运动障碍或痴呆患者中123I-碘氟潘SPECT图像视觉判读联合或不联合定量的诊断效能
研究收集3项试验中304例临床诊断为帕金森综合征、非帕金森综合征、很可能路易体痴呆及非路易体痴呆受试者的123I-碘氟潘图像,由5名经验有限的核医学医师分别进行单纯视觉判读与视觉联合定量判读。联合判读的阳性符合率与单纯视觉判读相当,阴性符合率小幅升高但未达统计学显著,先进行联合判读的读者准确率显著高于单纯视觉判读,读者信心显著提升,联合判读不劣于单纯视觉判读。
要点
- 联合定量判读的阳性符合率80.2% vs 单纯视觉判读80.1%,阴性符合率89.9% vs 87.9%,差异未达统计学显著。
- 先进行联合判读的读者准确率85.8% vs 单纯视觉判读79.2%(P=0.018),接近原研究专家读者范围83.3%-87.2%。
- 联合分析使经验有限的读者判读信心显著改善(P<0.0001)。
核心结论
- 加入定量分析使经验有限的读者对123I-碘氟潘SPECT的判读准确率与原始研究中有经验的读者相当。
- 联合判读结果不劣于单纯视觉判读,并提高了读者信心。
研究设计与样本
- 研究收集3项试验中304例123I-碘氟潘图像,受试者临床诊断为帕金森综合征、非帕金森综合征(主要为特发性震颤)、很可能路易体痴呆及非路易体痴呆(主要为阿尔茨海默病)。
- 图像以标准化参数重建后,针对正常数据库量化纹状体结合比。
- 由5名既往123I-碘氟潘判读经验有限的核医学医师进行2次间隔至少1个月的判读,分别为单纯视觉判读或联合判读(视觉加定量数据)。
- 以随访诊断为标准真值,通过阳性符合百分比(相当于敏感度)和阴性符合百分比(相当于特异度)评估诊断准确率,并检验联合判读不劣于单纯视觉判读的假设。
主要发现
- 联合判读与单纯视觉判读相比,平均阴性符合百分比小幅升高但未达统计学显著(89.9% vs 87.9%),阳性符合百分比相当(80.2% vs 80.1%)。
- 先进行联合分析的读者准确率显著高于单纯视觉判读(85.8% vs 79.2%;P=0.018)。
- 先进行联合分析的读者准确率接近原始研究专家读者的范围(83.3%-87.2%)。
- 联合分析使读者判读图像的平均信心显著改善(P<0.0001)。
关键数值与推荐
- 联合判读平均阴性符合百分比89.9% vs 单纯视觉判读87.9%。
- 联合判读平均阳性符合百分比80.2% vs 单纯视觉判读80.1%。
- 先进行联合分析的读者准确率85.8% vs 单纯视觉判读79.2%(P=0.018)。
- 原始研究专家读者准确率范围为83.3%-87.2%。
- 联合分析读者信心改善P<0.0001。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出临床推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Visual interpretation of 123I-ioflupane SPECT images has high diagnostic accuracy for differentiating parkinsonian syndromes (PS), from essential tremor and probable dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB) from Alzheimer disease. In this study, we investigated the impact on accuracy and reader confidence offered by the addition of image quantification in comparison with visual interpretation alone. Methods: We collected 304 123I-ioflupane images from 3 trials that included subjects with a clinical diagnosis of PS, non-PS (mainly essential tremor), probable DLB, and non-DLB (mainly Alzheimer disease). Images were reconstructed with standardized parameters before striatal binding ratios were quantified against a normal database. Images were assessed by 5 nuclear medicine physicians who had limited prior experience with 123I-ioflupane interpretation. In 2 readings at least 1 mo apart, readers performed either a visual interpretation alone or a combined reading (i.e., visual plus quantitative data were available). Readers were asked to rate their confidence of image interpretation and judge scans as easy or difficult to read. Diagnostic accuracy was assessed by comparing image results with the standard of truth (i.e., diagnosis at follow-up) by measuring the positive percentage of agreement (equivalent to sensitivity) and the negative percentage of agreement (equivalent to specificity). The hypothesis that the results of the combined reading were not inferior to the results of the visual reading analysis was tested. Results: A comparison of the combined reading and the visual reading revealed a small, insignificant increase in the mean negative percentage of agreement (89.9% vs. 87.9%) and equivalent positive percentages of agreement (80.2% vs. 80.1%). Readers who initially performed a combined analysis had significantly greater accuracy (85.8% vs. 79.2%; P = 0.018), and their accuracy was close to that of the expert readers in the original studies (range, 83.3%-87.2%). Mean reader confidence in the interpretation of images showed a significant improvement when combined analysis was used (P < 0.0001). Conclusion: The addition of quantification allowed readers with limited experience in the interpretation of 123I-ioflupane SPECT scans to have diagnostic accuracy equivalent to that of the experienced readers in the initial studies. Also, the results of the combined reading were not inferior to the results of the visual reading analysis and offered an increase in reader confidence.
引用
- Booij J, Dubroff J, Pryma D, et al. Diagnostic Performance of the Visual Reading of 123I-Ioflupane SPECT Images With or Without Quantification in Patients With Movement Disorders or Dementia. J Nucl Med. 2017. PMID: 28473597. doi:10.2967/jnumed.116.189266
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。