一种用于PET多中心放射组学研究的重建后协调化方法
本研究纳入乳腺癌患者治疗前18F-FDG PET图像,A科63例(其中三阴性病灶16个)、B科74例(其中三阴性病灶15个),并将A科图像经高斯滤波模拟第三科(A-S)。采用最初用于基因组数据的协调化方法估计科室效应。协调化后9个特征在两科室间分布均无显著差异(P>0.1),三阴性病灶识别明显改善。
要点
- 协调化前,健康肝组织中A科与B科9个特征中4个分布显著不同,A科与A-S科9个特征中6个显著不同(P<0.05,Wilcoxon检验)。
- 协调化后,两科室间9个特征分布均无显著差异(P>0.1)。
- 以ー科室数据确定截断值并应用于另一科室数据时,协调化后三阴性病灶识别明显改善。
核心结论
- 所提出的协调化方法能有效去除纹理特征和SUV的多中心效应。
- 该方法易于使用,保留与中心效应无关的生物学变异,且无需重新计算任何特征。
- 该协调化方法允许多中心研究以及放射组学模型或截断值的外部验证,并应有助于放射组学模型在临床实践中的应用。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入乳腺癌患者治疗前18F-FDG PET图像;A科63例患者使用飞行时间PET/CT扫描仪,其中三阴性病灶16个;B科74例患者使用不同品牌扫描仪和不同重建方案,其中三阴性病灶15个。
- A科图像经高斯滤波平滑以模拟第三科(A-S)数据。
- 对原发灶分割获得病灶感兴趣体积(VOI),并在健康肝组织设置球形VOI;所有VOI中计算3个SUV和6个纹理特征。
- 采用最初为基因组数据描述的协调化方法,基于观察到的特征值估计科室效应;比较各科室协调化前后的特征分布。
主要发现
- 健康肝组织中,协调化前A科与B科9个特征中4个分布显著不同,A科与A-S科9个特征中6个分布显著不同(P<0.05,Wilcoxon检验)。
- 协调化后,两科室间9个特征分布均无显著差异(P>0.1)。
- 病灶中观察到相同趋势,协调化后各科室间特征分布重新对齐。
- 当截断值在一个科室数据上确定并应用于另一科室数据时,协调化后三阴性病灶的识别明显改善。
关键数值与推荐
- 协调化前健康肝组织A科与B科9个特征中4个分布显著不同(P<0.05,Wilcoxon检验)。
- 协调化前健康肝组织A科与A-S科9个特征中6个分布显著不同(P<0.05,Wilcoxon检验)。
- 协调化后两科室间9个特征分布均无显著差异(P>0.1)。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论指出,该协调化方法允许多中心研究和放射组学模型或截断值的外部验证,并应有助于放射组学模型在临床实践中的应用。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Several reports have shown that radiomic features are affected by acquisition and reconstruction parameters, thus hampering multicenter studies. We propose a method that, by removing the center effect while preserving patient-specific effects, standardizes features measured from PET images obtained using different imaging protocols. Methods: Pretreatment 18F-FDG PET images of patients with breast cancer were included. In one nuclear medicine department (department A), 63 patients were scanned on a time-of-flight PET/CT scanner, and 16 lesions were triple-negative (TN). In another nuclear medicine department (department B), 74 patients underwent PET/CT on a different brand of scanner and a different reconstruction protocol, and 15 lesions were TN. The images from department A were smoothed using a gaussian filter to mimic data from a third department (department A-S). The primary lesion was segmented to obtain a lesion volume of interest (VOI), and a spheric VOI was set in healthy liver tissue. Three SUVs and 6 textural features were computed in all VOIs. A harmonization method initially described for genomic data was used to estimate the department effect based on the observed feature values. Feature distributions in each department were compared before and after harmonization. Results: In healthy liver tissue, the distributions significantly differed for 4 of 9 features between departments A and B and for 6 of 9 between departments A and A-S (P < 0.05, Wilcoxon test). After harmonization, none of the 9 feature distributions significantly differed between 2 departments (P > 0.1). The same trend was observed in lesions, with a realignment of feature distributions between the departments after harmonization. Identification of TN lesions was largely enhanced after harmonization when the cutoffs were determined on data from one department and applied to data from the other department. Conclusion: The proposed harmonization method is efficient at removing the multicenter effect for textural features and SUVs. The method is easy to use, retains biologic variations not related to a center effect, and does not require any feature recalculation. Such harmonization allows for multicenter studies and for external validation of radiomic models or cutoffs and should facilitate the use of radiomic models in clinical practice.
引用
- Orlhac F, Boughdad S, Philippe C, et al. A Postreconstruction Harmonization Method for Multicenter Radiomic Studies in PET. J Nucl Med. 2018. PMID: 29301932. doi:10.2967/jnumed.117.199935
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。