文献速递放射性药物与辐射防护

我们是否正接近线性无阈模型的终结?

Are We Approaching the End of the Linear No-Threshold Era?
PubMed 文献 · J Nucl Med · 2018-09-27

本文评述线性无阈(LNT)模型在辐射致癌与辐射防护政策中的适用性,指出低剂量辐射可增强抗氧化与DNA修复等防御并增强免疫,从而可能减少癌症,即辐射兴奋效应;作者认为支持LNT的证据薄弱、反对LNT的证据较多,建议咨询机构客观评估双方证据,LNT模型时代或接近终结。

要点

  • LNT模型自1950年代被国家和国际咨询机构采纳并指导全球辐射防护政策。
  • 低剂量辐射可增强抗氧化与DNA修复酶等防御,并增强免疫系统。
  • 作者称有相当证据支持辐射兴奋效应并反对LNT模型。

核心结论

  • 考虑到反对LNT模型的证据强度和支持LNT模型的证据薄弱,本分析表明咨询机构将被迫拒绝LNT模型,因此我们可能正接近LNT模型时代的终结。

研究设计与样本

  • 本文为评论性文章,评述LNT模型及支持与反对该模型的证据,并讨论NCRP Commentary 27等报告。

主要发现

  • LNT模型基于低水平辐射增加突变、突变增加意味着癌症增加的概念,但该概念可能不成立。
  • 低剂量辐射增强抗氧化与DNA修复酶等防御,可能减少后续时期内源性DNA损伤,从而减少DNA损伤和突变。
  • 突变是致癌所必需但不充分,免疫系统可消除或控制癌细胞,免疫抑制患者癌症风险显著增加。
  • 低剂量辐射增强免疫系统,可能减少癌症,即辐射兴奋效应。
  • 支持辐射兴奋效应并反对LNT模型的证据包括原子弹幸存者、本底辐射、环境辐射、癌症患者、医学辐射和职业暴露等研究。

关键数值与推荐

  • NCRP Commentary 27结论称近期流行病学研究广泛支持LNT模型,但对其研究的批判性审查显示并非如此。
  • Commentary 27的另一缺陷是未考虑大量可获得的辐射兴奋效应证据。
  • 其他支持LNT模型的咨询机构报告存在类似缺陷。

临床怎么用

  • 作者敦促咨询机构批判性评估支持双方的证据,并就LNT模型的有效性达成客观结论。

局限性

  • 原文未述局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

The linear no-threshold (LNT) model for radiation-induced cancer was adopted by national and international advisory bodies in the 1950s and has guided radiation protection policies worldwide since then. The resulting strict regulations have increased the compliance costs for the various uses of radiation, including nuclear medicine. The concerns about low levels of radiation due to the absence of a threshold have also resulted in adverse consequences. Justification of the LNT model was based on the concept that low levels of radiation increase mutations and that increased mutations imply increased cancers. This concept may not be valid. Low-dose radiation boosts defenses such as antioxidants and DNA repair enzymes. The boosted defenses would reduce the endogenous DNA damage that would have occurred in the subsequent period, and so the result would be reduced DNA damage and mutations. Whereas mutations are necessary for causing cancer, they are not sufficient since the immune system eliminates cancer cells or keeps them under control. The immune system plays an extremely important role in preventing cancer, as indicated by the substantially increased cancer risk in immune-suppressed patients. Hence, since low-dose radiation enhances the immune system, it would reduce cancers, resulting in a phenomenon known as radiation hormesis. There is considerable evidence for radiation hormesis and against the LNT model, including studies of atomic bomb survivors, background radiation, environmental radiation, cancer patients, medical radiation, and occupational exposures. Though Commentary 27 published by the National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements concluded that recent epidemiologic studies broadly support the LNT model, a critical examination of the studies has shown that they do not. Another deficiency of Commentary 27 is that it did not consider the vast available evidence for radiation hormesis. Other advisory body reports that have supported the LNT model have similar deficiencies. Advisory bodies are urged to critically evaluate the evidence supporting both sides and arrive at an objective conclusion on the validity of the LNT model. Considering the strength of the evidence against the LNT model and the weakness of the evidence for it, the present analysis indicates that advisory bodies would be compelled to reject the LNT model. Hence, we may be approaching the end of the LNT model era.

来源:J Nucl Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Doss M. Are We Approaching the End of the Linear No-Threshold Era? J Nucl Med. 2018. PMID: 30262515. doi:10.2967/jnumed.118.217182

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。