全身FDG PET图像衍生动脉血SUV的观察者间变异性
本研究纳入83例非小细胞肺癌或头颈癌患者的FDG PET/CT,由8名观察者使用5种勾画工具测定主动脉血SUV(BSUV),评估观察者间变异性。结果显示汇总数据观察者间变异RMS为2.8%,远小于受试者间变异(SD 16%),表明图像法手动测定BSUV具有足够可重复性,是准确计算SUR的前提。
要点
- 图像法手动测定主动脉BSUV的观察者间变异RMS为2.8%,可重复性良好。
- 观察者间变异远小于受试者间变异(SD 16%)。
- 不同患者间观察者变异范围[0.7, 7.4]%,部分患者差异较明显。
核心结论
- 图像法手动测定主动脉BSUV在不同观察者和勾画工具间具有足够可重复性,是准确计算SUR的前提。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析83例患者(72男、11女;非小细胞肺癌46例、头颈癌37例)的FDG PET/CT扫描。
- 8名观察者使用5种专用勾画工具测定主动脉BSUV,每位患者共12次独立观测。
主要发现
- 汇总数据观察者间变异RMS=2.8%,受试者间变异SD is=16%。
- 全体患者平均后,各观察者偏离观察者均值的范围[-0.96, 1.05]%。
- 观察者间变异在不同患者间存在差异,范围为[0.7, 7.4]%。
临床怎么用
- 在需要计算SUR时,可采用图像法手动测定主动脉BSUV,其观察者间变异较小。
- 对于观察者间变异较大的患者,需注意BSUV测定的稳定性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Today, the standardized uptake value (SUV) is essentially the only means for quantitative evaluation of static [18F-]fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG) positron emission tomography (PET) investigations. However, the SUV approach has several well-known shortcomings which adversely affect the reliability of the SUV as a surrogate of the metabolic rate of glucose consumption. The standard uptake ratio (SUR), i.e., the uptake time-corrected ratio of tumor SUV to image-derived arterial blood SUV, has been shown in the first clinical studies to overcome most of these shortcomings, to decrease test-retest variability, and to increase the prognostic value in comparison to SUV. However, it is unclear, to what extent the SUR approach is vulnerable to observer variability of the additionally required blood SUV (BSUV) determination. The goal of the present work was the investigation of the interobserver variability of image-derived BSUV. METHODS: FDG PET/CT scans from 83 patients (72 male, 11 female) with non-small cell lung cancer (N = 46) or head and neck cancer (N = 37) were included. BSUV was determined by 8 individuals, each applying a dedicated delineation tool for the BSUV determination in the aorta. Two of the observers applied two further tools. Altogether, five different delineation tools were used. With each used tool, delineation was performed for the whole patient group, resulting in 12 distinct observations per patient. Intersubject variability of BSUV determination was assessed using the fractional deviations for the individual patients from the patient group average and was quantified as standard deviation (SD is), 95% confidence interval, and range. Interobserver variability of BSUV determination was assessed using the fractional deviations of the individual observers from the observer-average for the considered patient and quantified as standard deviations (SD p, SD d) or root mean square (RMS), 95% confidence interval, and range in each patient, each observer, and the pooled data respectively. RESULTS: Interobserver variability in the pooled data amounts to RMS = 2.8% and is much smaller than the intersubject variability of BSUV (SD is= 16%). Averaged over the whole patient group, deviations of individual observers from the observer average are very small and fall in the range [ - 0.96, 1.05]%. However, interobserver variability partly differs distinctly for different patients, covering a range of [0.7, 7.4]% in the investigated patient group. CONCLUSION: The present investigation demonstrates that the image-based manual determination of BSUV in the aorta is sufficiently reproducible across different observers and delineation tools which is a prerequisite for accurate SUR determination. This finding is in line with the already demonstrated superior prognostic value of SUR in comparison to SUV in the first clinical studies.
引用
- Hofheinz F, Maus J, Zschaeck S, et al. Interobserver variability of image-derived arterial blood SUV in whole-body FDG PET. EJNMMI Res. 2019. PMID: 30830508. doi:10.1186/s13550-019-0486-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。