文献速递神经核医学肿瘤 PET/CT

Centiloid稳健性:样本量与图像分辨率对Centiloid转换准确性的影响

Exploring Centiloid Robustness: Impact of Sample Size and Image Resolution on Centiloid Conversion Accuracy.
PubMed 文献 · J Nucl Med · 2025-12-03

该研究基于[11C]PiB、[18F]florbetaben和[18F]florbetapir PET图像,考察校准数据集随机抽样导致的SUV比值-to-Centiloid转换方程系数变异及图像分辨率对Centiloid定量的影响;发现最小样本量下转换误差仍较小,分辨率降低使高阳性扫描Centiloid系统性偏低,而在25 Centiloid附近误差最小。

要点

  • 校准样本含15例cAD与10例Aβ阴性者时,25与100 Centiloid处转换误差分别为1.7与3.4 Centiloid。
  • 增至50例cAD与30例Aβ阴性者后,误差降至25 Centiloid处1.0、100 Centiloid处2.0 Centiloid。
  • 高分辨率下100 Centiloid的[11C]PiB扫描在中、低分辨率下分别量化为94.2与84.9 Centiloid。

核心结论

  • 在最小所需校准数据集下仍可获得较准确的SUV比值-to-Centiloid转换方程用于level 2分析。
  • 增加cAD参与者数量可降低高Centiloid值处的误差,而增加Aβ阴性参与者影响很小。
  • 图像分辨率显著影响高阳性扫描的Centiloid值,解读不同设置采集的数据时需考虑。
  • 在判断Aβ阳性的常用界值25 Centiloid附近,误差仍很小。

研究设计与样本

  • 分析200例临床诊断阿尔茨海默病(cAD)与114例Aβ阴性参与者的[11C]PiB扫描,采用标准Centiloid流程与基于MRI的非标准流程处理。
  • 将数据分为训练集与测试集(各n=157),在含10–30例Aβ阴性者与15–50例cAD参与者的子样本中比较转换方程。
  • 将[11C]PiB图像及604例[18F]florbetaben、538例[18F]florbetapir图像从高分辨率(6/7 mm3)降至中(8 mm3)、低(10 mm3)分辨率并比较Centiloid。
  • 使用rPOP与CapAIBL两个仅PET处理流程探索PET空间分辨率在不同流程中的影响。

主要发现

  • 15例cAD与10例Aβ阴性者的最小样本下,转换误差在25 Centiloid处为1.7 Centiloid、100 Centiloid处为3.4 Centiloid。
  • 纳入50例cAD与30例Aβ阴性者后,误差降至25 Centiloid处1.0 Centiloid、100 Centiloid处2.0 Centiloid。
  • 高分辨率下估计为100 Centiloid的[11C]PiB扫描,中、低分辨率下分别量化为94.2与84.9 Centiloid。
  • 高分辨率下为25 Centiloid的[11C]PiB扫描,中、低分辨率下分别降至23.5与20.6 Centiloid。
  • [18F]florbetaben与[18F]florbetapir扫描观察到类似趋势。

关键数值与推荐

  • 最小所需数据集为15例cAD与10例Aβ阴性参与者,对应25 Centiloid处误差1.7 Centiloid、100 Centiloid处3.4 Centiloid。
  • 50例cAD与30例Aβ阴性参与者时,25 Centiloid处误差1.0 Centiloid、100 Centiloid处2.0 Centiloid。
  • 高分辨率下100 Centiloid的[11C]PiB扫描在中、低分辨率下分别为94.2与84.9 Centiloid。
  • 高分辨率下25 Centiloid的[11C]PiB扫描在中、低分辨率下分别为23.5与20.6 Centiloid。
  • 25 Centiloid为判定Aβ阳性的典型界值,该处误差仍很小。

临床怎么用

  • 建立或验证SUV比值-to-Centiloid转换方程时,校准样本可参考至少15例cAD与10例Aβ阴性者的最低要求。
  • 若关注高Centiloid值区间,应适当增加cAD参与者以降低转换误差。
  • 比较不同分辨率或不同采集设置获得的Centiloid数据时,需考虑分辨率带来的系统性差异,尤其是高阳性扫描。
  • 在25 Centiloid界值附近判读Aβ阳性时,分辨率与样本量所致误差相对较小。

局限性

  • 原文摘要未报告研究的局限性描述。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

As Centiloids are increasingly used in trials and clinical settings to quantify amyloid-β (Aβ) PET, better characterization of sources of measurement error is essential. We examined 2 potential factors driving it: variability in the estimated coefficients in the SUV ratio-to-Centiloid conversion equation related to random sampling of the calibration dataset and PET image resolution. Methods: First, we analyzed [11C]PiB scans in 200 participants with a clinical diagnosis of Alzheimer disease (cAD) and 114 Aβ-negative participants. PET scans were processed using the standard Centiloid pipeline and a nonstandard MRI-based pipeline (native space, cerebellar cortex as reference). We split data into training and test datasets (n = 157 each) to compare conversion equations in subsamples with an n of 10-30 Aβ-negative and 15-50 cAD participants. Second, all [11C]PiB images, along with 604 [18F]florbetaben and 538 [18F]florbetapir images, were reduced from high (6/7 mm3) to medium (8 mm3) and low (10 mm3) resolution and resulting Centiloids were compared between resolutions. rPOP and CapAIBL, 2 PET-only processing pipelines, were used to explore the effects of the PET spatial resolution across different pipelines. Results: In the smallest required sample of 15 cAD and 10 Aβ-negative participants, conversion error was 1.7 Centiloids at 25 Centiloids and 3.4 Centiloids at 100 Centiloids. Error decreased to 1.0 Centiloid at 25 Centiloids and 2.0 Centiloids at 100 Centiloids, when including 50 cAD and 30 Aβ-negative participants. Lower image resolution was associated with a systematic difference in Centiloids, especially in highly positive [11C]PiB scans: a scan estimated as 100 Centiloids in high resolution was quantified as 94.2 Centiloids and 84.9 Centiloids at medium and low resolution. When a [11C]PiB scan was quantified as 25 Centiloids in its high resolution, lowering its resolution resulted in reduced values of 23.5 Centiloids and 20.6 Centiloids for medium and low resolution, respectively. Similar trends were observed for [18F]florbetaben and [18F]florbetapir scans. Conclusion: A relatively accurate SUV ratio-to-Centiloid conversion equation for level 2 analyses can still be achieved with a minimally required datasets. Increasing the number of cAD participants reduced error at higher values, whereas adding Aβ-negative participants had little effect. Image resolution significantly impacts Centiloids in highly positive scans and should be considered when interpreting data acquired with different settings. Errors remain minimal at 25 Centiloids, the typical cutoff for determining Aβ positivity.

来源:J Nucl Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Zhang J, Soleimani-Meigooni DN, Koeppe R, et al. Exploring Centiloid Robustness: Impact of Sample Size and Image Resolution on Centiloid Conversion Accuracy. J Nucl Med. 2025. PMID: 41130790. doi:10.2967/jnumed.125.270607

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。