以冠状动脉造影为参考,比较CZT相机立位与仰位负荷-only显像与常规γ相机经与未经衰减校正图像的分析
研究在同一批受试者中比较CZT相机立位与仰位负荷-only显像与常规Anger相机衰减校正负荷-only图像的诊断效能,以冠状动脉造影为参考。112例有冠状动脉造影资料及40例冠心病验前概率<5%的受试者完成两种显像,两位阅者独立盲法判读。CZT与衰减校正Anger相机图像的阳性和阴性预测值相似(均P=NS),但第一位阅者衰减校正Anger相机图像的敏感性更高(81.3% vs 58.3%,P=.05)、特异性更低(29.7% vs 50.0%,P=.005)、正常率更低(87.5% vs 100%,P=.025),第二位阅者两种相机间无显著差异。结论认为CZT负荷-only立位与仰位显像在统计学上非劣于衰减校正Anger相机负荷-only显像,但对某些阅者CZT负荷-only显像诊断敏感性可能降低。
要点
- CZT立位与仰位负荷-only显像与衰减校正Anger相机图像对阻塞性冠心病的阳性预测值(阅者1/阅者2:50.0%/44.1% vs 46.4%/51.9%)和阴性预测值(66.7%/64.0% vs 67.9%/67.7%)相似,均P=NS。
- 第一位阅者衰减校正Anger相机图像敏感性更高(81.3% vs 58.3%,P=.05)、特异性更低(29.7% vs 50.0%,P=.005)、正常率更低(87.5% vs 100%,P=.025),第二位阅者两相机间无显著差异。
- CZT负荷-only立位与仰位显像在统计学上非劣于衰减校正Anger相机负荷-only显像,但对某些阅者诊断敏感性可能降低。
核心结论
- CZT负荷-only立位与仰位显像在统计学上非劣于衰减校正Anger相机负荷-only显像。
- 然而,与衰减校正Anger相机图像相比,CZT负荷-only显像对某些阅者可能伴随诊断敏感性降低,其临床可接受性可能低于负荷加静息显像。
研究设计与样本
- 112例有冠状动脉造影对照资料的受试者及40例冠心病验前概率<5%的受试者,完成常规Anger相机衰减校正负荷-only显像以及CZT相机未校正立位与仰位负荷显像。
- 两位阅者对负荷-only图像进行独立、盲法判读。
主要发现
- CZT立位与仰位负荷-only图像与衰减校正Anger相机图像的阳性预测值(阅者1/阅者2:50.0%/44.1% vs 46.4%/51.9%)和阴性预测值(66.7%/64.0% vs 67.9%/67.7%)相似,所有P=NS。
- 第一位阅者中,衰减校正Anger相机图像的敏感性更高(81.3% vs 58.3%,P=.05)、特异性更低(29.7% vs 50.0%,P=.005)、正常率更低(87.5% vs 100%,P=.025)。
- 第二位阅者中,两种相机间无显著差异。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Diagnostic performance of stress-only imaging using a Cadmium-Zinc-Telluride (CZT) camera has not been directly compared in the same patients to stress-only attenuation-corrected conventional Anger camera images. METHODS: 112 subjects with correlative coronary angiographic data and 40 subjects with <5% pre-test likelihood of coronary disease completed attenuation-corrected stress-only images on a conventional Anger camera and uncorrected upright and supine stress images on a CZT camera. Two readers provided independent, blinded interpretations of stress-only images. RESULTS: Upright and supine stress-only CZT images and attenuation-corrected Anger camera images provided similar positive (reader 1/reader 2, 50.0%/44.1% vs 46.4%/51.9%) and negative (66.7%/64.0% vs 67.9%/67.7%) predictive values (all P = NS) for obstructive coronary artery disease; however, the sensitivity was higher (81.3% vs 58.3%, P = .05), specificity lower (29.7% vs 50.0%, P = .005), and normalcy rate lower (87.5% vs 100%, P = .025) with attenuation-corrected Anger camera images for the first reader with no significant differences between cameras for the second reader. CONCLUSIONS: Stress-only upright and supine CZT imaging was non-inferior statistically to attenuation-corrected stress-only Anger camera imaging. Nevertheless, stress-only CZT imaging may be associated with reduced diagnostic sensitivity for some readers compared to attenuation-corrected Anger camera images, which may be less acceptable clinically compared to stress plus rest images.
引用
- Jameria ZA, Abdallah M, Fernandez-Ulloa M, et al. Analysis of stress-only imaging, comparing upright and supine CZT camera acquisition to conventional gamma camera images with and without attenuation correction, with coronary angiography as a reference. J Nucl Cardiol. 2017. PMID: 28108979. doi:10.1007/s12350-017-0781-7
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。