用于心肌灌注显像的不同相机对小范围心脏运动的易损性比较
该体模研究在Discovery NM-530c和DSPECT CZT相机及配备散光准直器(IQ.SPECT)或常规平行孔准直器(Conv.SPECT)的Anger Symbia T2相机上模拟左心室插件在半个SPECT采集期间沿六个正交方向、幅度为5或10毫米的平移,评估小范围心脏运动的影响。结果显示所有相机从基线到5毫米和10毫米运动时,17个左心室节段记录活性的不均匀性逐渐增加,Anger相机在各幅度均高于CZT相机,10毫米幅度下伪影异常节段平均数为Conv.SPECT 3.7、IQ.SPECT 1.8、Discovery 0.7、DSPECT 0,但易损性强烈依赖于重建参数。
要点
- 所有相机在5毫米和10毫米运动时左心室17节段活性不均匀性逐渐增加,Anger相机各幅度均高于CZT相机。
- 10毫米幅度下伪影异常节段平均数:Conv.SPECT 3.7、IQ.SPECT 1.8、Discovery 0.7、DSPECT 0。
- Conv.SPECT不使用推荐的分辨率恢复算法重建时易损性显著降低,DSPECT不使用推荐的心脏模型重建时易损性增加。
核心结论
- CZT相机尤其是DSPECT对小范围心脏运动的易损性低于Anger相机,但这些差异强烈依赖于重建参数。
研究设计与样本
- 该研究为基于体模的研究,在Discovery NM-530c和DSPECT CZT相机及配备散光准直器(IQ.SPECT)或常规平行孔准直器(Conv.SPECT)的Anger Symbia T2相机上模拟左心室插件在半个SPECT采集期间沿六个正交方向、幅度为5或10毫米的平移。
- SPECT图像最初按当前临床常规推荐进行重建。
主要发现
- 所有相机从基线到5毫米和10毫米运动时,17个左心室节段记录活性的不均匀性逐渐增加。
- Anger相机在各运动幅度下的不均匀性均高于CZT相机。
- 10毫米幅度下伪影异常节段平均数为Conv.SPECT 3.7、IQ.SPECT 1.8、Discovery 0.7、DSPECT 0。
- Conv.SPECT不使用推荐的分辨率恢复算法重建时,这种运动易损性显著降低。
- DSPECT不使用推荐的心脏模型重建时,这种运动易损性增加。
关键数值与推荐
- 10毫米运动幅度下伪影异常节段平均数:Conv.SPECT 3.7、IQ.SPECT 1.8、Discovery 0.7、DSPECT 0。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
This phantom-based study was aimed to determine whether cardiac CZT-cameras, which provide an enhanced spatial resolution and image contrast compared to Anger cameras, are similarly affected by small cardiac motions. Translations of a left ventricular (LV) insert at half-SPECT acquisitions through six possible orthogonal directions and with 5- or 10-mm amplitude were simulated on the Discovery NM-530c and DSPECT CZT-cameras and on an Anger Symbia T2 camera equipped with an astigmatic (IQ.SPECT) or conventional parallel-hole collimator (Conv.SPECT). SPECT images were initially reconstructed as currently recommended for clinical routine. The heterogeneity in recorded activity from the 17 LV segments gradually increased between baseline and motions simulated at 5- and 10-mm amplitudes with all cameras, although being higher for Anger- than CZT-cameras at each step and resulting in a higher mean number of artifactual abnormal segments (at 10-mm amplitude, Conv.SPECT: 3.7; IQ.SPECT: 1.8, Discovery: 0.7, DSPECT: 0). However, this vulnerability to motion was markedly (1) decreased for Conv.SPECT reconstructed without the recommended Resolution Recovery algorithm and (2) increased for DSPECT reconstructed without the recommended cardiac model. CZT-cameras and especially the DSPECT appear less vulnerable to small cardiac motions than Anger-cameras although these differences are strongly dependent on reconstruction parameters.
引用
- Salvadori J, Petegnief Y, Sabbah R, et al. Compared vulnerabilities to small cardiac motions between different cameras used for myocardial perfusion imaging. J Nucl Cardiol. 2018. PMID: 29327252. doi:10.1007/s12350-017-1175-6
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。