age, 64.2 y old) who underwent Glu-NH-CO-NH-Lys-(Ahx)-[68Ga(HBED-CC)] (68Ga-PSMA11) PET/MRI for initial staging of biopsy-proven intermediate- or high-risk PC, and 57 patients (mean age, 70.5 y old) who underwent 68Ga-PSMA11 PET/CT because of biochemically recurrent PC. Three nuclear medicine physicians independently evaluated all 68Ga-PSMA11 PET/MRI and PET/CT studies according to the 3 interpretation criteria. Two of them reevaluated all studies 6 mo later in the same manner and masked to the initial reading. The Gwet agreement coefficient was calculated to evaluate interreader, intrareader, and intercriteria agreement based on the following sites: local lesion (primary tumor or prostate bed after radical prostatectomy), lymph node metastases, and other metastases. Results: In the PET/MRI group, interreader, intrareader, and intercriteria agreement ranged from substantial to almost perfect for any site according to all 3 criteria. In the PET/CT group, interreader agreement ranged from substantial to almost perfect except for judgment of distant metastases based on the PSMA Reporting and Data System (Gwet agreement coefficient, 0.57; moderate agreement), in which the most frequent cause of disagreement was lung nodules. Intrareader agreement ranged from substantial to almost perfect for any site according to all 3 criteria. Intercriteria agreement for each site was also substantial to almost perfect. Conclusion: Although the 3 published criteria have good interreader and intrareader reproducibility in evaluating 68Ga-PSMA11 PET, there are some factors causing interreader disagreement. Further work is needed to address this issue.
引用
- Toriihara A, Nobashi T, Baratto L, et al. Comparison of 3 Interpretation Criteria for 68Ga-PSMA11 PET Based on Inter- and Intrareader Agreement. J Nucl Med. 2019. PMID: 31562226. doi:10.2967/jnumed.119.232504
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。