文献速递放射性药物与辐射防护肿瘤 PET/CT核素与放射性配体治疗

通过国际原子能机构核医学质量管理审计项目对核医学进行全面审计。第2部分:结果分析

Comprehensive Auditing in Nuclear Medicine Through the International Atomic Energy Agency Quality Management Audits in Nuclear Medicine Program. Part 2: Analysis of Results.
PubMed 文献 · Semin Nucl Med · 2017-07-27

对国际原子能机构核医学质量管理审计项目过去8年间全球42次审计任务(39个中心,其中3个被重新审计)的报告进行回顾性分析,总体符合水平为73.9±8.3%(范围56.6%–87.9%),临床服务领域符合水平最高,放射药物2级、计算机系统与数据处理、质量管理体系评价符合水平最低;共提出1687条建议,其中关键276条(16%)、主要604条(36%)、次要807条(48%)。

要点

  • 42次审计任务总体符合水平为73.9±8.3%,范围56.6%–87.9%。
  • 影像临床服务符合水平83.7%,治疗临床服务87.9%,放射药物2级仅56.6%。
  • 1687条建议中关键276条(16%)、主要604条(36%)、次要807条(48%)。

核心结论

  • QUANUM项目适用于从较小执业机构到配备PET/CT和回旋加速器的较大中心等多种机构。
  • 向患者提供的临床服务对国际标准显示出良好依从性,而工作人员和患者的辐射防护相关问题需要更高程度的关注。
  • 这是国际原子能机构关于安全建议有效转化为常规实践的重要反馈。
  • 标准操作程序的起草和应用培训也应被视为优先事项。

研究设计与样本

  • 对过去8年间全球42次审计任务(39个中心,其中3个被重新审计)的报告进行回顾性分析。
  • QUANUM项目基于内部和外部审计,并使用专门开发的Excel电子表格评估对预先定义质量标准的符合水平。
  • 符合水平按实施程度评分:0(缺失)至4(完全符合);0、1、2分视为不符合,3、4分视为符合。

主要发现

  • 所有审计报告的总体符合水平为73.9±8.3%(均值±标准差),范围56.6%–87.9%。
  • 临床服务领域符合水平最高:影像为83.7%,治疗为87.9%。
  • 符合水平最低的领域为放射药物2级(56.6%)、计算机系统与数据处理(66.6%)和质量管理体系评价(67.6%)。
  • 最终审计报告共产生1687条建议,按对安全和日常临床活动的影响分为关键276条(16%)、主要604条(36%)和次要807条(48%)。
  • 建议占比最高的类别为管理组织与文档(26%)、工作人员辐射防护与安全(17.3%)、放射药物制备、分发与处理(15.8%)、质量保证/质量控制与设备和软件管理(11.4%);建议占比最低的条目为人力资源(4%)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 符合水平评分0(缺失)至4(完全符合);0、1、2分为不符合,3、4分为符合。
  • 关键建议需立即行动(n=276,占16%);主要建议需在相对短时间内行动,通常为3至6个月(n=604,占36%);次要建议尽可能处理(n=807,占48%)。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

The International Atomic Energy Agency has developed a program, named Quality Management Audits in Nuclear Medicine (QUANUM), to help its Member States to check the status of their nuclear medicine practices and their adherence to international reference standards, covering all aspects of nuclear medicine, including quality assurance/quality control of instrumentation, radiopharmacy (further subdivided into levels 1, 2, and 3, according to complexity of work), radiation safety, clinical applications, as well as managerial aspects. The QUANUM program is based on both internal and external audits and, with specifically developed Excel spreadsheets, it helps assess the level of conformance (LoC) to those previously defined quality standards. According to their level of implementation, the level of conformance to requested standards; 0 (absent) up to 4 (full conformance). Items scored 0, 1, and 2 are considered non-conformance; items scored 3 and 4 are considered conformance. To assess results of the audit missions performed worldwide over the last 8 years, a retrospective analysis has been run on reports from a total of 42 audit missions in 39 centers, three of which had been re-audited. The analysis of all audit reports has shown an overall LoC of 73.9 ± 8.3% (mean ± standard deviation), ranging between 56.6% and 87.9%. The highest LoC has been found in the area of clinical services (83.7% for imaging and 87.9% for therapy), whereas the lowest levels have been found for Radiopharmacy Level 2 (56.6%); Computer Systems and Data Handling (66.6%); and Evaluation of the Quality Management System (67.6%). Prioritization of non-conformances produced a total of 1687 recommendations in the final audit report. Depending on the impact on safety and daily clinical activities, they were further classified as critical (requiring immediate action; n = 276; 16% of the total); major (requiring action in relatively short time, typically from 3 to 6 months; n = 604; 36%); whereas the remaining 807 (48%) were classified as minor, that is, to be addressed whenever possible. The greatest proportion of recommendations has been found in the category "Managerial, Organization and Documentation" (26%); "Staff Radiation Protection and Safety" (17.3%); "Radiopharmaceuticals Preparation, Dispensing and Handling" (15.8%); and "Quality Assurance/Quality Control" and "Management of Equipment and Software" (11.4%). The lowest level of recommendations belongs to the item "Human Resources" (4%). The QUANUM program proved applicable to a wide variety of institutions, from small practices to larger centers with PET/CT and cyclotrons. Clinical services rendered to patients showed a good compliance with international standards, whereas issues related to radiation protection of both staff and patients will require a higher degree of attention. This is a relevant feedback for the International Atomic Energy Agency with regard to the effective translation of safety recommendations into routine practice. Training on drafting and application of standard operating procedures should also be considered a priority.

来源:Semin Nucl Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Dondi M, Torres L, Marengo M, et al. Comprehensive Auditing in Nuclear Medicine Through the International Atomic Energy Agency Quality Management Audits in Nuclear Medicine Program. Part 2: Analysis of Results. Semin Nucl Med. 2017. PMID: 28969767. doi:10.1053/j.semnuclmed.2017.07.004

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。