数字飞行时间PET/CT扫描仪上惩罚似然估计重建用于18F-FDG全身检查的评估
该研究在数字飞行时间PET/CT扫描仪上纳入11例临床全身18F-FDG PET/CT检查,比较块序列正则化期望最大化(BSREM)与飞行时间OSEM(TOF OSEM)在不同β因子、采集时间和横断面视野下的表现。结果显示,β因子400时噪声与TOF OSEM相当,但SUVmax、SNR和SBR显著提高;BSREM在较短采集时间下可获得与TOF OSEM全采集时间相当的图像质量。
要点
- β因子400时噪声与TOF OSEM相当,SUVmax、SNR和SBR分别提高11%、22%和12%。
- BSREM β因子533在2分钟/床位采集时间下与TOF OSEM 3分钟/床位全采集时间相当。
- 横断面视野从70 cm缩至50 cm时,SNR升高而SBR降低。
核心结论
- 与TOF OSEM相比,惩罚BSREM重建在匹配噪声水平下提高了肿瘤SUVmax并改善了SNR和SBR。
- BSREM允许比TOF OSEM更短的采集时间,且图像质量相当。
研究设计与样本
- 纳入11例在数字TOF PET/CT扫描仪上采集的临床全身18F-FDG PET/CT检查。
- 数据采用BSREM(带点扩散函数恢复,β因子133、267、400和533)和TOF OSEM(带点扩散函数)在不同每床位采集时间和不同视野下重建。
- 分析噪声水平、信噪比(SNR)、信号本底比(SBR)和SUV,并由2名核医学医师对图像质量多个方面进行掩蔽式视觉评估。
主要发现
- 最高β因子达到最低噪声水平,导致最高SNR,进而导致最低SBR。
- β因子400时噪声与TOF OSEM相当,但SUVmax显著提高11%、SNR显著提高22%、SBR显著提高12%。
- BSREM β因子533在缩短的采集时间(2分钟/床位)下与TOF OSEM全采集时间(3分钟/床位)相当。
- 横断面视野从70 cm变为50 cm时,SNR升高而SBR降低。
- 视觉图像质量评估中重建图像得分相似,β因子400获得最高均值,而β因子267在整体图像质量、对比度、锐利度和肿瘤可检测性方面排名最佳。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The resolution and quantitative accuracy of PET are highly influenced by the reconstruction method. Penalized-likelihood estimation algorithms allow for fully convergent iterative reconstruction, generating a higher image contrast than ordered-subsets expectation maximization (OSEM) while limiting noise. In this study, a type of penalized reconstruction known as block-sequential regularized expectation maximization (BSREM) was compared with time-of-flight OSEM (TOF OSEM). Various strengths of noise penalization factor β were tested along with various acquisition durations and transaxial fields of view (FOVs) with the aim of evaluating the performance and clinical use of BSREM for 18F-FDG PET/CT, both quantitatively and in a qualitative visual evaluation. Methods: Eleven clinical whole-body 18F-FDG PET/CT examinations acquired on a digital TOF PET/CT scanner were included. The data were reconstructed using BSREM with point-spread function recovery and β-factors of 133, 267, 400, and 533-and using TOF OSEM with point-spread function-for various acquisition times per bed position and various FOVs. Noise level, signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), signal-to-background ratio (SBR), and SUV were analyzed. A masked evaluation of visual image quality, rating several aspects, was performed by 2 nuclear medicine physicians to complement the analysis. Results: The lowest levels of noise were reached with the highest β-factor, resulting in the highest SNR, which in turn resulted in the lowest SBR. A β-factor of 400 gave noise equivalent to TOF OSEM but produced a significant increase in SUVmax (11%), SNR (22%), and SBR (12%). BSREM with a β-factor of 533 at a decreased acquisition duration (2 min/bed position) was comparable to TOF OSEM at a full acquisition duration (3 min/bed position). Reconstructed FOV had an impact on BSREM outcome measures; SNR increased and SBR decreased when FOV was shifted from 70 to 50 cm. The evaluation of visual image quality resulted in similar scores for reconstructions, although a β-factor of 400 obtained the highest mean whereas a β-factor of 267 was ranked best in overall image quality, contrast, sharpness, and tumor detectability. Conclusion: In comparison with TOF OSEM, penalized BSREM reconstruction resulted in an increased tumor SUVmax and an improved SNR and SBR at a matched level of noise. BSREM allowed for a shorter acquisition than TOF OSEM, with equal image quality.
引用
- Lindström E, Sundin A, Trampal C, et al. Evaluation of Penalized-Likelihood Estimation Reconstruction on a Digital Time-of-Flight PET/CT Scanner for 18F-FDG Whole-Body Examinations. J Nucl Med. 2018. PMID: 29449445. doi:10.2967/jnumed.117.200790
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。