文献速递核素与放射性配体治疗放射性药物与辐射防护

基于3D打印双腔室肾脏体模优化177Lu SPECT/CT图像定量

Optimizing Image Quantification for 177Lu SPECT/CT Based on a 3D Printed 2-Compartment Kidney Phantom.
PubMed 文献 · J Nucl Med · 2017-11-02

本研究用3D打印的双腔室肾脏体模、球体和椭球体,在SPECT/CT系统上以xSPECT Quant和Flash3D两种方法重建177Lu图像,比较5种部分容积校正方法的活性测定准确性。结果显示未平滑重建联合基于低剂量CT的恢复系数准确度最佳,球体与肾皮质体模的恢复系数差异达31.7%。

要点

  • 未后滤波时,基于模型的恢复系数法准确度最佳(xSPECT误差1.5%,Flash3D误差10.3%)。
  • 球体与椭球体恢复系数仅差0.7%,但球体与肾皮质体模之间差异达31.7%。
  • 42%阈值法量化误差最大(xSPECT 32.3%,Flash3D 46.7%),后滤波后误差普遍增加。

核心结论

  • 最佳活性测定方案为未平滑的SPECT/CT重建联合基于低剂量CT的恢复系数。
  • 球体与肾脏恢复系数的差异提示,通常使用的仅基于球体、依赖体积的恢复系数查找表应被更具几何特异性的替代方案取代。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究制造了不同几何形状的3D打印体模:双腔室肾脏体模(70%皮质、30%髓质)、球体和椭球体,三者体积相等。
  • 体模填充177Lu后使用SPECT/CT系统扫描,分别以xSPECT Quant和Flash3D重建。
  • 应用5种部分容积校正方法并评估活性测定准确性,同时研究重建后高斯滤波的影响。

主要发现

  • 球体与椭球体的恢复系数仅相差0.7%,而球体与肾皮质体模之间相差31.7%。
  • 未后滤波时,基于模型的恢复系数法(方法1和方法2)准确度最佳:xSPECT误差1.5%,Flash3D误差10.3%。
  • 扩大感兴趣体积法(方法3)次之:xSPECT误差8.5%,Flash3D误差13.0%。
  • 峰值毫升法(方法4)仅在球体和椭球体上显示较大误差:xSPECT 23.4%,Flash3D 21.6%。
  • 应用42%阈值(方法5)导致最大量化误差:xSPECT 32.3%,Flash3D 46.7%;后滤波后误差普遍增加。

关键数值与推荐

  • 方法1:基于3D打印模型的几何特异性恢复系数。
  • 方法2:基于低剂量CT的几何特异性恢复系数。
  • 方法3:包含溢出计数的扩大感兴趣体积。
  • 方法4:将峰值毫升活性浓度应用于整个CT基于的体积。
  • 方法5:在包含目标物体的大体积内采用最大值的42%固定阈值。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

The aim of this work was to find an optimal setup for activity determination of 177Lu-based SPECT/CT imaging reconstructed with 2 commercially available methods (xSPECT Quant and Flash3D). For this purpose, 3-dimensional (3D)-printed phantoms of different geometries were manufactured, different partial-volume correction (PVC) methods were applied, and the accuracy of the activity determination was evaluated. Methods: A 2-compartment kidney phantom (70% cortical and 30% medullary compartment), a sphere, and an ellipsoid of equal volumes were 3D printed, filled with 177Lu, and scanned with a SPECT/CT system. Reconstructions were performed with xSPECT and Flash3D. Different PVC methods were applied to find an optimal quantification setup: method 1 was a geometry-specific recovery coefficient based on the 3D printing model, method 2 was a geometry-specific recovery coefficient based on the low-dose CT scan, method 3 was an enlarged volume of interest including spilled-out counts, method 4 was activity concentration in the peak milliliter applied to the entire CT-based volume, and method 5 was a fixed threshold of 42% of the maximum in a large volume containing the object of interest. Additionally, the influence of postreconstruction gaussian filtering was investigated. Results: Although the recovery coefficients of sphere and ellipsoid differed by only 0.7%, a difference of 31.7% was observed between the sphere and the renal cortex phantoms. Without postfiltering, the model-based recovery coefficients (methods 1 and 2) resulted in the best accuracies (xSPECT, 1.5%; Flash3D, 10.3%), followed by the enlarged volume (method 3) (xSPECT, 8.5%; Flash3D, 13.0%). The peak-milliliter method (method 4) showed large errors only for sphere and ellipsoid (xSPECT, 23.4%; Flash3D, 21.6%). Applying a 42% threshold (method 5) led to the largest quantification errors (xSPECT, 32.3%; Flash3D, 46.7%). After postfiltering, a general increase in the errors was observed. Conclusion: In this work, 3D printing was used as a prototyping technique for a geometry-specific investigation of SPECT/CT reconstruction parameters and PVC methods. The optimal setup for activity determination was found to be an unsmoothed SPECT/CT reconstruction in combination with a recovery coefficient based on the low-dose CT. The difference between spheric and renal recovery coefficients suggests that the typically applied volume-dependent but only sphere-based recovery coefficient lookup tables should be replaced by a more geometry-specific alternative.

来源:J Nucl Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Tran-Gia J, Lassmann M. Optimizing Image Quantification for 177Lu SPECT/CT Based on a 3D Printed 2-Compartment Kidney Phantom. J Nucl Med. 2017. PMID: 29097409. doi:10.2967/jnumed.117.200170

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。