使用不同PET自动分割方法得到的标准化图像特征所构建预后模型的评估
该研究纳入427例经活检证实的食管癌患者,于2010年9月至2016年7月行PET/CT分期,比较9种自动PET分割方法中4种(KM2、GCM3、AT、WT)构建的预后模型对风险分层的影响。AT与KM2构建的预后模型完全相同,但不同分割方法导致最多73例(17.1%)患者风险分层组别发生改变。结论认为包含定量图像特征的预后模型依赖于原发肿瘤勾画方法,并影响风险分层。
要点
- 9种自动PET分割方法中4种(KM2、GCM3、AT、WT)因主观准确率≥90%被纳入分析。
- AT与KM2分割方法构建的预后模型完全相同。
- 不同分割方法导致最多73例(17.1%)患者风险分层组别改变。
核心结论
- 包含定量图像特征的预后模型依赖于用于勾画原发肿瘤的方法。
- 分割方法对风险分层有后续影响,患者会根据所用图像分割方法而改变分组。
研究设计与样本
- 连续纳入427例经活检证实的食管癌患者,最终分析纳入该队列。
- 所有患者于2010年9月至2016年7月间行PET/CT分期。
- 研究比较了9种自动PET分割方法,所有肿瘤轮廓经主观分析评估准确性,准确率<90%的分割方法被排除。
- 使用标准化图像特征和相同临床数据构建一系列预后模型,并计算风险分类组别改变的患者比例。
主要发现
- 9种PET分割方法中,聚类均值(KM2)、通用聚类均值(GCM3)、自适应阈值(AT)和分水岭阈值(WT)方法被纳入分析。
- 已知临床预后因素(年龄、治疗和分期)在所有构建的预后模型中均有显著性。
- AT与KM2分割方法构建的预后模型完全相同。
- 患者风险分层依赖于构建预后模型所用的分割方法,最多73例(17.1%)患者风险分层组别发生改变。
关键数值与推荐
- 分割方法纳入标准为主观分析准确率≥90%,准确率<90%的方法被排除。
- 共9种自动PET分割方法被研究,最终4种(KM2、GCM3、AT、WT)纳入分析。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Prognosis in oesophageal cancer (OC) is poor. The 5-year overall survival (OS) rate is approximately 15%. Personalised medicine is hoped to increase the 5- and 10-year OS rates. Quantitative analysis of PET is gaining substantial interest in prognostic research but requires the accurate definition of the metabolic tumour volume. This study compares prognostic models developed in the same patient cohort using individual PET segmentation algorithms and assesses the impact on patient risk stratification. Consecutive patients (n = 427) with biopsy-proven OC were included in final analysis. All patients were staged with PET/CT between September 2010 and July 2016. Nine automatic PET segmentation methods were studied. All tumour contours were subjectively analysed for accuracy, and segmentation methods with < 90% accuracy were excluded. Standardised image features were calculated, and a series of prognostic models were developed using identical clinical data. The proportion of patients changing risk classification group were calculated. RESULTS: Out of nine PET segmentation methods studied, clustering means (KM2), general clustering means (GCM3), adaptive thresholding (AT) and watershed thresholding (WT) methods were included for analysis. Known clinical prognostic factors (age, treatment and staging) were significant in all of the developed prognostic models. AT and KM2 segmentation methods developed identical prognostic models. Patient risk stratification was dependent on the segmentation method used to develop the prognostic model with up to 73 patients (17.1%) changing risk stratification group. CONCLUSION: Prognostic models incorporating quantitative image features are dependent on the method used to delineate the primary tumour. This has a subsequent effect on risk stratification, with patients changing groups depending on the image segmentation method used.
引用
- Parkinson C, Foley K, Whybra P, et al. Evaluation of prognostic models developed using standardised image features from different PET automated segmentation methods. EJNMMI Res. 2018. PMID: 29644499. doi:10.1186/s13550-018-0379-3
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。