中低收入国家SPECT心肌灌注显像阅片者间变异:IAEA-MPI审计项目I-MAP结果
国际原子能机构(IAEA)通过两阶段国际临床审计评估中低收入国家既往受训者对核心实验室分发SPECT心肌灌注显像(MPI)的阅片一致性。24名核心参与者与11名国际专家分别阅片,专家在所有参数上一致性极好,核心参与者第一阶段好至极好,第二阶段SSS与SRS一致性提升至极好,不同心脏分析软件包所得LVEF值存在显著差异。
要点
- 专家阅片者两个阶段所有参数一致性均达极好水平。
- 核心参与者第一阶段所有参数一致性好至极好,第二阶段SSS与SRS一致性提升至极好。
- 核心参与者与专家合并LVEF值无显著差异,但不同软件包所得LVEF值存在显著差异。
核心结论
- 核心组阅片者间一致性为中等至好,专家阅片者间一致性为好至极好。
- 报告质量受处理质量影响。
- 结果证实IAEA培训活动对改善中低收入国家影像质量的重要作用。
研究设计与样本
- 国际临床审计,分两阶段进行:第一阶段分发原始数据要求按本地实践完整处理,第二阶段分发核心实验室预处理图像。
- 24名中低收入国家既往受训者(核心参与者组)与11名国际专家(专家组)参与,评估两阶段阅片者间变异及阶段间变化,并比较两组结果。
主要发现
- 专家阅片者在第一阶段和第二阶段所有参数一致性均为极好。
- 核心参与者组第一阶段所有参数一致性评好至极好,第二阶段重新评估的SSS与SRS一致性提升至极好。
- 专家阅片者分类变量报告在两个阶段间几乎不变,核心参与者组第二阶段有所增加。
- 核心参与者组与专家组合并LVEF值无显著差异。
- 不同心脏分析软件包所得LVEF值之间存在显著差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 报告数据包括 summed stress score(SSS)、summed rest score(SRS)、summed difference score(SDS)、左心室射血分数(LVEF)和舒张末期容积(EDV)。
- 定性评估包括灌注及缺血、瘢痕或混合模式、短暂性缺血性扩张(TID)和心脏事件(CE)风险。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Consistency of results between different readers is an important issue in medical imaging, as it affects portability of results between institutions and may affect patient care. The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) in pursuing its mission of fostering peaceful applications of nuclear technologies has supported several training activities in the field of nuclear cardiology (NC) and SPECT myocardial perfusion imaging (MPI) in particular. The aim of this study was to verify the outcome of those activities through an international clinical audit on MPI where participants were requested to report on studies distributed from a core lab. METHODS: The study was run in two phases: in phase 1, SPECT MPI studies were distributed as raw data and full processing was requested as per local practice. In phase 2, images from studies pre-processed at the core lab were distributed. Data to be reported included summed stress score (SSS); summed rest score (SRS); summed difference score (SDS); left ventricular (LV) ejection fraction (EF) and end- diastolic volume (EDV). Qualitative appraisals included the assessment of perfusion and presence of ischemia, scar or mixed patterns, presence of transient ischemic dilation (TID), and risk for cardiac events (CE). Twenty-four previous trainees from low- and middle-income countries participated (core participants group) and their results were assessed for inter-observer variability in each of the two phases, and for changes between phases. The same evaluations were performed for a group of eleven international experts (experts group). Results were also compared between the groups. RESULTS: Expert readers showed an excellent level of agreement for all parameters in both phase 1 and 2. For core participants, the concordance of all parameters in phase 1 was rated as good to excellent. Two parameters which were re-evaluated in phase 2, namely SSS and SRS, showed an increased level of concordance, up to excellent in both cases. Reporting of categorical variables by expert readers remained almost unchanged between the two phases, while core participants showed an increase in phase 2. Finally, pooled LVEF values did not show a significant difference between core participants and experts. However, significant differences were found between LVEF values obtained using different software packages for cardiac analysis. CONCLUSIONS: In this study, inter-observer agreement was moderate-to-good for core group readers and good-to-excellent for expert readers. The quality of reporting is affected by the quality of processing. These results confirm the important role of the IAEA training activities in improving imaging in low- and middle-income countries.
引用
- Dondi M, Rodella C, Giubbini R, et al. Inter-reader variability of SPECT MPI readings in low- and middle-income countries: Results from the IAEA-MPI Audit Project (I-MAP). J Nucl Cardiol. 2018. PMID: 30168029. doi:10.1007/s12350-018-1407-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。