临床前PET/CT成像标准化:多中心研究提升定量准确性与可重复性
该多中心研究评估了5台商用临床前PET/CT扫描仪默认协议下的定量偏差,并开发标准化协议。结果显示默认CT协议下水和空气的HU偏差大,标准化后HU偏差减小、组织等效材料精度提升,小鼠和大鼠CT吸收剂量分别从72 mGy和40 mGy降至37 mGy和24 mGy;PET均匀性、恢复系数和SUV准确性也改善。
要点
- 默认CT协议下HU偏差大,标准化后水和空气HU偏差减小且组织精度提升。
- 标准化CT协议使小鼠和大鼠吸收剂量分别降至37 mGy和24 mGy。
- 标准化PET协议改善均匀性、恢复系数变异及SUV准确性。
核心结论
- 默认协议下临床前PET/CT存在重要定量偏差和吸收剂量差异,标准化协议可提升准确性、精密度并降低CT吸收剂量。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心研究,纳入欧洲和美国5台不同商用临床前PET/CT扫描仪,使用7种PET/CT体模评估默认协议偏差并开发标准化协议。
主要发现
- 默认CT协议下提取的最大HU:水为133 HU,空气为-967 HU;所有组织等效材料组间均有显著差异。
- 默认CT协议下小鼠和大鼠平均CT吸收剂量分别为72 mGy和40 mGy。
- 标准化CT协议下提取的最大HU:水为-77 HU,空气为-990 HU;各组织组变异性降低,精度改善。
- 标准化CT协议下小鼠和大鼠平均CT吸收剂量分别降至37 mGy和24 mGy。
- 默认PET协议下1台扫描仪均匀性不达标,恢复系数最大偏差43%,SUV最大偏差44%;标准化后均匀性改善36%,恢复系数变异性降低13个百分点,SUV准确性改善至10%。
临床怎么用
- 临床前PET/CT多中心研究应采用标准化采集与重建协议,以提高数据可重复性和临床转化潜力。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Preclinical PET/CT is a well-established noninvasive imaging tool for studying disease development/progression and the development of novel radiotracers and pharmaceuticals for clinical applications. Despite this pivotal role, standardization of preclinical PET/CT protocols, including CT absorbed dose guidelines, is essentially nonexistent. This study (1) quantitatively assesses the variability of current preclinical PET/CT acquisition and reconstruction protocols routinely used across multiple centers and scanners; and (2) proposes acquisition and reconstruction PET/CT protocols for standardization of multicenter data, optimized for routine scanning in the preclinical PET/CT laboratory. Methods: Five different commercial preclinical PET/CT scanners in Europe and the United States were enrolled. Seven different PET/CT phantoms were used for evaluating biases on default/general scanner protocols, followed by developing standardized protocols. PET, CT, and absorbed dose biases were assessed. Results: Site default CT protocols were the following: greatest extracted Hounsfield units (HU) were 133 HU for water and -967 HU for air; significant differences in all tissue equivalent material (TEM) groups were measured. The average CT absorbed doses for mouse and rat were 72 mGy and 40 mGy, respectively. Standardized CT protocol were the following: greatest extracted HU were -77 HU for water and -990 HU for air; TEM precision improved with a reduction in variability for each tissue group. The average CT absorbed dose for mouse and rat decreased to 37 mGy and 24 mGy, respectively. Site default PET protocols were the following: uniformity was substandard in one scanner, recovery coefficients (RCs) were either over- or underestimated (maximum of 43%), standard uptake values (SUVs) were biased by a maximum of 44%. Standardized PET protocols were the following: scanner with substandard uniformity improved by 36%, RC variability decreased by 13% points, and SUV accuracy improved to 10%. Conclusion: Data revealed important quantitative biases in preclinical PET/CT and absorbed doses with default protocols. Standardized protocols showed improvements in measured PET/CT accuracy and precision with reduced CT absorbed dose across sites. Adhering to standardized protocols generates reproducible and consistent preclinical imaging datasets, thus augmenting translation of research findings to the clinic.
引用
- McDougald W, Vanhove C, Lehnert A, et al. Standardization of Preclinical PET/CT Imaging to Improve Quantitative Accuracy, Precision, and Reproducibility: A Multicenter Study. J Nucl Med. 2019. PMID: 31562220. doi:10.2967/jnumed.119.231308
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。